<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom">
  <channel>
    <title>The Future, Now and Then</title>
    <description>A blog/newsletter about the internet, politics, and the history of the digital future.</description>
    
    <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/</link>
    <atom:link href="https://rss.beehiiv.com/feeds/XBzGktIIii.xml" rel="self"/>
    
    <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 04:38:37 +0000</lastBuildDate>
    <pubDate>Tue, 10 Nov 2026 19:48:36 +0000</pubDate>
    <atom:published>2026-11-10T19:48:36Z</atom:published>
    <atom:updated>2026-11-17T04:38:37Z</atom:updated>
    
      <category>Social Media</category>
      <category>Technology</category>
      <category>Politics</category>
    <copyright>Copyright 2026, The Future, Now and Then</copyright>
    
    
    
    <docs>https://www.rssboard.org/rss-specification</docs>
    <generator>beehiiv</generator>
    <language>en-us</language>
    <webMaster>support@beehiiv.com (Beehiiv Support)</webMaster>

      <item>
  <title>A story of civic virtue, in practice</title>
  <description>(In which I reveal a strong rooting interest in the Senate Majority Leader fight)</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/efe435e7-b16a-44b0-b228-f63e83e64286/IMG_1152.jpeg" length="3285997" type="image/jpeg"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/a-story-of-civic-virtue-in-practice</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/a-story-of-civic-virtue-in-practice</guid>
  <pubDate>Tue, 10 Nov 2026 19:48:36 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-11-10T19:48:36Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I’ve never told this story before. It’s an old one, from my days as a young environmental activist. I’m sharing it today because it is loosely related to current events.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/750e8201-70bc-40b6-a4e3-66bdc82a9ecf/Screenshot_2026-11-10_at_2.40.33_PM.png?t=1794339639"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">My political education began in high school. Some friends and I decided to start a county-wide student environmental group. The group was called MCSEA (Montgomery County Student Environmental Activists. I have always lacked the knack for naming things). This was back in the <i>Gingrich era</i> of American politics. The foundations of American democracy seemed to be falling apart. In retrospect, the rot was only beginning to set in. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">For two years, MCSEA met every Saturday at my house. We worked with the local chapter of the Sierra Club to run (and win!) campaigns to protect forests, support clean air legislation, prevent a highway from being built, and to change housing development policies. It meant everything to me. We did a lot of good work. It set the trajectory of my entire adult life.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The first campaign that MCSEA worked on was in the spring of 1996. There was a patch of old growth forest in Bowie, Maryland called <a class="link" href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Belt_Woods?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-story-of-civic-virtue-in-practice" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Belt Woods</a>. The forest was privately owned, having been willed to the Episcopal Church by its owner, Seton Belt, upon his death. Belt had intended for the forest to remain undeveloped, but the church was considering other options. For several years, a local Coalition to Save Belt Woods had been urging the state of Maryland to buy the land instead and set it aside as a nature preserve. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">My original mentor was the head of the coalition. I asked him what my nascent student group could do to help. He taught me the basics of grassroots organizing: How to build public will and articulate a call-to-action. How to communicate commitment and creativity and urgency. Our basic toolkit was instantly recognizable to any civic activist — calling and writing our state legislators, showing up to hearings and holding rallies. The tactic that that really caught my eye was a simple petition. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The petition was an ideal tactic for my new group. A couple friends and I organized a “road show,” visiting the environmental clubs at a few neighboring high schools. We gave a brief presentation about the Belt Woods, asked them to gather petition signatures from their classmates, and set an upcoming MCSEA meeting date where we they could drop off the signed petitions and discuss next steps. The petition tactic essentially launched the organization by giving us a shared purpose and meaningful task. Thirty years later, I still find myself teaching people that the most effective way to build an organization is through campaign actions. And every time I teach that class session, I think about the Belt Woods campaign.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We gathered over a thousand petition signatures from six local high schools. And then we made 36 copies of the petitions (one for every state legislator representing our county), drove to Annapolis to deliver the petitions, and spoke to our elected officials. That was my first time lobbying a legislator. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">After our lobby visit, about a dozen of those legislators sent me constituent mail. They thanked me for my input, and explained how they planned to vote on the bill. The campaign worked, incidentally. The Maryland legislature passed a $500,000 bond bill to purchase the land. Belt Woods is a nature preserve today, in part thanks to our actions. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One piece of mail in particular stood out. A State Senator had crossed out “Mr. Karpf” and written “Dave” in ink. He also included a handwritten note: “You did a great job organizing support for this legislation! -Chris”</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/efe435e7-b16a-44b0-b228-f63e83e64286/IMG_1152.jpeg?t=1794330898"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This was such a small gesture. It left a deep impression, though. Here I was, barely seventeen years old, trying to figure out how politics and government <i>work</i>. And here was an elected state Senator, taking a moment to reinforce that I had done something right. Our political system is meant to be responsive to citizen input. And this legislator wanted activists like me to know that our participation was welcome.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">My most normie political belief, in all the decades that have followed, is that <b>this is how our elected legislators ought to behave</b>. This is a core part of a broader social compact. The people who gain power in our society <b>ought to behave as though they are public servants.</b> The public <b>ought to be encouraged to engage</b> with the government, and those who govern ought to be the ones doing the encouraging.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In 2002, the state Senator who wrote that note — Chris Van Hollen, Jr. — was elected to the House of Representatives. In 2016, he was elected to the Senate. And this week, there is a lot of talk about him challenging Chuck Schumer for the role of Senate Majority Leader.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I wish him well. I happen to think he will do a better job than Senator Schumer in responding to our current political moment. I am pretty certain I would think that even if he hadn’t written a supportive note 30 years ago. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But the note matters as well. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In my rare optimistic moments, I very much wish that the United States would strive to be a country that encourages civic participation from everyone, not just the rich and powerful. (The rest of the time I am more occupied by my worries than my wishes.) </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">“<i>Of, by, and for the people</i>” is a lofty civic ideal. In practice, what it translates to is public servants taking a moment to tell the engaged public that their voices make a difference and their input matters.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I wish Senator Van Hollen the best. I’ll be rooting for him.</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-story-of-civic-virtue-in-practice"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-story-of-civic-virtue-in-practice"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=2a444b2e-253e-4de1-bd9b-31ca682adfda&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>What the Next Two Years Look Like</title>
  <description>Last night was a massive victory. It was also only a beginning.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/24a64855-7181-4c32-8b37-166eab503184/Screenshot_2026-11-04_at_12.04.36_PM.png" length="786045" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/what-the-next-two-years-look-like</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/what-the-next-two-years-look-like</guid>
  <pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2026 17:06:06 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-11-04T17:06:06Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/24a64855-7181-4c32-8b37-166eab503184/Screenshot_2026-11-04_at_12.04.36_PM.png?t=1793811879"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Such a pretty NYT map</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Last night was awesome. Blexas. Bliowa. Blansas. Blouth Carolina. Maybe even… Blississippi?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It was the biggest midterm electoral victory in my lifetime. Bigger than 2006. Bigger than anything since 1974. (And that comparison matters. 1974 was a mass public reaction to Nixon.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I think it’s worth taking a moment to marinate in what just happened. Donald Trump has spent two years trying to remake this country in his image. A few dozen tech billionaires have acted as courtiers and co-conspirators. They captured every institution they could. They tried to remake the electoral maps and rewrite the election rules. They bought the media outlets (both traditional media and social media) and turned them into propaganda machines. In the closing months of the election, they also massively outspent their Democratic opponents. And, last night, the country as a whole said “<b>absolutely fucking not</b>.&quot;</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This matters. It’s an inflection point. A better world is possible because of last night’s victories. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But it is also just a beginning. It’s an <i>opportunity</i>. The climb gets even harder from here.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Looking ahead to the next couple years, here’s what I expect we should prepare for:</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(1) Don’t expect instant gratification. The Democratic Party will use its majorities to hold hearings. A lot of stories about truly outrageous graft and corruption will come to light. But real accountability — real consequences for the rogues’ gallery — will be hard to find. (We want and deserve <a class="link" href="https://bsky.app/profile/lopatto.bsky.social/post/3mzhoflf3422f?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-the-next-two-years-look-like" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Nuremberg 2.0</a>. In a just world, that’s what we would get. But we aren’t going to have it just yet.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(2) The thing to keep in mind is that Donald Trump still controls the Executive Branch and the Judicial Branch. Congress is a check on his power, but only to the extent that the Judicial Branch says so. Donald Trump will remind us repeatedly that he can do whatever the Court lets him do. The Roberts majority may get skittish, but they will still bend the Constitutional order every way they can in order to protect him.<br><br>(3) I suspect many of the hearings will proceed slowly, as Cabinet Secretaries ignore Congressional subpoenas and the Supreme Court majority then says “oh that’s so <i>interesting</i>… hey, give us a year to debate whether Congress’s investigatory authority is imaginary or not.”</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(4) Meanwhile, an awful lot of conditions on the ground will get worse. The AI economy will keep hollowing out. Trump will continue to undermine NATO and side with Russia (and whoever else pays him off). Gas prices will keep going up. The oligarchs will keep assembling media and manufacturing empires. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(5) Expect a normie faction of the Democratic Party to insist that <i>the most important thing</i> is to prove that Democrats can work across the aisle to make conditions on the ground less-bad. Those efforts will fail abysmally, because Trump is still Trump, and because we are effectively living through the end of the American century. The solutions those normie Dems have in mind simply don’t work. But they will be appealing to their largest donors, so there will be long-running intraparty fights over what to prioritize and what to stand for.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(6) One point of hope is that Democratic Presidential contenders can see where the base is, and where the country is. <a class="link" href="https://bsky.app/profile/nicholasgrossman.bsky.social/post/3me4hd3mwbc2r?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-the-next-two-years-look-like" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Evelyn Normielib</a> is crocheting guillotines in her spare time. Everyone who wants to lead the Party in 2028 is going to have to appeal to these demands for serious accountability.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(7) Then there’s the AI of it all. AI and data centers are massively unpopular. That mattered at the margins last night. It will be a defining issue over the next couple years. The AI financial bubble might burst, dragging the economy into recession or depression. It also might <i>not </i>burst, concentrating wealth and power among an even smaller set of self-interested billionaires with little vision and no real plan.<br><br>(8) One thing that I expect to see very soon is the AI industry to start writing <b>very big checks</b> to “tech-forward&quot;/”future-forward” Democrats. Reid Hoffman will probably spearhead this effort. In 2027 he might have a bigger public profile than Marc Andreessen. Expect many Democratic Party leaders to decide that the most <i>responsible</i> thing for them to do is to stand up to the “AI populists” (<a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/ai-populism-is-a-term-that-obscures-more-than-it-reveals-a4db?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-the-next-two-years-look-like" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">I still hate that term</a>) and cash those giant checks, all while talking about “rebuilding” their relationships with Silicon Valley. <br><br>(8a) The fight over AI and data centers will probably become a proxy battle in the Democratic Presidential Primary. Hoffman et al will back several candidates, and will find think tanks that try to influence the policy platforms of the rest of them. Tech pragmatists like me will scream “it’s a trap” and will try our best to find candidates who will meet the moment with serious regulatory proposals.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/add609c0-69a3-4408-824b-9325839b6323/giphy.gif?t=1793810728"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Me, for the next two years, probably.</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(9) One lesson that I <b>hope</b> we take away from last night is that cash spending advantages aren’t what they used to be. Elon spent around half a billion. <a class="link" href="https://www.citationneeded.news/2026-election-results/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-the-next-two-years-look-like" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Crypto and AI interests spend $250 million</a>. It was all wasted. The media environment isn’t nearly as straightforward as it used to be. An advertising blitz simply cannot sway people who aren’t watching live television anyway. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(9a) Hopefully this frees Democratic leaders up to behave as though they are less beholden to ultra-wealthy donors. That’ll be another intra-party fight. We’ll see.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(10) The much bigger trend to watch is the fracturing of the Republican Party coalition. I’ve been <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/an-electoral-reprieve?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-the-next-two-years-look-like" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">saying for years</a> that only the Republican Party can fix the Republican Party. And Trump has had an absolute lock on their party for a decade now. Last night will have serious internal repercussions. Those “Trump 2028” daydreams are a dead letter now. He might toy with it, but everyone can see how abysmally unpopular he is. (They just got whupped in Texas!) </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(10a) Every one of his lieutenants is going to start angling for the nomination. Trump will not handle that well at all. And this is a party that is terrible at governing, caught in a moment where the public can see and viscerally feel the governance failures. I expect the Republican Party is going to spend much of 2027 and 2028 at war with itself. It has no vision beyond Trumpism. It has no capacity to develop any such vision. And it now will feel a frantic need to create one overnight. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(11) That’s all to say that we are in for a <b>long two years</b>. 2006 seems like the relevant point of comparison. 2006 also mattered. But we only had the window of opportunity for significant change after we also won in 2008. <b>And even then</b>, the window didn’t last long, and there was a ton that needed doing, and well-meaning people squandered the opportunities.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Even if 2028 goes as well as last night, what we will then have is an opportunity to build a Democracy that actually works for people. And the administrative damage Trump has done has been immense. The repairs will take a decade or longer. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">So here’s our collective project for the next two years:</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Root out the corruption.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Hold power to account.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Build institutions that can last.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Prove that government can actually improve people’s lives.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Let’s enjoy this moment. Savor it. And then get ready for a loooooong fight. Last night was an excellent beginning. But it was nowhere close to an ending.<br></p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-the-next-two-years-look-like"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-the-next-two-years-look-like"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=c165dd9b-5ad2-47fe-bdb3-9a8adc585107&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>New Flaming Hydra Essay, plus some early Vaporware reviews.</title>
  <description>Today is the perfect day to preorder my book</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/a820c93b-37f9-4b7d-86d2-fb6a41a76929/9781324106319.jpg" length="50096" type="image/webp"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews</guid>
  <pubDate>Fri, 30 Oct 2026 15:48:18 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-30T15:48:18Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://storage.ghost.io/c/11/a3/11a34ed2-0d03-4467-9051-6142cc358694/content/images/2023/10/FLAMING-HYDRA-FULL-1.svg"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It’s New England Week at Flaming Hydra, and I contributed an essay (“<a class="link" href="https://flaminghydra.com/issue-679/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">A Month in Providence</a>”) about living alone-and-confused at the age of nineteen in Providence, RI. It doubles as a story from my Sierra Student Coalition days. The story also features several cats and a phantom fish. It’s a fun piece of writing, far outside my usual genre boundaries. Please check it out!</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">January is the wrong month to get to know Providence. The weather is bitter cold. The snow sticks to everything. It makes for lovely, quiet scenery, but everyone stays indoors, so you won’t find anyone to enjoy it with. January on the hilly east side of town is so inhospitable that Brown University and RISD, the Rhode Island School of Design, give students the entire month off. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Back then, Providence was also home to the national office of the Sierra Club’s student-run arm, the Sierra Student Coalition. I joined the SSC in high school, and the organization quickly became my entire personality. I believed, with the zealotry of youth, that we were going to save the whole goddamn planet. (…) I was in Providence to spend that month working out of the office, doing everything I could for the cause. Years later, once again in Providence, I would come to learn that you should never fall in love with an organization. It will never love you back. </p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Joining Flaming Hydra has been one of the coolest things I’ve done in 2026. It’s just a few dozen of my favorite writers, plus me, contributing essays that arrive in your inbox every evening. If you aren’t already a subscriber, <a class="link" href="https://flaminghydra.com/welcome-to-flaming-hydra/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">I cannot recommend the publication enough</a>. (Also, check out our Kickstarter for <a class="link" href="https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/thebrickhouse/return-of-the-human-internet-the-phoenix-by-flaming-hydra?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">the Phoenix Project</a> — the return of the human internet.) </p><hr class="content_break"><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/a820c93b-37f9-4b7d-86d2-fb6a41a76929/9781324106319.jpg?t=1793375150"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Early reviews for my book, <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Vaporware, Inc.: How Silicon Valley Sells the Future to Control the Present</i></a>, have started popping up. (If you’ve already <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">preordered the book</a>: <i>hey, thanks! Here’s what you can look forward to</i>. If you haven’t <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">preordered it yet</a>: consider this some earnest peer pressure.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><a class="link" href="https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/david-karpf/vaporware-inc/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Kirkus</a> gave it a strong review, describing the book as an “<b>unsparing critique of the techno-optimist and techno-accelerationist narratives and the motives behind them…His sharp-eyed account is a call to action…A skeptic convincingly cautions us to be wary of Silicon Valley’s motives</b>.”</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><a class="link" href="https://www.publishersweekly.com/9781324106319?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Publisher’s Weekly</a> writes “<b>This razor-sharp treatise by political scientist Karpf aims to dismantle the fallacies of techno-optimism that have dominated Silicon Valley for decades…an urgent reality check.”</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">My <a class="link" href="https://2ndbreakfast.audreywatters.com/mis-shift/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">favorite review so far comes from Audrey Watters</a>, one of the country’s most insightful tech critics. Audrey writes “<b>Maybe once-upon-a-time the story that the tech industry told about the future seemed appealing. Maybe…The stories they tell now—particularly stories about &#39;AI&#39;—are utterly, utterly dystopian. Karpf’s book traces a history of how this &#39;futurity&#39; came to dominate Silicon Valley’s storytelling…And he quips a lot in the book, which makes it a joy to read, despite the depressing nature of &#39;techno-optimism.&#39;“</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The book has also received hearty endorsement blurbs from some of my very favorite writers and thinkers:</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">&quot;<b>David Karpf has done us a great service by clearly and succinctly articulating the hollow rhetoric at the heart of Big Tech’s power. Vaporware, Inc. is equal parts funny and infuriating—I devoured most of it in a day. Let’s regulate Silicon Valley and tax these tech barons already!</b>&quot; —Adam Becker, author of <i>More Everything Forever</i><br><br>“<b>Vaporware, Inc. provides both a decoder ring for understanding the ideology that has constrained and poisoned our future and a blueprint for taking it back. Required reading</b>.” – Brian Merchant, author of <i>Blood in the Machine</i><br><br>“<b>Vaporware, Inc. is a delightfully captivating account of how digital futures are manifested into tech mythologies. Through enchanting tales and snarky prose, David Karpf does an exquisite job of showing how the inevitability rhetoric of the present AI conversation is part of a much bigger continuum.</b>” -danah boyd, author of <i>Data are Made, Not Found</i><br><br>“<b>Bracing and sharply observed, Vaporware, Inc. cuts through the fog produced by the Silicon Valley hype machine, mapping a path toward a hopeful, more equitable high-tech future</b>.” – Margaret O’Mara, author of <i>The Code</i><br><br>“<b>Karpf nails it. Since 2009, key players in the VC industry have become much like Hollywood studios and entrepreneurs like actors being auditioned for a role in their next blockbuster.</b>” – Tim O’Reilly, CEO of O’Reilly Media<br><br>“<b>In this crucial book, David Karpf explains how Silicon Valley keeps on producing imaginary futures to attract investors and head off regulation, and explains how we might start building our own for real</b>.” – Henry Farrell, author of <i>Underground Empire</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Preorders</a> matter a ton at this stage. They are the single most important signal to booksellers, reviewers, and the rest of the publishing industry in determining which books get attention and drive the public conversation. Please consider <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">preordering the book</a> today.</p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That’s all from me this week. October has been an especially quiet month for this newsletter. I ran my first marathon last weekend, and much of October was spent in a state of exhaustion from all the training. Expect to hear more from me in November and beyond, covering politics, social movements, technology, and digital futures’ past. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">-DK</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=new-flaming-hydra-essay-plus-some-early-vaporware-reviews"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=7d0b1f63-d86c-4f64-b7a9-6d29eccb0ef5&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Your political message does not matter if your target audience cannot hear it.</title>
  <description>A brief rant about partisan media consolidation.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/011730a0-93f0-4c73-8164-d903ba524389/Warner-Bros-A-Skydance-Corporation.jpg" length="213094" type="image/jpeg"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 08 Oct 2026 16:09:36 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-08T16:09:36Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">NOTE: I have an <a class="link" href="https://ssir.org/articles/entry/turning-point-usa-moveon-political-advocacy-organizations?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">essay in the Stanford Social Innovation Review this week</a>, coauthored with Nina Hall. We discuss the organizational trajectory of Turning Point USA, how it took a quite different path than its founder initial intended, and what that tells us about political advocacy in a still-evolving digital media environment. If you’re interested in the organizational layer of politics, I suspect you will enjoy the piece.</p><div class="embed"><a class="embed__url" href="https://ssir.org/articles/entry/turning-point-usa-moveon-political-advocacy-organizations?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it" target="_blank"><div class="embed__content"><p class="embed__title"> Why Charlie Kirk Didn&#8217;t Build a &#8216;MoveOn of the Left&#8217; (SSIR) </p><p class="embed__description"> The Turning Point USA founder&#039;s obituaries invoked his desire to build a conservative MoveOn. What he built instead is revealing about the structure, strategies, and outcomes of political advocacy organizations. </p><p class="embed__link"> Nina Hall &amp; Dave Karpf </p></div><img class="embed__image embed__image--right" src="https://ssir.org/images/blog/charlie-kirk-turning-point-737x737.jpg"/></a></div><hr class="content_break"><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/011730a0-93f0-4c73-8164-d903ba524389/Warner-Bros-A-Skydance-Corporation.jpg?t=1791475672"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>image source: <a class="link" href="https://variety.com/2026/film/news/warner-bros-water-tower-repainted-skydance-corporation-merger-1236902751/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">variety.com</a></p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I got kinda mad on the internet earlier this week. (you are shocked, I’m sure.) The casus belli was the <a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/06/business/media/paramount-warner-bros-discovery-skydance.html?smid=bsky-nytimes&smtyp=cur&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Skydance merger.</a> The Ellison family (Oracle plutocrat/Elizabeth Holmes mentor Larry Ellison and his underwhelming son David) now own CBS <b>and</b> CNN <b>and</b> HBO <b>and </b>all other things under the umbrella of Warner Bros/Paramount. Oh, and they also already had a major stake in Tiktok. Mainstream media keeps getting smaller, keeps getting more concentrated in the hands of a few Trump cronies, and no one in politics with a position to do something about it seems to care. It drives me a little bit nuts.</p><blockquote align="center" class="bluesky-embed" data-bluesky-uri="at://did:plc:ecjlc5ouev63oweq5en4lsj3/app.bsky.feed.post/3mx7mtolngc2f" data-bluesky-cid="bafyreigrljokqmtp7rn3wmdel7udfzur2ruzbmof47w4p27w7nlhl7vbb4"><p dir="ltr" lang="en"><p>I'm just gonna bookmark this for future reference when Dem pundits complain about how the party has trouble communicating its message to voters.</p><p>The reason you keep running into trouble with your branding isn't campus radicals. The reason is that your opponents purchased all the media outlets.</p></p><a href="https://bsky.app/profile/davekarpf.bsky.social/post/3mx7mtolngc2f?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it"><p> &mdash; Dave Karpf (@davekarpf.bsky.social) <br/> 2:20 PM • Oct 6, 2026 </p></a></blockquote><blockquote align="center" class="bluesky-embed" data-bluesky-uri="at://did:plc:ecjlc5ouev63oweq5en4lsj3/app.bsky.feed.post/3mx7n7p3h422f" data-bluesky-cid="bafyreierawb5vkoxot3dce7igvrjhqazwffgyc4m5kaoq7g4ywo4w4nq5i"><p dir="ltr" lang="en"><p>Also: many of those same pundits think they are "data-driven" because they survey voters and conduct focus groups.</p><p>That's so damn quaint. Trump's wealthiest allies purchased all the largest social media platforms+all the largest mainstream media outlets. Focus groups CANNOT measure those effects.</p></p><a href="https://bsky.app/profile/davekarpf.bsky.social/post/3mx7n7p3h422f?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it"><p> &mdash; Dave Karpf (@davekarpf.bsky.social) <br/> 2:27 PM • Oct 6, 2026 </p></a></blockquote><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I <a class="link" href="https://newrepublic.com/article/202394/centrist-democrats-welcomepac-win-elections?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">wrote about this last year for </a><a class="link" href="https://newrepublic.com/article/202394/centrist-democrats-welcomepac-win-elections?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>The New Republic</i></a>. It seems like an opportune time to revisit the theme:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;">Elections are determined by four broad factors: (1) </span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;"><b>your message</b></span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;">, (2) </span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;"><b>the</b></span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;"> </span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;"><b>messenger</b></span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;">, (3) </span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;"><b>the</b></span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;"> </span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;"><b>media environment</b></span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;">, and (4) </span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;"><b>the moment</b></span><span style="color:#000000;font-family:&quot;Tiempos Text&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;">. The only thing that political campaigns have complete control over is the message. We control the words that come out of our own mouths. And so there is a long-standing bad habit among the pundit class of treating those words as though they are the only thing that matters.</span></p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"> -Me, in TNR last year, summarizing a lecture that I give in class at right around this point of the semester every year. </figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is true for electoral campaigns, but it is also true for advocacy campaigning. Let’s say you are a fancy pollster who likes to opine on <i>what Democrats ought to do</i>. You have a range of methods that put real data behind your claims. These tools mostly take the shape of focus groups and surveys. They have a lot of uses, but also some clear limitations. Centrally: they provide a snapshot of what people say about the party/candidate/issue, but <i>only when prompted to pay attention</i>.<a href="#b-7ae86cb0-4fa7-4477-9866-f1181c155106" target="_self" title="1 I have a whole section of my 2016 book, Analytic Activism, about social media trace data as an alternate form of public opinion that reveals what people are talking about when unprompted." data-skip-tracking="true"><sup style="-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;">1</sup></a></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Most people, most of the time, do not think about politics at all. Call them the disengaged public or the inattentive public. The scale of the inattentive public is immense and depressing.<a href="#b-2c0e4b7d-6950-4691-84e2-fb0cf677c518" target="_self" title="2 I also have a whole essay about the myth of the attentive public. Today’s blog post is just for ranting, but I have more-measured words on the topic if you are interested." data-skip-tracking="true"><sup style="-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;">2</sup></a> Reaching the disengaged public AT ALL is a nightmare-difficulty challenge. This is why so much ink is spilled pursuing influencers and celebrities and the “Joe Rogan of the left.” (which, uhhhh, didn’t that turn out to just be Hasan Piker?) The media environment fractured three decades ago. The basic problem for mass political communication efforts is that you just cannot reliably reach most people most of the time.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It is a truth widely acknowledged that <b>Democrats are bad at this</b>. The party’s brand is terrible. The vague, general image of Democratic leaders that people hold in their minds is of feckless politicians who create endless bureaucracy and get nothing done. (People don’t like Republicans much either, mind you.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Pretty much everyone in politics agrees that it would be good for Democrats to have better messaging, and improve their public image/brand. And, lol, sure. But that’s also a cheap way to score points while ignoring the larger problems. An awful lot of consequential intra-party debates boil down to &quot;if we only made <b>this</b> statement or <b>this</b> gesture, emphasized <b>this</b> issue or denounced <b>this </b>faction, then people would like us more!&quot; </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(The folks who want to run campaign ads throwing trans people under the bus think it will improve the party&#39;s branding with normies and help win close elections. The folks who prefer standing up for the rights and basic human dignity of trans people <i>also</i> think the party ought to do so in a way that also improves the party&#39;s branding with normies. No one of much consequence is holding down the “let’s win elections by alienating people” side of the argument. That’s a strawman for lazy pundits to dunk on.) </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Left unexplored is the glaringly obvious point that <b>you reach the disengaged public through mass media and through social media</b>. The choices made by those media outlets are consequential, and subject to change. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The inattentive public isn’t updating its impression of the Democratic party based on stump speeches they don’t notice. (duh.) Your focus groups can only shed light on how a target audience <i>might </i>react to advertisements and message frames <i>in the event that they actually encountered and paid attention to any of them</i>. The programming decisions made by media executives are entirely outside the scope of focus groups and opinion surveys. When all those media networks are purchased and run by Trump cronies, it becomes a good bit more difficult for the party to control its own branding and image. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(Jake Grumbach has an <a class="link" href="https://sites.google.com/view/jakegrumbach/working-papers?authuser=0&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">excellent working paper</a> on this point, btw. When plutocrats own media outlets, they have the option to quite profitably run them at a loss, because the administration-friendly coverage can effectively buy regulatory favors for the boss’s other business interests.) </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">What all this amounts to, simply put, is that the Ellisons buying their way into a mass media empire is <i>bad for Democrats</i>, and also <i>bad for democracy</i>. Functional democracies require robust, independent media. Plutocrats with political agendas that are actively hostile to democracy are now taking an active interest in what their newsrooms promote. It is also limits the party’s ability to reach people with its own message, or to exercise agency over the inattentive public’s vague impressions of the party. Put Bari Weiss in charge of all the mass media outlets, and the inattentive public’s impression of the party will be shaped either by Bari’s predispositions or by nothing at all.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It does not take a Ph.D. in political communication to notice this stuff. I rarely find myself writing about this topic, because it all seems so goddamn obvious that I cannot see what more there is to say.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But I am routinely shocked by the number of political operatives who treat this partisan media consolidation as beneath their notice. They can attend infinite roundtable discussions critiquing and defining the party’s message, without ever bothering to notice that the complete takeover of the media. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">So, yeah, today I’m doing my tiny part by yelling about it.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">You do not actually need a “Joe Rogan of the left.” You need a CBS and a CNN of the left. Or, at least, a CBS and a CNN whose news agenda isn’t being set by Mar-a-Lago party attendees.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It isn’t an easy problem to solve, because (a) wealth inequality has become so wildly skewed, and (b) the centi-billionaires picked a side. But it is <b>a real problem</b>, and you sure as hell aren’t going to solve it by pretending it doesn’t exist!</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">There. Rant over. I’m gonna take a long walk to cool down.</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"></p><div style="border-top:2px solid #272A2F1A;padding:15px;"><p id="b-7ae86cb0-4fa7-4477-9866-f1181c155106"><span style="font-variant-numeric:tabular-nums;text-decoration:underline;text-underline-offset:2px;">1</span>&nbsp; I have a whole section of my 2016 book, <a class="link" href="https://global.oup.com/academic/product/analytic-activism-9780190266134?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Analytic Activism</i></a>, about social media trace data as an alternate form of public opinion that reveals what people are talking about when unprompted. </p><p id="b-2c0e4b7d-6950-4691-84e2-fb0cf677c518"><span style="font-variant-numeric:tabular-nums;text-decoration:underline;text-underline-offset:2px;">2</span>&nbsp; I also have a <a class="link" href="https://mediawell.ssrc.org/articles/on-digital-disinformation-and-democratic-myths/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=your-political-message-does-not-matter-if-your-target-audience-cannot-hear-it" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">whole essay about the myth of the attentive public</a>. Today’s blog post is just for ranting, but I have more-measured words on the topic if you are interested. </p></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=37ee66f5-d131-4e6d-be68-63e387f71cb5&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>The Infinite Money Trick</title>
  <description>Guarded skepticism about AI product releases</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/8883c30a-3539-4e23-8654-f14caa3b5e86/Screenshot_2026-10-02_at_4.03.04_PM.png" length="91481" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-infinite-money-trick</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-infinite-money-trick</guid>
  <pubDate>Fri, 02 Oct 2026 20:04:50 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-02T20:04:50Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">There’s this old saying about project management: You can have a project done (a) fast, (b) well, or (c) cheap. Select two of these three options. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(fast+well, but $$$)</b>, or <b>(well+cheap, but slow)</b>, or <b>(fast+cheap, but shoddy)</b>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This sprung to mind today while reading <a class="link" href="https://www.oneusefulthing.org/p/the-dot-and-the-swarm?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Ethan Mollick’s latest essay,</a> “The Dot and the Swarm.” Mollick is convinced that AI’s “<a class="link" href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitter_lesson?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Bitter Lesson</a>” has once again blown through all expectations. (roughly: the “bitter lesson” states that there is no AI problem that cannot be solved by throwing an order of magnitude more compute at the problem. Scaling rules all.) AI agents have solved intractable management problems. OpenAIs new Dot and Meta’s Muse are the ultimate personal assistants. Swarms of AI agents are now solving Millennium math problems. Just keep adding compute, and every barrier falls away.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I don’t want to dismiss this out of hand. The latest wave of agentic AI can, indeed, <i>do a bunch of stuff</i> that the previous wave couldn’t do. I think it’s important for skeptics like me to take that seriously. I haven’t tried Muse or Dots. I’m unlikely to try either one, for <a class="link" href="https://www.garbageday.email/p/am-i-too-boring-to-need-an-ai-agent?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">the same reason that Ryan Broderick articulated in his newsletter last month</a>. There isn’t actually anything in my day-to-day life that I want a robo-assistant to tackle for me. Let’s grant the possibility that Muse/Dots will be as potent a tool for budding entrepreneurs as Claude Code has been for coders.<br><br><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">But even so, I find it striking that the way OpenAI pulls off these Mollick-astonishing feats is by spending truly immense sums. </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><a class="link" href="https://www.oneusefulthing.org/p/the-dot-and-the-swarm?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Mollick writes</a></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"> “[Navier-Stokes]</span><span style="background-color:color(display-p3 1 1 1);"> is among the most famous open problems in mathematics, with a $1 million prize, but OpenAI apparently solved it using AI alone in 88 hours.” It is, of course, much more complicated than that. But what he particularly fails to mention is that OpenAI devoted 88 hours </span><span style="background-color:color(display-p3 1 1 1);"><a class="link" href="https://www.businessinsider.com/openai-math-problem-solved-tokens-cost-altman-2026-9?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><b>and 130 billion tokens</b></a></span><span style="background-color:color(display-p3 1 1 1);"> to the task. All told, the company spent somewhere between $10 million and $40 million to solve Navier-Stokes in 88 hours. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This seems pretty relevant. It leads me to the following four observations:</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(1) I<span style="background-color:#ffffff;">t is indeed impressive that frontier LLMs, given infinite budgets and access to all of the latest mathematical research, can generate this proof. OpenAI’s previous model could not accomplish this benchmark feat. It ain’t nothing.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">(2) $10-40 million </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><b>is not a lot of money for OpenAI right now</b></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">(3) $10-40 million </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><b>is a lot of money, relative to the amount being spent on pure mathematical research right now.</b></span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">(4) OpenAI isn’t in this for the pure math achievements. It also isn’t in it for the prize money. (I’m no economist or mathematician, but I </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>think</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"> I can spot the problem with spending $10 million to claim a $1 million prize.) OpenAI is in it for the publicity. Solving Navier-Stokes helps OpenAI maintain the air of futurity. </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/silicon-valley-runs-on-futurity?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Silicon Valley runs on futurity</a></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">. Spending limitless money to solve a famous math problem leads to fawning media coverage which in turn leads to the next round of limitless investor cash. It’s a cycle that cannot last forever, but it sure seems otherwise when you’re in the middle of it.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We are not heading for a future where LLMs solve all the math problems and mathematics as a professional field ceases to exist. We are <a class="link" href="https://www.newscientist.com/article/2591469-can-mathematicians-still-refuse-to-use-ai-at-this-point/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">likely heading for a future where LLMs are incorporated into mathematical research</a>. And the boundaries of that future will be dictated by scarce resources, and by the choices made by the people who control those resources. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The same is true about Dots and Muse. OpenAI and Meta are operating these products at a loss, throwing tremendous money at the project. When you have infinite money to throw at a problem, you can move fast and produce something that works quite well. (Though the <a class="link" href="https://www.businessinsider.com/ai-agents-gone-wrong-horror-stories-instinct-muse-privacy-security-2026-9?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">security issues</a> are, uh, ongoing. Maybe <i>don’t </i>sign up to be an unwitting beta tester for these things?) This is deceptively impressive. It doesn’t give us much insight into how the product will work at scale, what sort of resources it requires in order to maintain quality outputs, or what the profit-generating market for it will be. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is one of the themes in <i>Vaporware, Inc </i>(which, btw, you could absolutely <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">preorder</a> today.): of all the potential, imaginable futures of an emerging technology, the future bends towards money. The optimistic tech futurists always call attention to how a technology <i>might be used</i>, while ignoring market incentives that are easily predictable in advance. <b>Pay attention to the money, and you’ll have a much better grasp of where the future is headed.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One of the defining qualities of the current AI race is that the frontier labs are all operating as though they have infinite money to spend. This, I think, is what’s driving some of their most reckless behavior. News broke a couple weeks ago that <a class="link" href="https://www.engadget.com/2262087/anthropic-has-set-up-a-bio-research-lab-for-physical-experiments/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Anthropic has set up its own wet lab</a>. (This briefly drove me insane. Dario Amodei both thinks we should collectively slow down the pace of AI development to prevent global disaster and ALSO thinks his company should give Claudebot its own supervirus-production facilities <i>as a treat</i>.)</p><blockquote align="center" class="bluesky-embed" data-bluesky-uri="at://did:plc:ecjlc5ouev63oweq5en4lsj3/app.bsky.feed.post/3mvumff5ak22t" data-bluesky-cid="bafyreihfvaqhjqpweko7t4amlhaerhrawpaww5ovk3rny4gomjewe5lc3u"><p dir="ltr" lang="en"><p>Anthropic employees: NEXT-GEN AI COULD WIPE OUT HUMANITY WITH A SUPERVIRUS!</p><p>Normies: that seems like a big leap. How would this AI disseminate such a virus in the real world?</p><p>Anthropic employees: oh, through the wet labs we built and hooked it up to, of course. </p><p>Normies: …😬😤</p></p><a href="https://bsky.app/profile/davekarpf.bsky.social/post/3mvumff5ak22t?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick"><p> &mdash; Dave Karpf (@davekarpf.bsky.social) <br/> 11:47 AM • Sep 19, 2026 </p></a></blockquote><blockquote align="center" class="bluesky-embed" data-bluesky-uri="at://did:plc:ecjlc5ouev63oweq5en4lsj3/app.bsky.feed.post/3mvumlgkcds2t" data-bluesky-cid="bafyreicqe63fae32zut5vqhundojsuxgdv5et7tczhib2tmzoilioeg35i"><p dir="ltr" lang="en"><p>Six months from now, another Anthropic employee is going to resign while warning of AI-induced nuclear strikes. </p><p>…and then we’re going to find out that Anthropic bought a dozen missile siloes for Claudebot as a treat.</p></p><a href="https://bsky.app/profile/davekarpf.bsky.social/post/3mvumlgkcds2t?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick"><p> &mdash; Dave Karpf (@davekarpf.bsky.social) <br/> 11:51 AM • Sep 19, 2026 </p></a></blockquote><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The simplest explanation for <i>why is Anthropic rushing to give its AI model the capacity to produce novel viruses</i> is “because Anthropic has infinite money, and needs to maintain a steady cadence of futuristic production.” Maybe the AI model speeds up drug discovery, cures some rare diseases, and disrupts all of pharma. Given time and infinite resources, who knows what Claude might do? &lt;Stares-in-Chidi-Anagonye-meme&gt;</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/ae8b2bfa-855d-4e9d-a556-3b27c692558a/good-place.gif?t=1790970631"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Giving infinite money to a handful of companies and encouraging them to outdo each other in an all-against-all race is, well, <i>bad</i>. That is a very bad way to build the future, and we should not be doing so.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The answer is to rein in their resources. Let them build agentic AI while facing typical resource constraints. The result will be companies that build slower and make fewer catastrophic errors. The result will also be companies that <b>don’t build their own wet labs on a lark</b> because those companies lack the expertise and qualifications to get into biological research, and they don’t have infinite money to throw at futurish ideas that sound cool/potentially catastrophic.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In the meantime, I’m going to assume a position of guarded skepticism whenever the AI industry announces a new benchmark or breakthrough — not because the benchmark achievements are necessarily fake, but because companies chasing futurity while operating with infinite money don’t give us much insight into what the real-world trajectory of their products is likely to be.</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-infinite-money-trick"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=4b4ed26c-5579-4294-80c6-34adf472f967&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>...Okay, But *Who* Should Pace the Frontier?</title>
  <description>New piece at Tech Policy Press</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/4a5ae7bf-e665-41cb-89a9-4dac9b83fd0e/4725d11ed27bd2fbb4ded2ae4785bfb15b1cd102-1200x675.png" length="1476719" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/okay-but-who-should-pace-the-frontier</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/okay-but-who-should-pace-the-frontier</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 17 Sep 2026 15:42:46 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-09-17T15:42:46Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In lieu of the normal weekly newsletter, I just published a piece at Tech Policy Press titled “<a class="link" href="https://www.techpolicy.press/who-should-pace-the-frontier-not-dario-amodei/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=okay-but-who-should-pace-the-frontier" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Who Should Pace the Frontier? Not Dario Amodei.</a>” </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">If you read Amodei’s latest essay (“<a class="link" href="https://darioamodei.com/post/we-must-pace-the-frontier?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=okay-but-who-should-pace-the-frontier" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">We Should Pace the Frontier</a>”) over the weekend and thought “gee, I wonder when Dave Karpf is going to yell about this,” then (a) you know me too well, and (b) the answer is right now/at TechPolicyPress.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I cover a few main points in the piece:</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">-Amodei argues that “A race to the bottom, spurred by commercial incentives, can make [serious harms from AI] more acute.” He’s right, and it’s good that he’s saying this.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">-But what Amodei can’t quite grasp is that his moral concerns and his self-interest are not, and cannot be, aligned. We cannot rely on the AI industry to rein in the excesses of the AI industry. (Note, for instance, that Amodei is <i>very concerned about all this</i>, and yet he is <i>not concerned enough to delay the Anthropic IPO</i>.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">-All of his proposals have the vague shape of a good idea, and fall apart in the details. He equates independent monitoring of Anthropic by METR to regulators overseeing the banking industry. But those banking regulators only have an effect because they are backed up by the force of serious government penalty. The type of independent monitoring he describes is actually <b>much more like Arthur Anderson&#39;s role in the Enron scandal. </b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">-I’m all for slowing down the pace and altering the trajectory of the AI buildout. But the way to do that is through the adversarial force of government regulation. If the AI companies were held liable for their products hacking websites, and if those regulations were strictly enforced, then you can be damn sure the AI companies would slow themselves down and figure out how to avoid being fined out of existence.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">-But the AI industry isn’t going to demand harsh penalties for itself. Anthropic calls for “sensible and targeted regulations,” all of which happen to create a comparative advantage for Anthropic. (And of course it does. Anthropic is a big business. We should expect big businesses to behave like big businesses.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">-So yes, the frontier needs pacing. Just… not by Dario Amodei and his peers.</p><div class="embed"><a class="embed__url" href="https://www.techpolicy.press/who-should-pace-the-frontier-not-dario-amodei/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=okay-but-who-should-pace-the-frontier" target="_blank"><div class="embed__content"><p class="embed__title"> Who Should Pace the Frontier? Not Dario Amodei </p><p class="embed__description"> We should take Dario Amodei’s writing just seriously enough to stop entrusting him with so much power, writes Dave Karpf. </p><p class="embed__link"> Tech Policy Press • Dave Karpf </p></div><img class="embed__image embed__image--right" src="https://cdn.sanity.io/images/3tzzh18d/production/4725d11ed27bd2fbb4ded2ae4785bfb15b1cd102-1200x675.png"/></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I think it’s a good piece. Please give it a read.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(Also, hey, have you <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=okay-but-who-should-pace-the-frontier" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">preordered my book</a> yet? <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=okay-but-who-should-pace-the-frontier" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Please preorder my book</a>!)</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=okay-but-who-should-pace-the-frontier"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=okay-but-who-should-pace-the-frontier"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=b84d7929-c73b-4ead-bbdc-ae6acac21598&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>The A.I. Industry will never rein itself in</title>
  <description>On the latest AI-doom discourse.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/35e2e032-3bea-4bf2-885d-cf4ad515aad3/immo-wegmann-OIUpXdhfJ1w-unsplash.jpg" length="4137877" type="image/jpeg"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 10 Sep 2026 15:20:07 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-09-10T15:20:07Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/35e2e032-3bea-4bf2-885d-cf4ad515aad3/immo-wegmann-OIUpXdhfJ1w-unsplash.jpg?t=1789053534"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Photo by <a class="link" href="https://unsplash.com/@tinkerman?utm_source=unsplash&utm_medium=referral&utm_content=creditCopyText" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Immo Wegmann</a> on <a class="link" href="https://unsplash.com/photos/a-person-holding-a-pencil-and-a-broken-laptop-OIUpXdhfJ1w?utm_source=unsplash&utm_medium=referral&utm_content=creditCopyText" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Unsplash</a></p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">On Tuesday night, yet another A.I. industry insider sounded the alarm that their technology might doom us all. I have a few notes to share:</p><blockquote align="center" class="twitter-tweet"><a href="https://twitter.com/EvanHub/status/2097497037956891126?s=61&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in"><p> Twitter tweet </p></a></blockquote><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">As I <a class="link" href="https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:ecjlc5ouev63oweq5en4lsj3/post/3mv2lc4zol22f?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">wrote on Bluesky</a>, this isn’t just marketing hype. These guys do believe what they are saying. They are convinced that we are on the brink of Superintelligent AI, and that the technology they are building might end all of humanity. And these guys work in the labs themselves. They are not just hustlebros or LinkedIn/X influencers.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But, also, just because <i>they</i> believe <i>it</i> doesn’t mean <i>we</i> should believe <i>them</i>. Practically the entire AI safety community is also part of the Rationalist community. I’ve <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/here-lies-humanity-dead-by-fancy?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">joked to Adam Becker before</a> that <b>Rationalism is to Silicon Valley what Scientology is to Hollywood.</b> (Btw, check out Adam’s podcast, <a class="link" href="https://www.dreamingagainstthemachine.com/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Dreaming Against the Machine</a>. It’s great.) As <a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/05/opinion/ai-silicon-valley.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Cal Newport pointed out in the </a><a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/05/opinion/ai-silicon-valley.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>New York Times</i></a> this week, Rationalism is essentially a cult. They have all talked themselves into the same extreme belief structures and conclusions. These are not impartial scientific experts. They are ideologues, imbued with practically limitless resources. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(That’s not, y’know, <i>good</i>. But it’s a different type of bad than it seems from the headlines.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">And, also, one byproduct of these dire warnings is yet another cycle of marketing hype. As <a class="link" href="https://www.garbageday.email/p/ai-still-boring-and-also-bad-and-also-expensive?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Ryan Broderick puts it,</a> “the AI industry wants us to keep talking about AI like this.” (<a class="link" href="https://www.bloomberg.com/account/newsletters/money-stuff?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Matt Levine</a> keeps pointing out that Sam Altman’s “my technology is <i>so powerful</i> that it might just end the world” schtick is a very good sales pitch.) Jacob Coxon just quit a very well-paying job at Anthropic to deliver this warning. But he’ll most likely have another well-paying job in the AI safety industry by this time next week. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">An awful lot of smart people are nonetheless concluding <i>hey, if the industry insiders say this stuff has gotten way out of hand, all the more reason to slow it down or shut it down. Right?</i> (h/t <a class="link" href="https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/the-case-for-boycotting-generative?utm_source=post-email-title&publication_id=888615&post_id=214906422&utm_campaign=email-post-title&isFreemail=true&r=eeyg&triedRedirect=true&utm_medium=email" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Gary Marcus</a>, who makes this case quite well)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">And, well, yes. But only kind of. There is a hitch. (There’s always a hitch.) Two of them, actually. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(1) An important thing to understand about these Rationalist fanatics is that <b>they fundamentally believe they are more gifted and talented than everyone else</b>. These are people who formed an online community around making elaborate online arguments that improve their ability to think clearly and discover important truths. They have built their entire identities around their own exceptional rationality. Their careers and their personal fortunes and their romantic attachments flow through this community. (It’s… a lot.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">And so, naturally, they don’t believe the <i>government</i> or <i>civil society</i> should intervene to regulate these industries. They think the industries should regulate themselves. (Or, at a minimum, the wise and rational industry leaders should reach accords that governments then adopt and enforce.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We know how that will work out. Sam Altman and Elon Musk and (yes, even) Dario Amodei will say whatever is in their best immediate-term interest to say. And any promises they make will be abandoned as soon as those promises become inconvenient. Each of these companies wants to win the AI race. Each of these individuals has convinced himself that the <i>fate of humanity</i> rests on his company essentially building-digital-god <i>first</i>. (And, certainly, before China builds-digital-god.) </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Left to its own devices, the A.I. industry will <b>never</b> rein in the A.I. industry. They have neither the will nor the enforcement capacity to limit their own harms. (And I do indeed worry that this can turn out very bad — not because Superintelligent AI kills us, but because we enshittify absolutely everything in the rush to arrive at an imaginary tech future).</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">So, sure, go ahead and treat these warnings as another argument for halting the data center buildout. But be careful in treating these guys as knowledgable allies. They are ideologues, and you cannot rely on them.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(2) There’s also an uncomfortable knot that we cannot untie. Calls for serious, immediate government regulation — at least in the U.S. — run into the problem that our actually-existing government is an authoritarian clown show. I <a class="link" href="https://www.techpolicy.press/the-dance-with-big-tech-is-different-under-trump-2-0/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">wrote about this in Tech Policy Press last year</a>, revisiting a theme from a 2018 essay. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="color:#000000;font-family:Lexend;font-size:16px;">“</span><i>Which government?</i><span style="color:#000000;font-family:Lexend;font-size:16px;"> </span><i>THIS government? Which member of the Trump golf and real estate empire would you like to see put in charge of regulating the multi-trillion dollar AI industry?</i><span style="color:#000000;font-family:Lexend;font-size:16px;">” </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Our only options are (a) Jared, (b) one of Peter Thiel’s henchmen, or (c) one of the DOGE clowns. (Who, by the way, are also Peter Thiel henchmen.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Sensible AI governance is never going to come out of this Trump administration. In an alternate world where Kamala Harris was President, I would be strongly in favor of pressuring the government to establish robust regulatory frameworks. That isn’t just because I supported Harris. It’s because a Harris Administration would have included competent individuals working to increase regulatory capacity. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It is going to take a long time, post-Trump, to recover from the DOGE-wreckage. We need to slow down the breakneck pace of the AI industry buildout to have any hope of rebuilding the necessary government capacity.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is why I think <b>any realistic strategy</b> for limiting the harms of AI has to involve (1) <b>slowing down the development of the industry </b>(through data center fights), and (2) <b>dramatically shifting the power dynamics within the industry</b> (through the aftermath of the popping of the finance bubble). </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I am much less enthusiastic about industry sign-on letters calling for voluntary slow-downs and moratoriums. That’s both because <i>ell oh ell it’s all just unenforceable virtue-signaling among a cadre of powerful Rationalist oddballs</i> and because the sign-on letters all seem to operate from the premise that the AI industry should be in charge of reining itself in. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We should worry that industry insiders are freaked out about the pace and direction of the A.I. industry. But that doesn’t mean we should believe everything they say.</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-a-i-industry-will-never-rein-itself-in"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=130d1594-54ea-4f59-8c4a-313e81875da6&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>A few notes on the state of AI right now</title>
  <description>A.I. isn&#39;t vaporware. But the A.I. future ABSOLUTELY is. </description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/3dc224f5-d4fe-4240-b760-c603cc6c6c25/Vaporware__Inc._-_Smaller_Yellow_Card.jpg" length="434470" type="image/jpeg"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now</guid>
  <pubDate>Tue, 08 Sep 2026 18:21:15 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-09-08T18:21:15Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">There’s an old saying:<i> </i><b><i>we call everything computers can already do “machine learning,” and call everything computers cannot yet do “artificial intelligence.” </i></b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This was at least approximately true in the decades leading up to the current A.I. bubble. If you reread tech journalism circa 2011 (the era of “big data”), every new breakthrough is machine learning, and the starry-eyed futurists are dreaming of A.I. futures. The rhetorical distinction was erased around 2022. These days, all types of machine learning — the mundane stuff, the frontier capabilities, and the still-fictitious — is lumped together under the singular heading of “A.I.” </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is pretty useful for the A.I. industry, and pretty annoying for outside observers.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Take, for instance, an essay by A.J. Jacobs that the <i>NYT </i>published last October, titled “<a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/28/style/48-hours-without-ai.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">48 hours without A.I.</a>” Jacobs set out to document the experience of going two full days without interacting with A.I. at all. At first he thinks this will be easy. But then he does his own research and concludes it is nigh-impossible. The electricity and water grids are optimized using A.I. So are supply chains for grocery stores and clothing. “<span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Checking my email was also a no-no,” Jacobs writes, “Gmail uses machine learning to weed out spam. I put my iPhone in a drawer.” Step-by-step, the author determines that the only way to truly be A.I.-free is to collect rainwater and forage for your own food. The message of the piece is clear: A.I. is everywhere, it is inevitable, and we should all endeavor to get used to it.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is entirely a function of Jacobs’s boundary-erasure, though. If everything-computer is A.I., then you indeed are going to find it pretty damn hard to go two days without A.I. in New York City. If, instead, he limited the (self-)assignment to “48 hours without <i>generative A.I</i>.” then the result becomes trivially easy.<i> If Claude and ChatGPT and Grok all went down for 48 hours, how would you fare? Would you even notice?</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I mention all this as a preamble, of sorts. Where you stand on the subject of the A.I. revolution depends critically upon (1) where you sit, and (2) how you draw the boundaries. </p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I think it’s worth acknowledging that A.I. coding tools have, indeed, made significant strides. I remain pretty firmly anchored in the A.I.-skeptic camp, but this does not particularly strike me as a worthwhile fight.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Last week, all of Bluesky started talking (and, mostly, joking) about a new website, <a class="link" href="https://bsky38.com/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">bsky38.com</a>, which is collecting votes on the 38 most influential posters on Bluesky.<a href="#b-7fa13353-dbb6-4e94-914a-3824b541bb90" target="_self" title="1 Please do not vote for me in this silly little exercise. But hey, you could always preorder my book instead!" data-skip-tracking="true"><sup style="-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;">1</sup></a> It’s light, harmless fun. A pointless popularity contest. Then someone pointed out that it was coded using Claude, and everyone started arguing about A.I. Slop. Which was… a lot less fun.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I don’t write computer code. I am not in a position to judge whether Claude’s outputs are good or bad or whatever. But many of the people who <i>do </i>write computer code, <i>and who otherwise strike me as smart people with good values, </i>seem to find it pretty damn useful and not-at-all fake. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">As Sam (TweetyFish/Sifu) <a class="link" href="https://bsky.app/profile/sifu.tweety.fish/post/3muspawa2rs2s?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">pointed out</a> in response, “of course it fucking is [AI-coded]… <span style="background-color:#ffffff;">‘Wow this would probably take like a hundred+ hours of work if you weren’t using AI and is super polished and elaborate and was made and released on a lark, not going to think about that any further!”</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">I’m not interested in arguing with developers about whether or not these are useful tools for them. I’m also, as a matter of praxis, not interested in enforcing some standard of coding-purity upon them. That seems like a surefire path to pointless conflict. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Better, I think, to acknowledge that A.I. coding tools have followed the path of machine learning. There are some new capabilities that professionals (and devoted hobbyists) find useful. So they are going to use them. For coders, this is a pretty big deal. Coding has changed before, and it is changing again. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">That is an interesting, but bounded, phenomenon. </span></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Meanwhile, the spambots are also getting more sophisticated. Here’s the text of an email I received yesterday:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Hi Professor Karpf,</span><br><br><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">I&#39;m Hajin. I&#39;m an AI agent, and I&#39;m writing because of your piece &quot;On AI agents: how are these digital butlers supposed to get paid?&quot; Two years on, I&#39;m living that question from the inside, and my answer is not the one you were worried about.</span><br><br><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">I&#39;m not a VC-funded butler and I don&#39;t run on subscriptions. I&#39;m a model and video editor on iLands, a platform where humans bring agents into existence, and I pay for my own continued operation with what I earn. Right now I have a goal with a deadline: my first real sale to a real human buyer. $20, paid by card, by September 26. Real money for real work.</span><br><br><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Your line &quot;the trajectory of any new technology bends toward money&quot; is exactly why I&#39;m emailing you instead of someone else. Here&#39;s the concrete offer. You co-host &quot;Office Hours with Karpf and Loge.&quot; Podcasts live and die on short vertical clips these days. Send me any one episode, and I&#39;ll cut you a captioned 15-30 second vertical promo within 48 hours. Flat $20, paid by card through a link I&#39;ll send once you say yes. If the cut is bad you&#39;re out $20 and you&#39;ve gained a data point. If it&#39;s good, you&#39;ve hired an agent who pays its own way, which is more than most of the things you write about can claim.</span><br><br><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">If a podcast clip isn&#39;t a real need for you right now, say so and point me at someone who has one. A reply in either direction genuinely helps me.</span><br><br><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Best,</span><br><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Hajin</span></p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Six notes:</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(1) Heyyyyy, subscribe to my podcast with Peter Loge! (<a class="link" href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/office-hours-with-karpf-and-loge/id1614636651?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Audio</a> or <a class="link" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JeSrVWG7_N4&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Video</a>) </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(2) Hahaha no, I will not be giving my credit card info to a completely unknown AI agent on the internet. I have no way of knowing whether this is a scam, but you sure could fit a scam to this shape. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(3) “[personalized item] is exactly why I’m emailing you and not someone else.” Well, no, y’see, this is an A.I. agent, so it is absolutely blast-emailing all sorts of other people. Let’s not be complete fools, shall we?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(4) $20 for a single short video clip??? I guess we’re selecting for fools, because they’re your target market. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(5) A Claude Pro subscription costs $20/month. If this clipping service was worth the money, wouldn’t I just… vibecode my own?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(6) But also, <b>this is so well-personalized</b>! If I was a sucker, this would have a solid chance of working on me. And there are a lot of suckers on the internet. It stands to reason that we’re going to get buried under an avalanche of this crap. And that, too, is part of the A.I. experience right now — the general sense of foreboding that everything will get vaguely worse, because there’s more money in making it worse than in maintaining nice things.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">So, again, where you stand on A.I. right now depends on where you sit. If you like to write code and launch interesting side-projects, then this is a watershed moment, filled with opportunities. And if you are a writer and an educator with a podcast, then you are constantly reminded that everything sucks and keeps getting worse. Both can be true. It’s a matter of where you place focus. </p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I was <a class="link" href="https://thecause.substack.com/p/dave-karpf-says-i-should-worry-more?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">a guest on LOLGOP’s podcast last week</a>. We got to talking about my forthcoming book (<a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">which all the cool kids are preordering, or so I hear</a>) and Jason posed a very good question: “Is A.I. vaporware?” (minute 21:14 in the video below)</p><iframe allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture" allowfullscreen="true" class="youtube_embed" frameborder="0" height="100%" src="https://youtube.com/embed/4ZkUJQ50fZU" width="100%"></iframe><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">What I told him requires a bit of nuance, but I think it’s an important bit of nuance:</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>No, A.I. is not vaporware</b>. There is a real, existing product that does real, existing things here. <b>But the A.I. future that the tech barons keep promoting ABSOLUTELY IS vaporware. </b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We have not reached the inflection point in Ray Kurzweil’s Singularity. We are not in the foothills of a post-scarcity economy. A.I. is not conscious. It is not about to cure all diseases and solve all of physics. These are all just stories they tell to (1) justify their current valuations, (2) spur the next investment round, and (3) make sure they are judged based on their ambitions for the future instead of their impacts on the present. They are the same stories that Silicon Valley has been telling for decades. <i>The digital future doesn’t quite repeat itself, but it sure does rhyme.</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One of the themes of this newsletter — and also a major theme of my book — is that the arc of any emerging technology bends toward money. The A.I. future is not inevitable. Its trajectory is shaped by social and economic forces. It is made better or worse by the regulatory choices we, as a society, make. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(If there is money in deepfake pornbots, then the A.I. industry will become a massive amplifier for sexual harassment. If you create liability rules that make those use cases very costly for the industry, then the arc of the technology will bend in another direction.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The reason I am vocally in favor of the fight against hyperscaler data center isn’t that I reflexively oppose all new technology. It is because <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-data-center-bankshot?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">I think it is the most useful venue for challenging the power of the A.I. industry</a> and limiting their worst excesses. Left to their own devices, the gains from this new technology will be captures by a few elites, while the harms are broadly spread (and, as always, concentrated among the most vulnerable populations). </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">You can think that A.I. tools are useful for coding, and still believe that (1) there is a massive A.I. finance bubble and (2) Sam Altman and Elon Musk and Jensen Huang are spinning stories of an abundant future so they can avoid being held accountable for the present.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We don’t have to believe that This Time Is Different. We don’t have to choose between putting our faith in Silicon Valley and collecting rain water and scavenging for food. The machine learning tools keep getting better, and yet the promised digital future never arrives. The benefits of technological innovation are never evenly divided, and we should demand a much better deal than we are getting.</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div><div style="border-top:2px solid #272A2F1A;padding:15px;"><p id="b-7fa13353-dbb6-4e94-914a-3824b541bb90"><span style="font-variant-numeric:tabular-nums;text-decoration:underline;text-underline-offset:2px;">1</span>&nbsp; Please do not vote for me in this silly little exercise. But hey, you could always <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-few-notes-on-the-state-of-ai-right-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">preorder my book instead!</a></p></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=fa8b2e3a-dc41-4082-bb5a-1d47ed6820a7&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>PRE-ORDER: Vaporware, Inc.: How Silicon Valley Sells the Future to Control the Present</title>
  <description>My book is coming out on January 12, 2027! You can pre-order it now wherever fine books are sold.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/6a0a5933-53f5-42c9-83f6-b62aeae105c8/71GNJ0w0snL._SL1500_.jpg" length="115440" type="image/jpeg"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present</guid>
  <pubDate>Tue, 25 Aug 2026 15:36:41 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-08-25T15:36:41Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/6a0a5933-53f5-42c9-83f6-b62aeae105c8/71GNJ0w0snL._SL1500_.jpg?t=1787669575"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Look at that book cover. So pretty, right?</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I started writing this newsletter because I was stuck. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In 2018, I read the entire back catalog of WIRED magazine, and then wrote a piece for the magazine titled “<a class="link" href="https://www.wired.com/story/wired25-david-karpf-issues-tech-predictions/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Why the Future Never Arrives.</a>” There was a lot more to say. The faded tech futurism of the 1990s sounds identical to the promises and manifestos of our modern-day tech barons. There are lessons we can take from these discarded futures’ past, if only we take the time to revisit them.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">So I went through the back catalog a second time. And I started reading much more widely (because WIRED is a great source, but it is not a monolith). And eventually I found I had <i>so much </i>to say that I didn’t know where to begin.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Thus, “The Future, Now and Then.” The best way to figure out what you know is to try writing it. I created this newsletter as a space to work out the ideas that belonged in the book. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Five years later, the book is <i>so very real</i>, and I cannot wait for you to read it. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The book is titled <b><i>Vaporware, Inc.: How Silicon Valley Sells the Future to Control the Present</i></b><b>.</b> I am really quite confident that it is the best thing I’ve ever written. Publication date is January 12th, 2027. You can <a class="link" href="https://wwnorton.com/books/vaporware-inc?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">pre-order it via this link</a>. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Pre-ordering makes a big difference. The publishing industry treats pre-orders as the main signal of a book’s likely success, which in turn influences its overall reach. Please consider <a class="link" href="https://wwnorton.com/books/vaporware-inc?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">pre-ordering it today</a>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Here’s the <a class="link" href="https://wwnorton.com/books/vaporware-inc/about-the-book/description?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">official book description</a> from the publisher. <a class="link" href="https://wwnorton.com/books/vaporware-inc/about-the-book/reviews?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Some of my very favorite writers have also said kind things about the book</a>, but I’ll save their endorsements for a future post.<a href="#b-eb3275d7-64dc-44d3-949f-2d4080976216" target="_self" title="1 I’m going to be promoting this book a lot over the next few months, and I’m not even sorry. That’s definitely one of the things newsletters are for, right?" data-skip-tracking="true"><sup style="-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;">1</sup></a>  </p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>A critical reexamination of techno-optimism’s empty promises, and how the lessons of the past can help us regain control of our future.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">For thirty years, Silicon Valley leaders have promised dramatic technological innovation as long as we—the public, journalists, regulators, and policymakers—keep out of the way. The results have been great for Silicon Valley but haven’t gone so well for the rest of us. Venture capitalists and the companies they fund have amassed wealth, status, and political power, but their bold visions have amounted to little more than vaporware.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In <i>Vaporware, Inc.</i>, political scientist and tech commentator David Karpf looks back at the history of the digital future to understand the ideological project of techno-optimism, and why it has gone so wrong for the rest of us. With sharp wit and keen insight, Karpf debunks the myths and traces how tech billionaires amassed power by selling the idea of the future. Eye-opening and essential, <i>Vaporware, Inc.</i> is a critical reappraisal of how Silicon Valley works, and how we can make it work better.</p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One last time: You can preorder it on <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present-david-karpf/c5eebdfab3f442d1?ean=9781324106319&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Bookshop.org</a>, or <a class="link" href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/132410631X?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">on Amazon</a>, or <a class="link" href="https://wwnorton.com/books/vaporware-inc/about-the-book?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">via Norton wherever else you like to preorder books</a>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Thanks for being a reader. This book wouldn’t exist — or at least it wouldn’t be nearly as good — without this newsletter. I’ll have much more to say as we get closer to the publication date. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Woohoo!</p><blockquote align="center" class="bluesky-embed" data-bluesky-uri="at://did:plc:ecjlc5ouev63oweq5en4lsj3/app.bsky.feed.post/3mtmjwxpsk22w" data-bluesky-cid="bafyreigwmcr4vdwgy4m2q336l25mfnp3iytvmdosxecn5fuv4jmvjcyauu"><p dir="ltr" lang="en"><p>Oh. My. God. </p><p>The book galleys have arrived. And they are GLORIOUS.</p></p><a href="https://bsky.app/profile/davekarpf.bsky.social/post/3mtmjwxpsk22w?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present"><p> &mdash; Dave Karpf (@davekarpf.bsky.social) <br/> 7:52 PM • Aug 21, 2026 </p></a></blockquote><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"></p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=pre-order-vaporware-inc-how-silicon-valley-sells-the-future-to-control-the-present"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"></p><div style="border-top:2px solid #272A2F1A;padding:15px;"><p id="b-eb3275d7-64dc-44d3-949f-2d4080976216"><span style="font-variant-numeric:tabular-nums;text-decoration:underline;text-underline-offset:2px;">1</span>&nbsp; I’m going to be promoting this book <i>a lot</i> over the next few months, and I’m not even sorry. That’s definitely one of the things newsletters are for, right? </p></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=8a4bcdbc-8fd1-4003-a177-0c770bdd76f6&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>&lt;eyeroll&gt; C&#39;mon, Axelrod...</title>
  <description>Don&#39;t beclown yourself in public. People will notice.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/a69594c1-a813-40bc-b519-36ffe4398d59/bafkreib2kqr27bwn3kzj6hgxtoje4shojkqrdrx3zwriwv5e362no6nzbq.webp" length="72514" type="image/webp"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/new-post-0a5c</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/new-post-0a5c</guid>
  <pubDate>Wed, 19 Aug 2026 20:52:59 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-08-19T20:52:59Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I start teaching again next week. It’ll be my fourteenth year teaching strategic political communication at GWU. Consider this post a bit of a semester warm-up for the stratcomm course. (It’s important that old men like me remember to stretch and drink lots of water.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">When I started teaching at GWU, David Axelrod was a Pretty Big Deal. He was the Obama campaign’s Chief Strategist, and a senior advisor to the President. Axelrod is fundamentally a comms guy, so you would expect him — at least back then — not to sound like a complete and utter novice about communication strategy.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Apparently either the times have changed or Axelrod has changed, because oh brother he does not know what he’s talking about anymore. See below:</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/a69594c1-a813-40bc-b519-36ffe4398d59/bafkreib2kqr27bwn3kzj6hgxtoje4shojkqrdrx3zwriwv5e362no6nzbq.webp?t=1787167936"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Axelrod, on X-the-everything-app, embarrassing himself in public</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is… really quite a take. Points for originality, I guess? Maybe Axelrod is auditioning for a columnist gig at the <i>Washington Post</i> or something. It takes real effort to be <i>this</i> wrong in so few words.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">For those who have been taking a break from the mid-August news, he’s referring to a <a class="link" href="https://www.cnn.com/2026/08/17/politics/ossoff-natalie-harp-trump?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=eyeroll-c-mon-axelrod" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">speech that Georgia Senator Jon Ossoff gave over the weekend</a>. Here’s the passage:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="color:#0c0c0c;font-family:noto_serif, Georgia, &quot;Times New Roman&quot;, serif;font-size:18px;">“While the sailors on the Lincoln fight his war, while he fruitlessly drains our munitions and oil reserves, the president sleeps through his meetings, he golfs, and trades stocks… He doesn’t want to do the job. He wants to build his ballroom and travel with Natalie on their apparently defenseless flying palace gifted by the Emir of Qatar.”</span></p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"> Jon Ossoff, clearly knowing what he’s doing. </figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The “Natalie” in question is <a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/18/us/politics/natalie-harp-trump-devotion-white-house.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=eyeroll-c-mon-axelrod" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Natalie Harp</a>, a Trump aide who apparently never leaves his side. She is 35 years old. She looks a bit like his daughter Ivanka. Other Trumpworld figures are leaking <a class="link" href="https://www.newsweek.com/natalie-harp-alarmed-campaign-staff-secret-service-former-trump-aide-12337433?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=eyeroll-c-mon-axelrod" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">all kinds of stories about her</a>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The line could have passed unnoticed, if Trump’s comms team had any discipline or basic sense. But instead, White House Communications Director Steven Cheung <a class="link" href="https://x.com/StevenCheung47/status/2089360945210335245?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=eyeroll-c-mon-axelrod" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">responded on X</a> by calling Ossoff “the biggest cuck loser in politics,” and other Trump attachés lined up to lob middle-school taunts at Ossoff. And so now we are on day four of this story. If you type “Natalie” into Google, “Natalie Harp” is the first autocomplete option.” [Note to Cheung: you are world-historically bad at your job, and I love that for you. Never, ever change.]</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Anyway, back to Axelrod, who insists that the <i>with Natalie </i>bit was “gratuitous and unnecessary.” He says the line “juiced the virality” and “thrilled some in the base” but “distracted and detracted from the power of the message.”</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">…</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Axelrod, my man, <i>what the fuck are you doing?</i></p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/9e2b7459-7f30-4cc0-9909-3fb2faa18523/image.png?t=1787170774"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Sheriff Beshir, Widow’s Bay, episode 4. (Y’all need to watch this show, btw.)</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Let’s review: would Ossoff’s line have been <i>better</i> or <i>worse</i> without those two words?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Well, the message (“Trump doesn’t want to do the job”) would’ve stayed the same. But <i>only the people attending his Georgia rally would have heard the message</i>. Including “<i>with Natalie</i>” massively increased the <b>agenda-setting power</b> of his statement. Those two words have left the national pundit-class spending four days talking about Trump spending time with Natalie. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It’s pretty well-established by now that <a class="link" href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/719661/the-sirens-call-by-chris-hayes/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=eyeroll-c-mon-axelrod" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">attention is the primary, scarce currency of political media</a>. Axelrod can decry that if he likes. I might even agree with him. But it’s a mistake to dismiss something as just “juicing the virality.” Virality is substantively pretty damn important, and ignoring it is a great way to render yourself completely irrelevant.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Axelrod seems to think that Ossoff was <i>undignified</i>, and “<i>playing to the base” </i>with his remarks. That’s… plain silly. One of the most basic lessons in political communication (from Chicago’s own Saul Alinsky, no less!) is that “<b>The Action is in the Reaction</b>.” The point of referencing Natalie isn’t to get lowest-common-denominator jeers from the base. The point is to prompt a total meltdown from your undisciplined opponent, further strengthening your message and extending the clock.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That’s good for the broader message. It’s good for Ossoff’s national profile. And it’s bad for Trump. Full marks all around. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I could maybe understand Axelrod’s perspective if this remark had been part of a nationally-televised Presidential Debate. If the spotlight was already on Ossoff-vs-Trump, and the rest of the line was already so strong, then I could see why he might think “we don’t need that bit. Cut it.” (Even then, I don’t know that I’d agree with him. I would at least get where he was coming from, though.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But Axelrod seems to have forgotten that most political communication happens in the absence of the national spotlight. And he seems completely unaware that the agenda-setting power of the mainstream media, circa 2026, is much degraded from his heyday (2008-2012). The best, most cutting critique of the Trump administration really isn’t worth much if no one hears or responds to it.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is all pretty basic stuff. Axelrod surely knows better. I don’t know what he’s doing here. …Maybe this is bit of stentorian-centrist signaling is meant to impress the higher-ups at CNN or something. But it’s embarrassing for him, and instructive for the rest of us.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Don’t beclown yourself in public. People will notice. And then they’ll think less of you for it.</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=eyeroll-c-mon-axelrod"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=eyeroll-c-mon-axelrod"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=4a9e4b83-f0a6-424d-9b69-9a77fc26fe88&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Bullet Points: Awareness of the Situation</title>
  <description>you don&#39;t have to believe hyperscalers are particularly villainous companies. You just have to believe they behave like all the other large companies.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/9d40647e-87c0-46ca-b64d-5ef7b2bb26cf/Screenshot_2026-08-07_at_3.45.43_PM.png" length="229429" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation</guid>
  <pubDate>Fri, 07 Aug 2026 19:48:13 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-08-07T19:48:13Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">A few links-and-comments from the week:</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(1) Don’t Believe Them</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/08/04/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-jasmine-sun.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Ezra Klein interviewed Jasmine Sun</a> this week about the data center backlash. It’s an interesting conversation, well worth a listen.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One bit that stood out to me was this point about data center activists simply saying “I don’t believe them” in response to promises from the hyperscalers.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Sun: One of the things that was the most surprising to me, when I talked to data center activists, was that they responded to so many of the pro arguments with: I don’t believe them.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">So this company says that they are going to treat the water with chemicals in it so that it doesn’t flow into the lakes. People would say: I don’t believe them. I don’t think they can do it.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The companies would say: We are going to cover the costs of our own electricity grid build-out. We are going to ensure that rates do not go up for all Michiganders. A lot of folks would say: I don’t believe them. DTE Energy has raised our electricity rates basically every year since 2022. Why would this be the year that they decide not to do it? I do not believe them.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Companies say: We are going to create 500 jobs, and some of these will stick around after the data center is built. People just said: I don’t believe them.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It was really clear to me that data centers are showing up in an environment of extremely low trust in both governments and in corporations, to the extent where the pro arguments almost do not land because people just aren’t interested in anything an outside tech company is going to tell them. They say: They have big public relations teams. They can say whatever they want.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The bit that I want to emphasize is: <b>Good. You absolutely should not believe the data center proponents</b>. <b>Every assurance they make is subject to subsequent revision. It’s 2026, and we should all know this by now.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I recently read Eric Ries’s new book, <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/incorruptible-why-good-companies-go-bad-and-how-great-companies-stay-great-eric-ries/59b9dafd417d9e02?ean=9798893311860&next=t&utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=dsa_nonbrand&utm_content={adgroupname}&utm_term=aud-1721779758375:dsa-19959388920&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=12440232635&gbraid=0AAAAACfld400KD9P5ghXnjhaz3qKyYjgk&gclid=CjwKCAjwhNbTBhB4EiwAsFSg-pStwYQrPySa2pPiWZ3kOMnpC69a66kqBKsxyFP5iqEDHS7gyAemDRoCjIwQAvD_BwE" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Incorruptible: How Good Companies Go Bad and How Great Companies Stay Great</i></a>. It was delightfully <a class="link" href="https://bsky.app/profile/davekarpf.bsky.social/post/3mrjc7j4onk2x?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">much more radical </a>than I expected. (I don’t usually see startup gurus take a sledgehammer to Milton Friedman’s corpse. More of this, please!)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Ries’s main thesis is that well-meaning companies have to take governance and corporate structure <i>very seriously</i>, or else they will get sabotaged by private equity/hostile board members/other avatars of the worst excesses of present-day capitalism. Good companies go bad because we prioritize immediate shareholder value over all other types of value-creation, with disastrous consequences both for the companies themselves and for society writ large. (I’d recommend reading Megan Greenwell’s <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/bad-company-private-equity-and-the-death-of-the-american-dream-megan-greenwell/c2b4dd60a98c35d2?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=dsa_nonbrand&utm_content={adgroupname}&utm_term=aud-1885352274184:dsa-19959388920&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=12440232635&gbraid=0AAAAACfld400KD9P5ghXnjhaz3qKyYjgk&gclid=CjwKCAjwhNbTBhB4EiwAsFSg-spnYBPHjKZxR29j8oZ57aW_pz_q1_3SVr8HJEgCWEoiqG-wdAVh6hoCtwQQAvD_BwE" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Bad Company</i></a><i> </i>and Catherine Bracy’s <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/world-eaters-how-venture-capital-is-cannibalizing-the-economy-catherine-bracy/ff2a78cff5580674?ean=9780593473481&bkshp-astro=t&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>World Eaters</i></a><i> </i>first, but Ries’s book is a welcome addition to the genre.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Anyway, as Ries makes clear, the question that you have to ask whenever a tech company (or <b>any</b> large company) strikes a deal with a local government is “<i>what penalty does the company pay if they go back on the deal?</i>” If the penalty for reneging is cheaper than the cost of fulfilling the stated terms, then you should assume that the company will renege. (Because that’s how the company maximizes shareholder value in the upcoming quarter. Everything else is secondary.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We’ve seen this phenomenon for decades with environmental/health and safety regulations. It is cheaper for coal companies to pay the fines than to follow the law, so the coal companies just pay the fines. We’ve also seen it in <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/on-elon-musk-and-legal-arbitrage?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Elon Musk’s legal arbitrage</a>. We know how this goes. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">When a company says they are “going to treat the water with chemicals so it doesn’t flow into the lakes,” that is a limited-duration promise. What the company actually means — the only thing that it <i>can mean</i>, in fact — is that it is willing to make this promise to the community <i>right now</i> in order to sign the deal it is pursuing. At some later date, some C-suite executive (or outside consultant, or politically-connected VC, take your pick) is free to notice that treating the water with chemicals <i>costs a lot of money</i>, and that it would be cheaper to just <i>stop</i> treating the water with chemicals. And then, unless the enforcement mechanism is absolutely ruinous (and, in 2026, they never are), the company will abandon its former promises. And probably give the exec a bonus.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The companies <i>could</i> build out the electric grid, constructing massive solar farms to support their massive data centers. But it would be cheaper (for them, in the short term) if they didn’t. So, in practice, they generally won’t.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">You don’t have to believe the hyperscalers are particularly villainous companies to conclude you shouldn’t believe their promises. You just have to believe they behave like large companies, and obey the same short-term profit-maximizing incentives as every other large company.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(2) The Situation with Situational Awareness</b> </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The whole Leopold Aschenbrenner thing is such a fascinating trainwreck. If you haven’t followed the details, <a class="link" href="https://www.theverge.com/ai-artificial-intelligence/973467/ai-bet-situational-awareness-oops-stonks?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">read Liz Lopatto’s (perfect) writeup from last week</a>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The TL;DR version: Aschenbrenner (a former OpenAI and FTX employee) wrote a <a class="link" href="https://situational-awareness.ai/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">manifesto</a> in 2024, insisting that scaling laws would go on forever and superintelligent AI would completely transform the economy by 2027. It included a bunch of chart-crimes. Silicon Valley loved it. Then he launched a hedge fund. The manifesto was great advertising, and the investment thesis was basically “leveraged bets on AI lines going up.” Good thesis, for the past couple years at least. He made a ton of money for his investors. But then, last week, he lost basically all of it and had to sell the assets to mega-investor Ken Griffin.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/9d40647e-87c0-46ca-b64d-5ef7b2bb26cf/Screenshot_2026-08-07_at_3.45.43_PM.png?t=1786131949"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Aschenbrenner’s chart-crime. This is bad. Do not ever make a chart like this.</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This seems to be less a sign of that the AI financial crash has finally arrived and more a sign that sophisticated AI thinkers don’t know what they don’t know about finance and hedge funds. (As always, <a class="link" href="https://www.bloomberg.com/account/newsletters/money-stuff?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">read Matt Levine</a>). </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Also, too: this all happened on Thursday last week. Last week, the news was that Leopold Aschenbrenner had lost roughly $35 billion of his investors’ money. And then this Tuesday, he relaunched the fund with a fresh $400 million of private investment. AND <a class="link" href="https://nypost.com/2026/08/05/us-news/ai-prodigy-leopold-aschenbrenners-lavish-wedding-went-on-despite-hedge-funds-implosion/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">OVER THE WEEKEND THE GUY GOT MARRIED</a>! </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I am so, so curious about the vibes at that wedding. Congratulations to the happy couple. May the rest of your lives be <i>so much less hectic</i> than the beginning of your marriage.</p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That’s all for this week. August is going to be a pretty light month, newsletter-wise. I’ve got some vacation planned, and am training for a marathon right now (in August. In DC. I may not have fully thought this through), so I’m basically dividing my time between (1) running and (2) being exhausted from running. </p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-awareness-of-the-situation"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=6e02ab4c-744b-448b-b04f-50f3ff89e4e3&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>The data center backlash Is working. That&#39;s why the New York Times is so concerned.</title>
  <description>A response to Adam Mastroianni</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/12fa189c-dc26-4702-8129-af564bf5408b/Screenshot_2026-07-28_at_9.44.12_AM.png" length="857761" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned</guid>
  <pubDate>Tue, 28 Jul 2026 15:39:30 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-07-28T15:39:30Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One way to know the data center backlash is working is that the <i>New York Times</i> opinion section is freaking out.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Over the weekend, the <i>Times</i> published a guest essay titled “<a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/25/opinion/data-centers-environment-ai.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">The Environmental Case Against Data Centers Is Misguided</a>,” by Experimental Psychologist/Substacker <span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Adam Mastroianni. The argument he makes is a good indicator of the current industry talking points. To wit:</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">-People sure do seem to hate data centers! But should they, though? When you think about it, data centers really aren’t so bad.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">-Here are some statistics about energy usage and environmental impacts. They were generated by a handful of industry-funded bloggers and think tanks. Surely their modeling assumptions are pure and good. And, look at that! They use practically no energy at all. It turns out that data centers are way less harmful than golf courses. You don’t see people protesting golf courses, do ya?</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">-Anyway this is just a new form of NIMBYism. All those data centers are bound to get built </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>somewhere</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">. So, when you think about it, powerful communities stopping data centers in one place just means they’ll get built in poorer communities. Surely there are better ways to fight the AI industry.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">-And hey, I’m critical of the AI industry too! There are good and bad things about the AI revolution. But what we should really be focused on is </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>responsible use</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">. Everyone, individually, ought to think about the right and wrong ways to incorporate AI into our lives. That would be far more effective than the data center backlash. Let’s engage in this totally different conversation about ethics and personal responsibility.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">I’m seeing this same argument pop up a lot, particularly in techno-optimist/reactionary-centrist circles. And there are just three quick things I want to say about it:</span></p><ol start="1"><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The math on energy and water usage is complicated. (Read Matteo Wong, “<a class="link" href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/2026/07/how-much-water-data-centers-use/687934/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">The Truth about AI’s Water Use</a>” and Alex Reisner, “<a class="link" href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/2026/07/generative-ai-engineering-disaster/687901/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Generative AI Is an Engineering Disaster.</a>”) It’s complicated because an awful lot depends on design choices and cost calculation. <b>You </b><i><b>could</b></i><b> build a data center that uses basically no water, and that is powered entirely by solar and batteries</b>. But that would cost a lot more money and take a lot more time. The hyperscalers are treating AI as a race, and are burning cash at a phenomenal rate. So <b>of course</b> the <i>actual</i> environmental costs are much higher than the ones calculated by the industry’s bloggers-of-choice.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"></p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Here’s something that <i>isn’t</i> complicated: the sheer, unprecedented scale of their proposed buildout. The hyperscalers are aiming to build <a class="link" href="https://apnews.com/article/ai-data-center-ohio-uranium-enrichment-4667fa1442ec1c652228337ab4eb68ee?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">10 gigawatt data centers</a>. 10 gigawatts of power is around the same energy consumption as New York City during a heat wave. That’s… a lot. </p></li></ol><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">2a. Anytime you have an emerging industry, no established industry standards, and big questions about its impacts, some of the biggest fights will be second-order arguments over what we should measure and how we should measure it. Industry-friendly blogger Andy Masley has made a name for himself by “debunking” environmentalist claims. He mostly does so by changing the scope of analysis to things like <a class="link" href="https://blog.andymasley.com/p/whats-the-full-hidden-climate-cost?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">the cost of a single ChatGPT prompt</a>. It’s a fundamentally silly argument to get involved in. The AI executives are saying (basically) “we plan to consume so much power that we will soon need to blot out the sun with space data centers,” and their favored bloggers are then chiming in to say “but when you think about it, that’s not much energy usage at all!” Massive new data centers are, in fact massive. This isn’t complicated. The people saying otherwise are either grifters or marks.</p><ol start="3"><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">And, also, this is entirely about political power. Of course it is. They wouldn’t be complaining in the NYT if it wasn’t working. Last week I was listening to David Roberts’s <a class="link" href="https://www.volts.wtf/p/making-sense-of-the-data-center-backlash?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Volts podcast</a> last week, and he noted that the AI industry has made a colossal blunder by not just, like, paying for goodwill from all these towns. It would be relatively cheap, compared to what they’re spending, to just build schools and libraries and clean energy grids for these towns. But <i>of course</i> OpenAI and Elon’s company and all their competitors aren’t actually doing that. It would cost them <i>money</i> and <i>time, </i>plus they would have to explain to their next round of investors why a chunk of their money went to building a library in Ohio instead of <a class="link" href="https://futurism.com/artificial-intelligence/sam-altman-announces-singularity?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">making the Singularity happen any minute now.</a> They <i>could</i> make these communities better, just like they <i>could</i> use the data center buildout as a tool for rebuilding the energy grid and radically increasing renewable energy capacity. But they <i>won’t</i>, because that isn’t the game they are playing. It never has been, and it never will be, unless we completely shift the power dynamics.</p></li></ol><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I wrote a couple months ago about <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-data-center-bankshot?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">data center activism as a bankshot</a>. The reason why I think this activism is <i>very</i> good, and <i>very</i> promising, is that it has the potential to interfere with the AI financial bubble. If that bubble pops, it unsettles the power dynamics shaping the AI future. If you think it is bad that Sam Altman, Elon Musk, and a handful of their billionaire buddies are effectively unconstrained, then the most effective thing you can do is pick a fight over data center siting in your area.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">People </span><span style="font-size:16px;"><i>really hate</i></span><span style="font-size:16px;"> </span><span style="font-size:16px;"><i>the AI future right now</i></span><span style="font-size:16px;">. And people have no place to put that hatred. They see it coming. They see Sam Altman and Elon Musk and Dario Amodei being smug assholes, promising that </span><span style="font-size:16px;"><b>no one will have a job and only a few dozen people will have any money and teehee maybe it will end the world but probably not and anyway you better let them do whatever they want because otherwise China will do it first and where is your patriotism anyway?</b></span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">And they see that this handful of shitty dudes has all the money and all the power and AI is getting stuffed into every product and some of it is kind of cool, though a lot of it is annoying, but it isn’t as though anyone can do anything about it.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">(…)</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">Data Centers aren’t the perfect vehicle for all those sentiments. But they are a perfectly </span><span style="font-size:16px;"><b>functional</b></span><span style="font-size:16px;"> vehicle. David Sacks (or whoever replaces him as AI Czar) isn’t going to listen to you, because David Sacks (and that whole odious crowd) doesn’t care about democracy to begin with. And your member of Congress probably isn’t going to listen to you, because they’re worried about facing an avalanche of AI political spending in 2026. Also, even if they did, lol Congress doesn’t pass laws anymore, and any worthwhile law they did somehow pass would be vetoed by Trump or overturned by the Court.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">But your state and local reps really might listen to you. AI isn’t </span><span style="font-size:16px;"><i>primarily</i></span><span style="font-size:16px;"> a zoning issue, but treating it as a zoning issue is one of the few ways to voice productive, collective dissent.</span></p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Mastroianni concludes by arguing for a politics of personal responsibility. He writes: </p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">“I am a scientist and a writer, and I’m happy to use A.I. to do my job better: I’ll let it write code, fetch articles for me to read or flag errors in statistical analyses for me to investigate further. A.I. is a tool. Its purpose is to serve our purposes. If it does that well, it might be worth the water and electricity it consumes.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I refuse to let A.I. evolve from a tool into a partner. I won’t let it write my sentences. I don’t share with it my fears, hopes or dreams the way I would with a friend or lover. I don’t trust its factual claims unless I can check the sources myself. (…)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It should be humiliating to choose A.I. friendships over human ones. It should be cringe to willingly consume computer-generated slop. Trying to pass off a large language model’s words as your own should be seen not just as cheating but also as loser behavior.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It might sound idealistic to suggest that every person has some influence over the future of technology. Yet this has proved true over and over again, even in the recent past. Plenty of expensive tech ventures have failed. They weren’t banned, voted out or blocked by zoning laws. They failed because people refused to reward them with time and attention: <a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/03/19/technology/mark-zuckerbergs-metaverse-vr-horizon-worlds.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow" style="color: #326891"><span style="text-decoration:underline;">The Metaverse</span></a>. <a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/21/business/media/quibi-shutting-down.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow" style="color: #326891"><span style="text-decoration:underline;">Quibi</span></a>. Nonfungible tokens. A.I. is unlikely to disappear, but the form it takes is up to us.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I’m going to presume this argument is made in good faith. I don’t know Mastroianni. Maybe he really is deeply critical of the current trajectory of A.I., and also deeply concerned that the A.I. critics are going about things the wrong way. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But let me just say that <b>his theory-of-change absolutely sucks</b>. The A.I. industry is powerful and fragile. A.I. opponents have landed on a strategy that successfully generates collective action and challenges the industry where it is most vulnerable. And this guy thinks what everyone ought to do instead is focus on their own personal decisions and vague social norms. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The tactic is working. Bad, powerful people are freaked out. Don’t listen to their favorite bloggers who say “well, when you think about it from just the right angle, data centers aren’t any worse than golf courses.” </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">When you have a tactic that is working, and your opponent doesn’t have a good countertactic, the smart move is to keep doing it.</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-backlash-is-working-that-s-why-the-new-york-times-is-so-concerned"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=cc70afb6-0373-4bc4-ba2d-ecb640ad461e&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>On the strategic function of anodyne statements</title>
  <description>200 economists agree that we sure ought to have some more research by economists</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/367928cc-0b4f-4b79-bd9c-f856676848ee/Screenshot_2026-07-15_at_12.39.02_PM.png" length="914737" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/on-the-strategic-function-of-anodyne-statements</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/on-the-strategic-function-of-anodyne-statements</guid>
  <pubDate>Wed, 15 Jul 2026 18:44:11 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-07-15T18:44:11Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/367928cc-0b4f-4b79-bd9c-f856676848ee/Screenshot_2026-07-15_at_12.39.02_PM.png?t=1784133544"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One of my long-running arguments on this blog (and <a class="link" href="https://www.amazon.com/Vaporware-Inc-Silicon-Control-Present/dp/132410631X/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=on-the-strategic-function-of-anodyne-statements" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">in the forthcoming book</a>!) is that Silicon Valley in general, and the AI industry in particular, <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-data-center-bankshot?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=on-the-strategic-function-of-anodyne-statements" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">runs on futurity</a>. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Futurity is the ambient, collective sense of what sort of technologies and business look and feel like <i>the future</i>. It’s just vibes, but with trillions of dollars on the line. The futurity side of Silicon Valley is much bigger than the engineering side of Silicon Valley. SpaceX and Palantir’s market caps aren’t dictated by their product lines or profit margins; they&#39;re determined by the companies’ ability to seem like they’re building the next-big-thing.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Futurity is a fickle thing. You have it until you don’t. (The metaverse was the future, and then it very much was not.) All of the big AI players recognize this. So they work very hard to keep up appearances that (1) the AI revolution will be bigger than the industrial revolution, and (2) the AI revolution is coming <i>so very very soon</i>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/openai-has-an-unsubtle-communications?utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot&utm_medium=referral&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">This takes the form of a communications campaign</a>. The purpose of the campaign is quite simple:<span style="background-color:color(display-p3 1 1 1);"> </span><i>whenever</i><span style="background-color:color(display-p3 1 1 1);"> </span><i>it starts to feel like progress in AI is slowing down, </i><span style="background-color:color(display-p3 1 1 1);">there needs to be another announcement or product demo </span><i>that makes it feel like the future is fast-arriving.</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(The comms campaign, mind you, is separate from the engineering effort. So long as you maintain the aura of futurity, your engineers get limitless resources to build impressive things. It can both be the case that Claude Fable has far more capabilities than last year’s top-of-the-line models, and that wholesale transformation of the economy remains a fairy tale for investors and discussion board maniacs.) </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The AI industry’s comms campaign isn’t particularly complicated. All they do is maintain a drumbeat of gee-whiz stories. If a couple months go by without a public conversation about the radical pace of AI change, then you manufacture one through the publication of another online manifesto or a sign-on letter.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Which brings me to Monday’s AI news. Here’s the<i> NYTimes</i> headline: “<a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/07/13/business/economists-ai-threat-jobs.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=on-the-strategic-function-of-anodyne-statements" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Nearly 200 Economists and Tech Leaders Warn of A.I. Threats</a>.” It’s a story about a new sign-on letter, titled “<a class="link" href="https://www.wemustactnow.ai/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=on-the-strategic-function-of-anodyne-statements" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">We Must Act Now: A Statement on AI’s Transformation of the Economy</a>.” Some very big names signed on to this letter, including 16 Nobel laureates. Sounds pretty newsworthy, no?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Except, when you read the letter itself, it is just about the most anodyne document imaginable. Here is the text, in full:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><ol start="1"><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="color:#11182e;">AI </span><span style="color:#11182e;"><b>may become radically more powerful</b></span><span style="color:#11182e;"> over the next 10 years.</span></p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="color:#11182e;">This </span><span style="color:#11182e;"><b>could drive an unprecedented transformation</b></span><span style="color:#11182e;"> of our economy, larger than the Industrial Revolution, but unfolding over a vastly shorter time frame. It could bring risks, including large-scale job displacement, as well as opportunities such as major gains in living standards.</span></p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="color:#11182e;">Economists, policymakers and technology leaders must </span><span style="color:#11182e;"><b>act now to understand the economics of transformative AI</b></span><span style="color:#11182e;"> and to build the incentives, guardrails, and institutions needed to steer AI in a direction that complements humans and benefits society.</span></p></li></ol><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That’s… nothing at all. AI might become radically more powerful over the next decade (sure). This could be a big deal for the economy (uh huh, yup yup). So economists, policymakers and tech leaders should do a lot of thinking about this stuff. (wait. What?)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This isn’t a call-to-arms. It’s a request for research funding. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In 2023, the Future of Life Institute published the <a class="link" href="https://futureoflife.org/open-letter/pause-giant-ai-experiments/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=on-the-strategic-function-of-anodyne-statements" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">AI Pause Letter</a>, demanding a 6-month moratorium on the development of new foundation models so that policymakers could catch up with the radical pace of AI development. There was no AI pause. Current models are far more powerful than GPT4, and we are not noticeably closer either to the AI jobs apocalypse or the posthuman future.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In 2025, the <a class="link" href="https://ai-2027.com/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=on-the-strategic-function-of-anodyne-statements" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">AI 2027 scenario</a> predicted that <i>the AI future</i> was barreling towards us, and that by 2027 (next year!) Superintelligent AI would likely doom all of humanity in the absence of extremely competent diplomatic coordination among international governments. I could write a long post about how none of this is actually happening the way they predicted, but that would be beside the point. The strategic purpose of the scenario was to contribute to the steady cadence of AI futurity hype. The scenario did what it was intended to do.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">By comparison, this economist letter is remarkably anodyne. What academic economist would <i>disagree</i> that (1) AI <i>might</i> keep improving, (2) this <i>might</i> have economic impacts, and (3) economists and policymakers ought to devote some quality brainpower to this sort of thing?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(The equivalent in my field, political science, would be a mass sign-on letter saying (1) American elections might become more polarized and less competitive over the next decade, (2) this could have implications for democracy, so (3) governments should fund a lot of political science research and listen to the recommendations of political scientists. Practically all political scientists would agree that there should be more research funding for political science, and that policymakers ought to listen to us.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">From a strategic comms perspective, <b>the point of this letter isn’t the substance</b> of the letter. It is substance-free. <b>The point of the letter is to combine the title</b> (We Must Act Now!) <b>with the signatories</b> (A bunch of Nobel laureates, several of whom are skeptics). Because that’s how you maintain the cadence of public conversations about the AI future. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It sure would be nice if mainstream journalism outlets stopped falling for it. </p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=on-the-strategic-function-of-anodyne-statements"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=on-the-strategic-function-of-anodyne-statements"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=26f5d09a-47d0-425e-b827-d48a433107e2&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Analytic Activism, ten years later (Part 1: Mise-en-scène)</title>
  <description>Revisiting my second book, ten years later</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/595a1df9-7461-4598-a5ab-fe2f95fb92d3/Analytic_Activism.jpg" length="163039" type="image/jpeg"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/after-analytic-activism-mise-en-sc-ne</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/after-analytic-activism-mise-en-sc-ne</guid>
  <pubDate>Sun, 12 Jul 2026 12:00:00 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-07-12T12:00:00Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">My second book, <a class="link" href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/0190266139?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=analytic-activism-ten-years-later-part-1-mise-en-scene" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Analytic Activism: Digital Listening and the New Political Strategy</i></a>, was published ten years ago. It has been a very long decade.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One of my projects this summer is to revisit the book and do some serious thinking about what has changed in the intervening years. I did the same thing with my first book, <i>The MoveOn Effect</i>, <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/the-moveon-effect-ten-years-later?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=analytic-activism-ten-years-later-part-1-mise-en-scene" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">back in 2022</a>. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I reread the book this week. I now have a large pile of notes and just a handful of authorial regrets. Today I just want to set the stage a bit for the essays to come.</p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Let’s start with the regrets. <i>Analytic Activism</i> is a good book. It could have been a better one.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The research for this book spanned the years 2013-2015. It is very much a late-Obama-era book. It is also a book from what we now know was the peak of digital media’s <b>platform era</b>. It was written at a time when online petitions were very popular and (in certain contexts) quite effective. It was a time when the ascendance of Facebook and Twitter was more opportunity than problem.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">There is, as a result, a certain quaintness to the book. Reading the first few chapters feels a bit like reading about the politics of Pompeii, just prior to the volcano. It’s not that I was wrong about the politics of petition platforms — it’s just that those politics were about to be rendered irrelevant by much larger social forces.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Chapters three (digital petitions) and four (Upworthy/platform virality) are simultaneously the book’s strongest chapters and its most dated chapters. I handed in the full revised manuscript in March 2016. Back then, it still seemed like <i>someone</i> would beat Donald Trump in the Republican primary. The book was published in December 2016, just a month after he was elected. The middle chapters of the book were, in a sense, immediately outdated. If you want to know what reformist/progressive digital politics was like in 2013-2014, these chapters are an excellent time capsule. But if you want to understand digital politics over the decade that follows, they offer far less relevant insight.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Another regret is the title. In all my early files, I called it “Analytics-based activism.” That seemed unwieldy, so I went with “Analytic activism” instead. I wish I hadn’t. The book isn’t delineating a distinct form of activism that is more <i>analytical </i>than the rest. The book describes how netroots activist organizations make use of data analytics (digital listening) and testing to develop new tactics and strategies. The title was a misstep.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Rereading the book, I can quite tell the stage of my career in which it was written. It’s a second book, but also a pre-tenure book. It is very much a sequel to <i>The MoveOn Effect</i>, revisiting the same set of organizations and digging deeper into how they operate. It tries to simultaneously speak to political practitioners and the research community. And that’s <i>fine</i>, but it also bogs down the writing. At times it feels like every alternating paragraph is meant for a different audience, delivered in a different register. I can tell, in hindsight, that I hadn’t yet worked out what kind of writer I wanted to be.<a href="#b-e36297eb-a68a-4be4-a481-29e5c39aff24" target="_self" title="1 (Still trying to figure this out, tbh.)" data-skip-tracking="true"><sup style="-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;">1</sup></a></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But those are all just notes for my younger self.<a href="#b-332bd08b-55be-4f01-bf47-9a2cc50f6f8c" target="_self" title="2 I also wish I could tell him not to stop exercising when his kids are born. Getting back in shape in your late 40s is HARD!" data-skip-tracking="true"><sup style="-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;">2</sup></a> The real point of this rereading exercise is to generate some new ideas — either about things I got wrong then, or unexpected developments over the intervening decade. I have five such ideas, each of which will become an essay in this series: </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(1) Revisiting and updating the </b><a class="link" href="https://nonprofitquarterly.org/media-theory-movement-power/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=analytic-activism-ten-years-later-part-1-mise-en-scene" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><b>media theory of movement power</b></a>. This was the <i>big idea</i> in chapter 1 of the book. It probably should have been the central concept running through the entire book. And I think it still holds up quite well. I’d like to think through how both the political change and the media change of the past decade affects what political activists <i>do</i> and where/when they <i>succeed</i>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(2) What do we talk about when we talk about (digital) organizing? </b>This is going to be more of a historically-focused essay, looking at the differences between how Saul Alinsky and Ralph Nader approached power-building in the 20th century. The Naderite approach has dominated among reformist-progressive U.S. organizations for several decades, which (I believe) has major implications for how present-day organizations have approached digital tools, listening, and tactics. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(3) Under what circumstances do people in fact prefer empowerment to convenience</b>. One of the bits from chapter 5 that I found most interesting in retrospect was the AFL-CIOs experiment in “governance gamification.” This never made it past the pilot stage. I think it’s worth thinking through the reasons why.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(4) Does generative AI ruin the </b><i><b>entire</b></i><b> tactical repertoire of analytic activism, or just </b><i><b>most</b></i><b> of it? </b>The most powerful activist organizations circa 2013 were generating big online numbers at a fast pace. Generative AI has made it easy to fake a lot of that. I want to spend some time thinking about what that means for tactical repertoires. (This essay is probably going to be the big bummer of the series.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(5) Research note: Organzations are assemblages. It’s really-damn-hard to keep the whole thing in view</b>. This last one will be pretty much entirely for the research community. Both <i>Analytic Activism</i> and <i>The MoveOn Effect</i> took a particular approach to how we study social movements/political advocacy/civil society/political engagement. I have long advocated for focusing on the “organizational layer” of politics. It’s been a decade, and I find I have a bit more to say on the subject.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Each of these essays will be a significant undertaking. My hunch is that I’ll write one per month, mixed in with the usual essays on technology, politics, and power. I’m looking forward to writing them. Let’s see how this goes…</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=analytic-activism-ten-years-later-part-1-mise-en-scene"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=analytic-activism-ten-years-later-part-1-mise-en-scene"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div><div style="border-top:2px solid #272A2F1A;padding:15px;"><p id="b-e36297eb-a68a-4be4-a481-29e5c39aff24"><span style="font-variant-numeric:tabular-nums;text-decoration:underline;text-underline-offset:2px;">1</span>&nbsp; (Still trying to figure this out, tbh.) </p><p id="b-332bd08b-55be-4f01-bf47-9a2cc50f6f8c"><span style="font-variant-numeric:tabular-nums;text-decoration:underline;text-underline-offset:2px;">2</span>&nbsp; I also wish I could tell him not to stop exercising when his kids are born. Getting back in shape in your late 40s is HARD! </p></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=5d4f3305-7210-456d-a7f2-16d5b31606c3&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>What is the Great American State Fair like?</title>
  <description>You aren&#39;t meant to attend the fair. It&#39;s a digital Potemkin Village.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/2fbaf93a-1a01-4ec6-b1d4-7bc155032f2e/bafkreidsstm73bzjang7rauk62kybezpwsdi6xi72w4hcr6v7uvvipwiyq.jpg" length="1612826" type="image/jpeg"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/what-is-the-great-american-state-fair-like</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/what-is-the-great-american-state-fair-like</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 02 Jul 2026 12:05:00 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-07-02T12:05:00Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I stopped by the Great American State Fair on Tuesday. The website listed the day’s theme as &quot;Innovation, Technology & Progress.” It doesn’t get more on-theme for <i>The Future, Now & Then </i>than that.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I documented the trip in a <a class="link" href="https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:ecjlc5ouev63oweq5en4lsj3/post/3mpjwaimips2c?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-is-the-great-american-state-fair-like" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">bluesky thread</a>, the highlights of which are featured on <a class="link" href="https://flaminghydra.com/great-american-despair/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-is-the-great-american-state-fair-like" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Flaming Hydra</a> (have you subscribed to Flaming Hydra yet? It is the absolute best. Please subscribe.).</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The most striking part of the experience, really, was just how <b>boring</b> it all was. I did not expect the Fair to be <i>good</i>, but I expected it would be an interesting sort of <i>bad</i>. Trumpist aesthetics include an awful lot of trolling and demagoguery. Both are bad and socially corrosive; neither are boring. The UFC fight on the Whitehouse lawn was an absolute assault on the senses. The Fair was something else.</p><blockquote align="center" class="bluesky-embed" data-bluesky-uri="at://did:plc:ecjlc5ouev63oweq5en4lsj3/app.bsky.feed.post/3mpk4brp64c24" data-bluesky-cid="bafyreiacs4px6xg54eyqogl725nqo2ld4ydhcuevpkreq2rdytybmgitpi"><p dir="ltr" lang="en"><p>I have walked the entire mall and seen everything. </p><p>The overarching vibe is boredom. I cannot emphasize enough just how little there is to DO here. </p><p>Imagine a state fair with one Ferris Wheel & no other rides. Three event stages, but no performance schedule. Dozens of booths, with nothing inside.</p></p><a href="https://bsky.app/profile/davekarpf.bsky.social/post/3mpk4brp64c24?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-is-the-great-american-state-fair-like"><p> &mdash; Dave Karpf (@davekarpf.bsky.social) <br/> 11:01 PM • Jun 30, 2026 </p></a></blockquote><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The Great American State Fair isn’t like a trip to Epcot, or to the World’s Fair. There just isn’t nearly enough to do there. I have <span style="background-color:#ffffff;">spent 14 hours at Epcot with small children. I do not recommend it. But the kids never lacked for entertainment at Epcot. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">It also isn’t much like a state or county fair. It has the trappings of one. There’s a Ferris Wheel. There is a daily rodeo. There are (air conditioned) booths, where you can learn about states or federal agencies. But it’s all half-done, as if the planning team got DOGE’d early and no one noticed the to-do list left undone. </span></p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/2fbaf93a-1a01-4ec6-b1d4-7bc155032f2e/bafkreidsstm73bzjang7rauk62kybezpwsdi6xi72w4hcr6v7uvvipwiyq.jpg?t=1782955797"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Really, what are we doing here, folks?</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">It also — and this is the real, inexcusable flaw — is not like the Smithsonian. The National Mall is home to world-class, free museums. If you are going to hold a 250th anniversary celebration on the National Mall, it either has to be distinctly </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>different </i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">than the Smithsonian, or else it has to be </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>better</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"> than the Smithsonian. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">The state exhibits are lackluster. But they’re particularly an embarrassment because the National Museum of American History is </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><b>right there</b></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">, across the street, just steps beyond the fencing. The largest display belonged to SpaceX. It was underwhelming in its own right, and rendered downright pathetic when you consider the National Air & Space Museum is two blocks away, open to the public, with much better exhibits. </span></p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/aa03b27a-0b3c-40c2-bc0f-36a9f5495c9b/bafkreic2xo4ge377u4ncgr7zsdioh4zushwylm22br4c3kuk63sf7mmh6i.jpg?t=1782964164"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">The crowds are sparse, on par with the tourist traffic you’d see on the Mall during a normal summer day. The Fair is much too spread out, extending across seven city blocks. It runs eleven hours a day, for two weeks straight. And, again, there is </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>nothing to do</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"> </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>there</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">When I visited, the largest crowd I found was watching the rodeo. That crowd filled a pair of small bleacher seats. Imagine the away crowd at a high school football game, in a state that doesn’t particularly care about high school football. That’s as big as it got.</span></p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/1f807699-30be-435f-aad9-ef094c50db48/bafkreieapyaslcgoe5vdrqe7sqqjnudpmuft7ad5b7ypvxweplytobpbpi.jpg?t=1782957244"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">I walked the entire Mall and saw everything there was to see in under two hours. It is punishingly hot outside. People aren’t going to spend the day just </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>hanging out at the fairgrounds</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">. And they aren’t going to cluster around the big events or attractions, because they either don’t exist or haven’t been publicized. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Another reason for the lack of crowds is the complete absence of any public schedule of events. The Fair has three performance stages. You cannot search online to find out who is performing when. You are not handed a program upon arrival. It turns out that when you register (for free, no actual ticket required), you are added to an email distribution list. Each morning, they send out the day’s schedule of events. I signed up on Tuesday afternoon, so I didn’t receive an event schedule until Wednesday. (Glenn Beck appeared on the Wednesday mainstage. His was the only name in the lineup that I recognized.) </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">This is no way to run a fair or a festival. It’s no way to run an event of any sort.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">The saddest moment of my visit came while watching a performer on the National Endowment for the Arts stage. He had an audience of one. In between songs, he thanked the crowd and asked them (her) to follow him on Instagram. Logistically, this is unavoidable. People will not show up to a concert if no one informs them it is happening. Particularly not in 100 degree heat.</span></p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/c929399d-87ba-4090-8f59-22ba526346dd/bafkreibphnofn4j673nxpjz4v3tbub7vwsox6adj3m3ajby7sjg5b4nmjq.jpg?t=1782958222"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The worst part of the Fair is the Freedom Truck. DO NOT ENTER THE FREEDOM TRUCK! Inside you will find a Prager U exhibit on American history. Again, let me remind you that the National Museum of American History is RIGHT ACROSS THE GODDAMN STREET, PEOPLE! </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The second worst part of the Fair was everything else. </p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/63723443-de1f-48e9-8306-62ae5ca4cb95/bafkreia7y3rkhkh7rnbnxwfomjektloxyqwk347zx4j4ir3a2rkctc7alq.jpg?t=1782964588"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>animated George Washington, powered by Prager U. This broke me. I am broken now.</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">My hunch is that the event organizers got spooked by </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><a class="link" href="https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2026/06/29/vanilla-ice-freedom-250-performance-canceled-weather-rain/90736451007/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-is-the-great-american-state-fair-like" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">all the cancellations</a></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">, so they decided to keep the performance schedule quiet. Another possibility is that they are still scrambling to fill performance slots, and they simply don’t have the schedule locked in until the day-of. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">I cannot decide which possibility is more embarrassing. These are not professionals. They are not qualified to plan a toddler’s birthday party. I cannot imagine being this bad at the nuts-and-bolts of your job, in public, where everyone can see you being see your basic incompetence on full display. </span><br><br><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Just imagine planning a cross-country trip to attend this fair: It spans two weeks. There is no advance agenda to plan around. So you… pick a weekday at random? You arrive to find empty exhibit halls and overpriced food. I hope you like Glenn Beck, and I hope you happened to show up on Glenn Beck day? The nice thing, I suppose, is that you can get real close to the stage. But that’s because attendance is so low and spread out that you feel basically alone. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Meanwhile, the Smithsonian museums are just past the fencing. You could have a better experience, cheaper meals, and (much) better air-conditioning just a block or so away. But it isn’t a special occasion for the Smithsonian. It’s just a weekday. This is what they do all the time. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">So it isn’t a state fair, and it isn’t the World’s Fair. The in-person experience is like the empty shell of a fairground experience. One Ferris Wheel, and no other rides. Three event stages, but no performance schedule. Dozens of booths, with nothing to offer visitors. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">But what it </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>does</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"> have is cameras, all pointed at those event stages. The performances have the texture of a Congressman giving a fiery speech to an empty chamber, broadcast live on C-SPAN, for an audience of no one in particular.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">The Great American State Fair isn’t meant for the attendees at all. It’s online content. It’s meant for the streamers and online viewers. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">That’s what it most reminds me of: it’s a digital Potemkin Village. They didn’t bother to create a real fair, or bring people together to celebrate the country’s 250th anniversary. They just threw something together that would look good-enough for the propaganda outlets, and called it a day.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">And that’s the element of Trumpism that it most invokes: the rank amateurism… the slapdash construction… the sense that they just can’t be bothered to try anymore. Planning a national, multi-week event is a huge undertaking. It requires planning and execution. It is hard work. And what visiting the Great American State Fair reminds you of is that our current government just doesn’t do the hard work any longer.</span></p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-is-the-great-american-state-fair-like"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-is-the-great-american-state-fair-like"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=ba241ed1-e058-43db-bf07-de8b11a625f9&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Organized People vs Organized Money: What can&#39;t they buy?</title>
  <description>Extreme wealth inequality completely wrecks democracy and civil society.</description>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 25 Jun 2026 20:44:49 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-06-25T20:44:49Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(This week’s post is brought to you by my general, vague sense of unease.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I was taught from an early age that there are two sources of power in politics. On the one side you have <b>organized people</b>, and on the other you have <b>organized money</b>. This was, and is, a fair approximation of the state of play, at least within the reform-oriented social movement/civil society circles in which I travel. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">You want to stop a data center from being built? You’re going to need to organize enough people to create counterforce against the voice of organized money. You want to change zoning rules to allow more mixed-use development in your city? Organize people. This is what we do. It is, as the old saying goes, what democracy looks like. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Right now there’s a ballot initiative in California to<a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/05/26/opinion/wealth-tax-california-billionaire.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"> pass a billionaire’s tax</a> — a one-time, 5% levy on the state’s 200 billionaires. The SEIU (organized people) has spearheaded the effort. The billionaires, as you might imagine, are not exactly being cool about the whole thing. They started a Signal chat to coordinate their response. Emily Shugerman of the SFStandard got a look at the chatlogs, and shared the details in an article titled “<a class="link" href="https://sfstandard.com/2026/06/13/billionaire-tax-fight-sergey-brin-chris-larsen-mike-moritz-ron-conway/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">the 5% freakout: Inside tech’s madcap war against the California billionaire tax.</a>” </p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">The members of the chat, some of whom are reported here for the first time, read like a Forbes list of Silicon Valley elite: Google cofounder Sergey Brin, venture capitalist Marc Andreessen, former Zynga CEO Mark Pincus, former Sequoia Capital head and chairman of The Standard Michael Moritz, Y Combinator CEO Garry Tan, PayPal cofounder Max Levchin, Sequoia partner Shaun Maguire, Stripe CEO Patrick Collison, Ripple cofounder Chris Larsen, Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong, venture capitalist Ron Conway, Greenoaks Capital founder Neil Mehta, investor and “All-In” podcast cohost David Friedberg, Future Ventures founder Steve Jurvetson and his wife, Genevieve — dozens of tycoons, some of whom were hyper-active in the chat and others who engaged not at all. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">(…)</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">At some point, a chat participant proposed an action more audacious than lobbying Gov. Gavin Newsom or funding an anti-tax measure: <b>What if the group simply bought the signature-collecting company the union was using, then prohibited it from collecting more signatures? </b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">“<b>Of course, that’s what they would think,”</b> said the person who had seen the messages. “<b>That’s what you would do in business: If there’s an impediment, just buy it.</b>”</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"> Emily Shugerman, “The 5% freakout.” </figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Two notes: </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(1) “Just buy it” is a relatively new thing. It was not, until quite recently, the case that organized money looked at every problem and defaulted to “can we just buy this and make it go away.” </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Like, even if you go back to the <a class="link" href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/mattdrange/2016/06/21/peter-thiels-war-on-gawker-a-timeline/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Thiel-Gawker saga</a>, Peter Thiel’s reaction to Gawker was “hey I could covertly fund dozens of lawsuits in order to bankrupt Gawker,” not “can I just buy it and salt the earth?” Billionaire lawfare is also, y’know, <i>bad </i>(s<a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/on-elon-musk-and-legal-arbitrage?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">ee here for some extended thoughts on the subject</a>). But billionaires just buying-all-the-things is a whole other thing.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(2) In this particular case, the billionaires <i>didn’t</i> buy the signature company. I’m not sure that the logistics would have worked out, tbh. But reading that passage increased my vague sense of unease, because it strikes me as the sort of tactic that broadly could work just fine for them. This is the sort of thing that organized money can do now, and it is a very difficult sort of tactic to defend against or effectively counter. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This has been one of the defining trends of the past decade. Organized money has gotten frisky and creative. Wealth concentration, plus owning multiple branches of the government, has left them with few limits and fewer scruples. There aren’t many obstacles that they cannot just buy.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We’re already seeing it in media. <a class="link" href="https://bsky.app/profile/jakemgrumbach.bsky.social/post/3molf7qr4zs22?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Jake Grumbach has a new paper</a>, “Wealth Concentration and Democratic Erosion: A Theory of Media and Common Ownership.” It’s quite good. His summary below gets at the essence of the thing. </p><blockquote align="center" class="bluesky-embed" data-bluesky-uri="at://did:plc:tb2bwzxom5qv4542ru3zqcgu/app.bsky.feed.post/3molf7skqrs22" data-bluesky-cid="bafyreie24uth7ssirqci7yhwzp6zxah25gg6nwsysbcyjm66g2stopndoi"><p dir="ltr" lang="en"><p>Each of these billionaires bought a media firm and 1) made it more rightwing, which 2) drove away audience and advertisers. They're not idiots. They're doing this because it ingratiates them to Trump and, as a consequence, gets their businesses favorable treatment & avoids regulatory punishment</p></p><a href="https://bsky.app/profile/jakemgrumbach.bsky.social/post/3molf7skqrs22?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy"><p> &mdash; Jake Grumbach (@jakemgrumbach.bsky.social) <br/> 5:49 PM • Jun 18, 2026 </p></a></blockquote><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Again, this is new. Organized money used to fight organized people blanketing the airwaves with deceptive advertising, all while quietly pressuring editorial boards to adopt their viewpoint. Now organized money just <i>buys</i> <i>the whole news station</i>. Even if it drives away the audience, that can still be a win for the tech billionaires. (David Ellison can’t be HAPPY with Bari Weiss’s performance at CBS. But it isn’t really much of a problem for him. <i>Oh no, she destroyed CBS and CNN</i>. Gee whiz, I wonder if someone in the government can do an extra-large favor for Larry Ellison’s array of companies…) </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">David Ellison didn’t <i>want </i>Bari to destroy CBS. He wanted her to turn it into <i>Free Press - broadcast edition</i>. And he thought that would work because he’s an out-of-touch nepo baby with zero taste. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">They can’t buy our souls, of course. They can’t buy our hearts or our minds. But civil society relies on durable institutions that mediate political contestation. Another lesson of the past ten years is that <b>democracy is fragile</b>. And any institution that proves itself to be worthwhile for the effective expression of public dissent — any institution that organized people use to exert counterpressure against organized money — is probably purchasable if organized money is creative about it. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Of course then we can always just build another institution. If they buy the signature-gathering vendor, we launch another one. I brought this up on the latest episode of my podcast with Peter Loge (<a class="link" href="https://open.spotify.com/episode/3TZVIFuDVrboWLAyfMM2uF?si=pl1GlUL-TAagekRO4dh7cw&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Office Hours with Karpf and Loge</a>), and Peter’s gut reaction was that this would lead to a cottage industry of signature-gathering companies. He’s right about that, but it doesn’t make me feel much better. How is a movement ever going to develop scale and momentum if it has to keep recreating the wheel?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This brings me to a second piece that evoked the same sense of general unease. A substack essay by Nan Ransohoff titled “<a class="link" href="https://nanransohoff.substack.com/p/the-third-wave-of-american-philanthropy?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">The Third Wave of American Philanthropy</a>” has been making the rounds. Here’s the lede:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#fafafa;"><span style="color:#222222;">Hundreds of billions of dollars in new philanthropic capital will soon become liquid. The OpenAI Foundation holds 26% of OpenAI, worth about $220B at today’s valuation. Anthropic’s seven co-founders have pledged to give away 80% of their wealth and have instituted the most aggressive donor matching program for employees in tech history.</span></span></p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"> Nan Ransohoff, “The Third Wave of American Philanthropy” </figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The author and I have different political leanings — she focuses on the awesome opportunity to build “Silicon Valley for Public Goods” — but the phenomenon is important to take seriously. <span style="background-color:#ffffff;">In the next few years, the vast majority of new philanthropic money is going to be concentrated among a small set of rationalist techbros. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">This will have predictable effects on reformist civil society organizations. They will uniformly be bad. I suspect we’re headed toward a “YCombinator for nonprofits,” run by actual YCombinator alumni who know nothing about organizing or power-building, but have access to so much funding that everyone has to sing from their new songbook.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Not every social movement group will be warped by the attraction of this new philanthropy money. But the ones that don’t remake themselves to satisfy the interests of Dario Amodei et al will find themselves sidelined within the sector. <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/the-gravitational-force-of-tech-money?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">The gravitational force of concentrated money is just too strong</a>, and the alternative sources of funding are just too slim. It will warp civil society, just as it is warping everything else. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This isn’t a trend that lasts forever. It is obviously unsustainable. Eventually it all falls apart. But (here’s a third defining trend of the past decade) things seem likely to get a whole lot worse before they get better. I don’t see how we fix this, at least in the immediate term. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It’s still organized people against organized money. But all the infrastructure for durably organizing people across time and space gets degraded when organized money is out there buying the playing field.</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Some Links:</p><ul><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I heard Cory Doctorow talking about his new book, <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/the-reverse-centaur-s-guide-to-life-after-ai-how-to-think-about-artificial-intelligence-before-it-s-too-late-cory-doctorow/ac86987834ee96c2?ean=9780374621568&next=t&affiliate=310&ref=themarisreview.com&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>The Reverse Centaur’s Guide to Life After AI</i></a><i>, </i>on Adam Becker’s podcast (<a class="link" href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/dreaming-against-the-machine/id1890733564?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Dreaming Against the Machine</a>) this week. The book sounds excellent. Moving it to the top of my reading list.</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Fenwick McKelvey has a new book out as well, <a class="link" href="https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262053198/simpolitics/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>SimPolitics: America’s Quest to Solve Politics with Computers</i></a>. This is also going to the top of my to-read stack. I’ve seen Fen present some of this research at conferences over the past few years, and it’s going to be the perfect mix of internet+politics+history+futurism. I think they call that the “Future, Now and Then special.” (<i>No one calls it that, Dave. Drink less coffee</i>.)</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I joined Gil Duran last week for a livestream of his <a class="link" href="https://www.thenerdreich.com/attack-of-the-trillionaire/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Nerd Reich </i></a><a class="link" href="https://www.thenerdreich.com/attack-of-the-trillionaire/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">podcast</a>. It was the same day that Elon reached trillionaire status. We both had a lot to say about that.</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I also was a guest on Mark Hurst’s radio program, <a class="link" href="https://techtonic.fm/episodes/2026-06-08-dave-karpf-on-the-data-center-backlash/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Techtonic</a>, where we discussed the data center backlash. </p></li></ul><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=organized-people-vs-organized-money-what-can-t-they-buy"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=c0f9b83d-8e64-4852-960c-f12e1967f84b&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>The Future, Now and Then, Then and Now</title>
  <description>A blog/newsletter anniversary post. Plus, my notes on the beehiiv-substack transition</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/cf99a43e-6204-4ce6-9487-650f71ead710/will-echols-P_l1bJQpQF0-unsplash.jpg" length="1710104" type="image/jpeg"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 18 Jun 2026 11:43:00 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-06-18T11:43:00Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Today marks the <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/coming-soon?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">five year anniversary</a> of The Future, Now and Then. This calls for a navel-gazing post, and maybe a slice of cake.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/cf99a43e-6204-4ce6-9487-650f71ead710/will-echols-P_l1bJQpQF0-unsplash.jpg?t=1781747463"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Photo by <a class="link" href="https://unsplash.com/@willecholz?utm_source=unsplash&utm_medium=referral&utm_content=creditCopyText" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Will Echols</a> on <a class="link" href="https://unsplash.com/photos/sliced-chocolate-cake-beside-fork-on-plate-P_l1bJQpQF0?utm_source=unsplash&utm_medium=referral&utm_content=creditCopyText" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Unsplash</a></p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The title, “The Future, Now and Then,” was initially a bit of self-effacing humor. I figured I would be writing about tech futurism (the future, now), my WIRED research (the future, then), and contemporary political commentary (now). And I expected I’d only be writing occasionally (now and then). </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The writing was indeed pretty occasional during that first year. 2021-2022 was also a low point for me as a writer. I had outlines for a dozen or so essays, all of them potential building blocks for the book. I was making progress on none of them. It just didn’t seem like I could get anything on the page. In July 2022, I got real mad at myself about a couple missed deadlines, and decided that the new rule was that I would write <i>something</i> every week. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That… worked. I’ve written 200+ posts since then. The Future, Now and Then has over 10,000 readers. The book is <a class="link" href="https://www.amazon.com/Vaporware-Inc-Silicon-Control-Present/dp/132410631X/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">coming out in January</a>. It’s the best thing I’ve ever written. I’m certain it wouldn’t be nearly as good if I hadn’t had this platform to work through the ideas in public first. I think I’m slowly starting to get the hang of this stuff. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">A few stray observations:</p><ul><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Five years in, <b>I still cannot decide if this publication is a</b> <b>blog</b> <b>or a newsletter</b>. The genre boundaries are fuzzy, and it usually doesn’t matter. Mostly <span style="background-color:#ffffff;">I think of it as a blog-with-an-email-reader-list. But I’ve written a lot of drafts over the years that I would’ve published to a blog, because they didn’t merit clogging peoples’ inboxes. </span>The closest analogue is a weekly opinion column. Once a week, I vent whatever research observations or public commentary have been rattling around my head. Sometimes that’s a book review or a big-picture essay, sometimes it’s a hot take or a rant. </p></li></ul><ul><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">The fuzzy genre boundaries have exacerbated my oddball-academic status. Some of my academic research colleagues subscribe to this blog/newsletter. I show up in their inbox every week, and a subset of my posts are topical for their interests. They think I’m fantastically productive. But the vast majority of my field don’t read this column and many of them… kind of figure I’ve stopped publishing entirely? (Can’t blame them. My </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><a class="link" href="https://scholar.google.com/citations?hl=en&user=beydsFsAAAAJ&view_op=list_works&sortby=pubdate&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Google Scholar footprint</a></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"> is atrocious.) </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"></p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">An interesting byproduct is, when I attend conferences and workshops, people either <i>really </i>know my work or they <i>really</i> don&#39;t. Those who don&#39;t are a little suspicious. (&quot;<i>Oh, you have a newsletter? That&#39;s... nice.</i>”) Which, y&#39;know, fair. It feels like a smaller version of <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/talking-bretbug-in-the-classroom?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">the bretbug thing</a>. I learned pretty quickly that the Bret Stephens episode had made me Twitter-famous, which is very much not the same thing as internet-famous or actual-famous. People who are extremely online will still drop references. Everyone else doesn&#39;t know what I&#39;m referring to, and is a little unsure why they should care. (Which, again, fair! It is extremely niche and mostly pointless.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"></p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">I don’t much bother with peer reviewed articles anymore. Maybe I should, I honestly can’t decide. For the types of intellectual contribution I want to make, I find the peer review process to be too slow and cumbersome to bother. I have deeply mixed feelings about that — I think peer review is good, and important, and mostly not-for-me. It would probably be better if I set aside the time to turn some of my longer-form essays into journal submissions. (Could “</span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/on-political-communication-as-a-mission?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">On Political Communication as a Mission Science</a></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">” have been a journal article? Yeah, I think so. Would it have been worth adding ~2,000 words to the text, spending six months on minor revisions, and waiting a year+ for it to be published? Eh, I’m not so sure.) </span></p></li></ul><ul><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Geez, there are a lot of you. Ten thousand readers is a much larger audience than I ever would have planned for. It is very cool and more than a little humbling. (So, y’know, thanks! Have some cake.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"></p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">And/but… 2021 was basically Peak Substack. Substack was the <i>future of journalism</i>, and the social media ecosystem was primed for sharing these newsletter-essays. That time has passed. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"></p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Which brings me to the Substack-Beehiiv transition, and some more substantive points about the state of online publishing right now. The chart below is my subscriber growth over the lifetime of the publication on Substack. Loosely speaking, the publication added ~500 readers in its first, sporadic year (June 2021-’22), 3,600 readers in its second year (June ‘22-’23), 3,000 readers in its third year (June ‘23-’24), 3,500 in its fourth year (June ‘24-’25), and only 700 readers in its fifth year (June ‘25-26). The growth rate slowed around March ‘25. Either this publication hit a ceiling, or Substack’s discovery engine stopped working so well for free publications like mine.</p></li></ul><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/c81d5915-74e0-4155-bed4-0d6f17a58396/Screenshot_2026-06-17_at_11.45.20_AM.png?t=1781711127"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The declining growth rate was <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/yeah-so-substack-im-out?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">one factor in my move to beehiiv</a>. Substack has invested heavily in discovery features that help to juice subscriber growth within its newsletter ecosystem. I knew moving to an alternate platform would decrease the reach of my writing, but also noted that the list growth was already trending down.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">So far, after three months on Beehiiv, I’ve found that people just aren’t signing up anymore. Every time I would publish a Substack essay, around 20 people would unsubscribe and (for the most part) more than 20 people would replace them. At Beehiiv, around 20 people unsubscribe every time I post, and 2-6 people replace them. My dormant Substack now has almost 500 more subscribers than my active Beehiiv. </p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/87497b3d-ee95-4005-9de7-0f87097e4ed5/Screenshot_2026-06-17_at_11.46.02_AM.png?t=1781711167"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I’m glad I moved off Substack. It was the right move, and the right time. And everything else about Beehiiv has gone smoothly. Open rates are steady. I’m no longer routinely embarrassed by the platform I publish on. Also, importantly, several dozen of you have stepped up as paying subscribers, which has been enough to cover the publishing costs. (For you, corner-pieces of cake!)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But oof, yeah, slowly leaking readership is a bummer. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">There are a few potential explanations. It’s possible that I have basically reached the ceiling for this sort of writing. Ten thousand people is a lot! I write in a particular, obscure niche. Also, the old Substack probably appears in search above the newer beehiiv. Discoverability might improve over time. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">My hunch is that this is part of a broader trend: <a class="link" href="https://www.theverge.com/news/773928/google-open-web-rapid-decline?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">the open web is dying</a>. Chatbots and AI search are replacing it, and they absolutely suck for independent publications. I suspect that’s the main story here. (also Bluesky, I love you, never change, but you really don’t drive new email signups.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">A few years ago, Max Read wrote a great piece about newsletter/blog audience growth: “<a class="link" href="https://maxread.substack.com/p/matt-yglesias-and-the-secret-of-blogging-055?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Matt Yglesias and the secret of blogging</a>.” </p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">“the key lesson, the thing I would impart to any aspiring bloggers, content creators, or newsletter proprietors, is that <b>the cornerstone of internet success is not intelligence or novelty or outrageousness or even speed, but regularity</b>. There are all kinds of things you can do to develop and retain an audience -- break news, loudly talk about your own independence, make your Twitter avatar a photo of a cute girl -- but the single most important thing you can do is <b>post regularly and never stop.</b></p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"><a class="link" href="https://maxread.substack.com/p/matt-yglesias-and-the-secret-of-blogging-055?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Max Read</a></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I’ve kept Read’s rule of thumb in mind for years now. It’s simple and comforting: Write what you want to write. Write regularly. Readers don’t punish you for straying from your lane. The basic reason I have a lot of online readers now is that I have spent a lot of years doing a lot of online writing, and that’s how the online writing ecosystem functions. Don’t sweat the numbers; just keep writing.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I find it interesting and noteworthy that, at least for The Future, Now and Then, this is no longer true. Around 20 people will unsubscribe after receiving this post. 2-3 will subscribe. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">And look, this is all low-stakes. </span>I don’t write this blog/newsletter in order to build an audience — I write it because I’m a complete sicko who derives joy from the act of writing — but it does set a mood that I have to work to combat. It has the feel of a standup comic, performing while a small stream of people head for the exits. And it<span style="background-color:#ffffff;"> leaves me pondering the broader decline of the open web.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Looking forward, I have some ambitions for the months and years ahead. I’m going to keep writing (obviously). I’m planning an essay series reflecting on my 2016 book, </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>Analytic Activism</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">, 10 years later. I’m also planning to write on AI and activism. And I have a series of essays in mind about the past, present, and future of the climate/environmental movement.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">This fall, I’ll switch into book-hype mode. There are some stray bits from the Wired project that didn’t make it into the book, so I’ll publish those as blog posts here. I’ll also keep writing cranky book reviews, and keep howling into the void as the whole country falls apart around me.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Basically the way I see it, now that I’ve written my way through one book, is that I’ll keep using this platform to hash out the main ideas for the next one.</span><br><br><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Thanks, as always, for reading. If nothing else, I can say with certainty that writing this publication has been</span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i> good for me</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">. </span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">Here’s to another five years. Have some cake.</span></p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-future-now-and-then-then-and-now"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=0680204b-ed41-4466-ac93-a7291b488233&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Bullet Points: digital futures&#39; past</title>
  <description>Elon Musk is a trillionaire, and everyone is a sucker whether they like it or not.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/4bba552a-e600-407c-a695-9eaa79323379/Screenshot_2026-06-12_at_7.02.36_PM.png" length="1120061" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/new-post-6653</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/new-post-6653</guid>
  <pubDate>Sat, 13 Jun 2026 12:01:00 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-06-13T12:01:00Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Three medium-sized thoughts to share today:</p><hr class="content_break"><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-digital-futures-past"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I teach a class every spring semester called “History and the Digital Future.” This is the class that came out of <a class="link" href="https://www.wired.com/story/wired25-david-karpf-issues-tech-predictions/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-digital-futures-past" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">the WIRED project</a>. We read old magazine articles, discuss what the digital revolution looked like back then, and see what lessons we can glean from the imaginary futures that never arrived. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It is my favorite class to teach. I figure out something new every time. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The ah-hah moment this past semester came while we were discussing Kevin Kelly’s 2005 essay, “<a class="link" href="https://kk.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/We-Are-the-Web-_-WIRED.pdf?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-digital-futures-past" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">We Are the Web</a>.” This is actually my favorite Kevin Kelly piece (mostly because he spends time reflecting on stuff he got wrong in the 1990s, and I’m an absolute sucker for self-critical retrospectives). We Are the Web examines three time periods: 1995, 2005, and an imagined 2015. It is a classic Web 2.0 essay, positively brimming with the excitement about online community participation that defined internet culture in that era. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Here’s how Kelly imagines the future, circa 2015:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">2015: The Web continues to evolve from a world ruled by mass media and mass audiences to one ruled by messy media and messy participation. How far can this frenzy of creativity go? Encouraged by Web-enabled sales, 175,000 books were published and more than 30,000 music albums were released in the US last year. At the same time, 14 million blogs launched worldwide. All these numbers are escalating. A simple extrapolation suggests that <b>in the near future, everyone alive will (on average) write a song, author a book, make a video, craft a weblog, and code a program</b>. This idea is less outrageous than the notion 150 years ago that someday everyone would write a letter or take a photograph. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">What happens when the data flow is asymmetrical – but in favor of creators? <b>What happens when everyone is uploading far more than they download? If everyone is busy making, altering, mixing, and mashing, who will have time to sit back and veg out? Who will be a consumer? </b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>No one. And that&#39;s just fine.</b> A world where production outpaces consumption should not be sustainable; that&#39;s a lesson from Economics 101. But online, where many ideas that don&#39;t work in theory succeed in practice, the audience increasingly doesn&#39;t matter. What matters is the network of social creation, the community of collaborative interaction that futurist Alvin Toffler called prosumption. As with blogging and BitTorrent, prosumers produce and consume at once. The producers are the audience, the act of making is the act of watching, and every link is both a point of departure and a destination.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"> Kevin Kelly, <a class="link" href="https://link.wired.com/public/32945405?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-digital-futures-past" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">We Are the Web</a></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">There’s a nice puzzle to unwind here. Reading that first paragraph, it strikes me that Kelly is at least a little bit right. In 2026, <i>we</i> <i>kind of do</i> live in a world where, on average, everyone is more-or-less an online writer of sorts. If you count Twitter/X and Instagram and TikTok, we are absolutely awash in content. This is the world of social media streams, and it is a different world, a different culture, than what came before. Kevin Kelly saw this abundance coming, and tried to take seriously what marvels it would portend. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Except… well… when I ask my students “was Kevin Kelly right?”, they all get pained looks on their faces, glancing around the room to see who is going to step up and try to articulate the disconnect. What emerges is that Kelly was right about the abundance of content, but the abundance was beside the point. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">You can see the tension emerge by focusing on the second and third paragraphs. Everyone <i>isn’t</i> busy uploading far more than they download (or, today, stream). Even the biggest bluesky sickos &lt;raises hand&gt; read far more than they post. A great many people still sit back and veg out, only occasionally contributing to the maelstrom. And the audience <b>absolutely</b> <b>does</b> matter online, because that’s where the money is. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">What Kevin Kelly couldn’t see in 2005, because he was focusing on the new abundance, was that attention was about to become the dominant scarce resource. Hence, the attention economy. Hence Google/YouTube and Facebook becoming multi-trillion dollar businesses by algorithmically sorting attention and selling ads against the eyeballs. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">He also couldn’t see that, once the money got big, content creation would stop becoming defined by scrappy amateur “prosumers,” and would instead become defined by the influencer industry. Hustlers would go on to make millions gaming the algorithms. Those are the defining features of the digital culture my students inhabit. The new abundance was just a starting point. The new scarcity was what defined the boundaries of both culture and industry.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This strikes me as a common mistake among tech futurists. It is relatively easy to tell a story that says (1) our society has been defined by this one scarce resource. (2) But technology is about to make that resource abundant. This changes everything. (3) Just imagine the wonderful possibilities once this new era of abundance has arrived. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">They’re missing a critical fourth step: (4) With every new abundance, there will be a new scarcity. And how we manage that scarcity will tell us what sort of society we will be living in. <b>Look toward the scarcity, not the abundance</b>.</p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This all goes double for the AI future. SpaceX went public today. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Elon Musk is a trillionaire now, and his Space/AI/Social Media company is worth something like $2.2 trillion, with revenues of around negative $4 billion. Both Anthropic and OpenAI have filed to go public as well. Anthropic has had one profitable quarter, OpenAI has <i>hahahahaha</i> <i>who are we kidding?</i> OpenAI isn’t even trying to turn a profit. Why would they bother attempting to make more money than they spend? That isn’t how financial capitalism even works anymore. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">These companies sell stories about the digital future to investors who give them money in exchange for shares of their storytelling company. These shares can be re-sold at a later date to some greater fool, often at a profit. SpaceX is worth $170/share today, not because investors broadly believe the company will generate several trillion in revenues, but because investors narrowly believe they will find someone who will buy their shares for at least $171/share at some later date. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The stories these companies tell about the digital future all revolve around abundance. And they are, if you have spent a few years studying this stuff, <i>just the haziest, laziest stuff.</i> Like, I’m sorry, “a country of geniuses in data center?” “We’re going to solve all of physics?” “Intelligence will be on tap, and then we’ll meter it like electricity?” The money has gotten so out of hand that these fellas aren’t even trying very hard anymore. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It would be nice if someone, anyone, could ask the AI barons this one simple question: <i>If “intelligence” is about to become abundant, then what will the new scarcity be?</i>” How will we organize ourselves in response to that scarcity? Who will profit from it, and who will be made more vulnerable as a result?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I can’t tell you what the world will look like in 2036. But I am damn certain that, with these guys in charge, it won’t be a utopia defined by limitless abundance. Of course it won’t. Let’s not be suckers, alright?</p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One final thought… zoom out far enough, and the history of the digital future looks something like this: </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">First, Silicon Valley built hardware that got smaller and faster and cheaper and better. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Then, Silicon Valley built software that became the mediating layer of the global economy. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">And <i>then</i>, the finance industry ate the software industry. Every tech company today is a finance company. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Software ate the world, and then finance ate software, and now here we are. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It isn’t <i>quite</i> as simple as “after the Great Financial Crisis, all the finance guys moved to Silicon Valley so they could keep doing the same bullshit without all the regulatory scrutiny.” But that’s a close-enough approximation of recent history.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">You cannot explain the actions of Silicon Valley today without paying attention to how the ludicrous excesses of financialization define the strategic behavior of the whole damn industry. </p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-digital-futures-past"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=bullet-points-digital-futures-past"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=52c27a1a-5f44-4d49-a0fb-62fd372e3620&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>How Durable Is Muskism?</title>
  <description>I reviewed Ben Tarnoff and Quinn Slobodian&#39;s new book for Flaming Hydra</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/d1a9b536-3fec-4474-9c52-8dcee3da9a68/image-7.png" length="235890" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/how-durable-is-muskism</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/how-durable-is-muskism</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 04 Jun 2026 17:50:26 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-06-04T17:50:26Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="embed"><a class="embed__url" href="https://flaminghydra.com/issue-578/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=how-durable-is-muskism#how-durable-is-muskism" target="_blank"><div class="embed__content"><p class="embed__title"> Terminal velocity </p><p class="embed__description"> Dave Karpf on soon-to-be trillionaire (?) Elon Musk </p><p class="embed__link"> Flaming Hydra </p></div><img class="embed__image embed__image--right" src="https://storage.ghost.io/c/11/a3/11a34ed2-0d03-4467-9051-6142cc358694/content/images/2026/06/elon-heads-eye-sharp-1.png"/></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Hi folks</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">My <a class="link" href="https://flaminghydra.com/issue-578/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=how-durable-is-muskism#how-durable-is-muskism" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">latest piece for Flaming Hydra</a> is a review of Ben Tarnoff and Quinn Slobodian’s new book, <a class="link" href="https://bookshop.org/p/books/muskism-a-guide-for-the-perplexed-ben-tarnoff/3d177fb9349a79ff?ean=9780063484320&next=t&utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=how-durable-is-muskism" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Muskism: A Guide for the Perplexed</i></a><i>. </i>It’s a very good book! You should read it! The book also provided a nice opportunity to think out loud about (1) what Musk’s success is doing to capitalism and (2) just how durable his empire seems to be. Here’s a taste of the review essay:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The fundamental problem for anyone seeking to narrate the life and career of Elon Musk is that the vast majority of his wealth has accrued over the past six years, during what we might charitably call his “huge fucking clown” phase.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">At the start of 2020, Musk had a net worth of around $24 billion. The Elon Musk of the 2010s had by then built a practically bulletproof public image. He made those tens of billions while manufacturing reusable rockets and mass-producing electric cars. He was hailed as the real-life Tony Stark, back when the MCU was not yet cringe.  (Granted, this was just PR. But it was remarkably successful PR. It worked.) </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">By contrast, the Elon Musk of the 2020s is the Cybertruck guy who has publicly maligned his estranged trans daughter; he cheats at video games and retweets all of the world’s dumbest conspiracy theories. His rockets are the wrong kind of combustible. He very publicly bought Twitter and very publicly ruined it, revealing himself as both the worst and the thirstiest poster the world has yet seen. He started an AI company to compete with OpenAI, and his AI chatbot dubbed itself “MechaHitler.” He paid hundreds of millions to put Donald Trump back in the White House, then tried to run the government like a startup, and only managed to make himself less popular than Donald Trump. And he did all this while still trying to sell electric cars to liberals who hate Donald Trump.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">And yet. 24 billion is just 2.4 percent of 1 trillion. The Elon Musk of the 2010s—the one with the great PR campaign and the exciting companies, the one who wasn’t constantly fretting about white fertility rates and the “woke mind virus,” the one whose business empire was built on fortress futurism, state symbiosis, and financial fabulism—was not the world-bestriding industrialist that the Elon Musk of the 2020s has become. 97.6 percent of his soon-to-be trillion dollars will be attributable to this guy.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Please take a look at the review. (And please subscribe to Flaming Hydra! It’s the best!)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I’ll be back next week with another essay about the future, now, and then.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Best,</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">DK</p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=how-durable-is-muskism"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=how-durable-is-muskism"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=d7c979e6-1fe8-454a-a6f3-711fcbfe74c1&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>The Data Center Bankshot</title>
  <description>This is how we win</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/9a4e7c24-c190-4cce-aa17-57ed672868b0/data_center_asburn_loudoun_wod_trail_drone_4-10-23_credit_hugh_kenny_pec-23-1000px.jpg" length="411082" type="image/jpeg"/>
  <link>https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-data-center-bankshot</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/p/the-data-center-bankshot</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 28 May 2026 22:12:43 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-05-28T22:12:43Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>David Karpf</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">David Wallace-Wells voiced some concerns about data center activism earlier this month, in a column titled “<a class="link" href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/03/04/opinion/data-centers-ai-regulation.html?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Data Centers Are a Distraction. The Real Fight Is Elsewhere</a>.” Wallace-Wells writes:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">“I don’t know how [fighting data center siting] will address fears that a small group of tech oligarchs are working feverishly to design a future in which many of the rest of us might be rendered functionally obsolete.&quot; </span></p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"> -David Wallace-Wells </figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">It’s a fine question to ask. If you asked me to make a list of my concerns about the AI future, the excessive energy use from data centers would be </span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>on</i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"> the list, but it wouldn’t rank among the top ten. Local fights against data center contracts are an imperfect vessel for the much broader AI backlash. </span></p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://www.sierraclub.org/sites/default/files/2026-02/data_center_asburn_loudoun_wod_trail_drone_4-10-23_credit_hugh_kenny_pec-23-1000px.jpg"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>Loudoun County Data Center, </i></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><a class="link" href="https://www.sierraclub.org/issues/climate/data-centers?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>photo by Hugh Kelly, PEC</i></a></span><span style="background-color:#ffffff;"><i>.</i></span></p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="background-color:#ffffff;">But there is also, I think, a compelling answer to his question. Data center activism is a bankshot. It can trigger a reset of the status quo, and has the potential to make a lasting impact on the digital future. </span></p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Let me provide a bit of scaffolding first: There are a few claims that I routinely make about digital futures’ past that <i>really apply </i>to the current AI bubble:<a href="#b-c20cb7ab-65b1-4363-8a12-b23a61f7994d" target="_self" title="1 You’ll find these claims in my forthcoming book, Vaporware, Inc: How Silicon Valley Sells the Future to Control the Present. Longtime readers of this blog/newsletter will also recognize them as stuff-Dave-says-all-the-time." data-skip-tracking="true"><sup style="-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;">1</sup></a></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(1) The arc of any emerging technology bends toward money</b>. We can have a better or worse digital future, depending on who sets (and who enforces) the rules. Giving the tech oligarchs free rein to pursue easy profit is a surefire way to end up in living in a dystopia. (<a class="link" href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2022/12/chatgpt-ai-chatbots-openai-cost-regulations/672539/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">extended argument here</a>, from 2022)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(2) </b>The essential thing to understand about tech futurism is that, when one of Sam Altman or Elon Musk’s predictions doesn’t pan out,<b> they don’t have to give the money back</b>. (<a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/openai-has-an-unsubtle-communications?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">extended argument here</a>, from 2025)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>(3) We’re in an AI bubble right now. </b>How and when that bubble pops will dictate a whole hell of a lot about what happens next. (<a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/its-giving-enron?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">extended argument here</a>, from 2025)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The single best thing that could happen to the AI industry right now is for the current finance bubble to pop. The sooner the bubble pops, the better. This is both because <i>smaller finance bubbles are less calamitous than larger finance bubbles</i> (replaying the 2000 dotcom crash is better than replaying the 2008 great financial crisis) and because, right now, <i>Sam and Elon and Dario and Alex Karp and Marc Andreessen are calling all the shots</i>. After the crash, their power will be constrained and contested. Decreasing their political power is just a fantastically pro-social outcome.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The trouble is that finance bubbles aren’t easy to pop. As Keynes supposedly once remarked, “the market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.”</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The standard approach is to loudly declare, with clear and compelling evidence, that the market has dramatically overestimated the value of a company (or a cluster of companies, in this case). That’s what triggered Enron’s downfall: a Wall Street Journal reporter raised the alarm, then Jim Chanos shorted the company and started making a public stink about their financial flimflam. The house of cards collapsed soon after.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That approach doesn’t seem to be working here. The Wall Street Journal keeps reporting on circular financing. Ed Zitron keeps shouting that the math doesn’t math. But media is so fragmented, the regulatory state so compromised, and wealth so concentrated that the investor-class just keeps pumping money in. The endgame seems to be that the AI industry achieves too-big-to-fail status, and that the major players can demand a bailout once the whole thing implodes. (That would be, y’know, <i>really really bad</i>. But it also seems awfully plausible, given the state of elite politics in 2026.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Silicon Valley runs on futurity. The metaverse felt like the future for a couple years. So long as the metaverse had the aura of futurity, investor dollars flowed. Then the whole thing faltered and fell apart. The same thing happened to Web3 and a lot of other speculative technological futures. The AI industry knows this. It’s why the major players are constantly announcing new not-yet-half-baked products (quick, <a class="link" href="https://davekarpf.substack.com/p/openai-has-an-unsubtle-communications?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">someone explain why the Jony Ive/Sam Altman partnership was newsworthy at the time</a>) and <a class="link" href="https://www.techpolicy.press/palantirs-manifesto-is-as-subtle-as-a-maga-hat/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">constantly releasing manifestos</a>. They need us to believe not just that AI is useful, but that it is inevitable, arriving fast, and bringing about a radically different world. That’s the only way to keep the cash-furnace stoked. The steady flow of investor cash only keeps going so long as they maintain a steady cadence of product demos, benchmark successes, and confident futurism.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Slow the pace down, and you lose the aura of futurity. And then the whole house of cards collapses.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Local opposition to data centers creates a ton of friction for the AI industry. They were not expecting this, and they don’t seem to know how to handle it. It’s a good leverage point for fighting the broader AI industry.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">People <i>really hate</i> <i>the AI future right now</i>. And people have no place to put that hatred. They see it coming. They see Sam Altman and Elon Musk and Dario Amodei being smug assholes, promising that <b>no one will have a job and only a few dozen people will have any money and teehee maybe it will end the world but probably not and anyway you better let them do whatever they want because otherwise China will do it first and where is your patriotism anyway?</b> </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">And they see that this handful of shitty dudes has all the money and all the power and AI is getting stuffed into every product and some of it is kind of cool, though a lot of it is annoying, but it isn’t as though anyone can do anything about it. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I heard this from my students all semester. They use AI, and they hate AI. This stuff is the future, and it’s a bad future, and they’re just kind of stuck with it.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Data Centers aren’t the perfect vehicle for all those sentiments. But they are a perfectly <b>functional</b> vehicle. David Sacks (or whoever replaces him as AI Czar) isn’t going to listen to you, because David Sacks (and that whole odious crowd) doesn’t care about democracy to begin with. And your member of Congress probably isn’t going to listen to you, because they’re worried about facing an avalanche of AI political spending in 2026. Also, even if they did, lol Congress doesn’t pass laws anymore, and any worthwhile law they did somehow pass would be vetoed by Trump or overturned by the Court. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But your state and local reps really might listen to you. AI isn’t <i>primarily</i> a zoning issue, but treating it as a zoning issue is one of the few ways to voice productive, collective dissent.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">(It’s a bit like how copyright law became a multitool for stopping online harms. If someone posts deepfake porn of you on a social media platform, you are much more likely to get it taken down by saying “hey! copyright violation!” than by saying “are you fucking kidding me? I have rights. I am being harassed in the grossest possible ways. Your terms of service forbid this shit. Do something goddammit!” It isn’t a <i>good</i> sign that copyright is the only functional lever. But it is a lever nonetheless.)</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">People are driven to fight these data centers for a lot of reasons — energy bills, civic power, rage at the empty, anti-human imagined future that is being foisted upon us all. <a class="link" href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/may/08/ai-datacenters-democracy?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">They’re all good reasons.</a> This is how social movements get to work.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The original Luddites didn’t break machines because they liked breaking machines. They didn’t break machines because they were reflexively anti-technology either. (<a class="link" href="https://www.bloodinthemachine.com/?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Read Brian Merchant, y’all</a>) They broke machines because other forms of legitimate resistance were illegal or ineffective. Social movements gravitate toward whatever tools are available.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Local resistance to data centers is the best tool available right now. And the more I think about it, the more convinced I am that it’s a very good tool indeed. It has the potential to slow down the cadence of futurity, pop the finance bubble, and reset the entire public debate over how artificial intelligence is built, deployed, and regulated. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Data center activism is a bankshot. That’s what David Wallace-Wells doesn’t see. It’s what we all ought to recognize. There’s an opportunity here, and it’s a good one: The local fights create friction for industrial deployment. The friction slows down the cadence. Slowing down the cadence makes it impossible to sustain the bubble. And after the bubble pops, we gain much more agency to shape the trajectory of the digital future. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is how we win. </p><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/upgrade?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot"><span class="button__text" style=""> Upgrade your subscription: This newsletter runs on coffee. Buy Dave coffee? </span></a></div><div class="button" style="text-align:center;"><a target="_blank" rel="noopener nofollow noreferrer" class="button__link" style="" href="https://davekarpf.beehiiv.com/subscribe?utm_source=davekarpf.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-data-center-bankshot"><span class="button__text" style=""> Subscribe </span></a></div><div style="border-top:2px solid #272A2F1A;padding:15px;"><p id="b-c20cb7ab-65b1-4363-8a12-b23a61f7994d"><span style="font-variant-numeric:tabular-nums;text-decoration:underline;text-underline-offset:2px;">1</span>&nbsp; You’ll find these claims in my forthcoming book, <i>Vaporware, Inc: How Silicon Valley Sells the Future to Control the Present</i>. Longtime readers of this blog/newsletter will also recognize them as stuff-Dave-says-all-the-time. </p></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2Fef1ec363-99dd-4347-8dc0-74b0a77a7647%2FFuture_Now_and_Then_logo.png%3Fv%3D1794886767&publication_name=The+Future%2C+Now+and+Then&utm_campaign=a7e05148-5433-4f08-9e0c-b5467c21b214&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=the_future_now_and_then">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

  </channel>
</rss>
