<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom">
  <channel>
    <title>On EdTech Newsletter</title>
    <description>Market analysis from Phil Hill &amp; Associates</description>
    
    <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/</link>
    <atom:link href="https://rss.beehiiv.com/feeds/bsvK5GP6NJ.xml" rel="self"/>
    
    <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 04:10:20 +0000</lastBuildDate>
    <pubDate>Sat, 14 Nov 2026 19:25:13 +0000</pubDate>
    <atom:published>2026-11-14T19:25:13Z</atom:published>
    <atom:updated>2026-11-17T04:10:20Z</atom:updated>
    
      <category>News</category>
      <category>Education</category>
      <category>Technology</category>
    <copyright>Copyright 2026, On EdTech Newsletter</copyright>
    
    
    
    <docs>https://www.rssboard.org/rss-specification</docs>
    <generator>beehiiv</generator>
    <language>en-us</language>
    <webMaster>support@beehiiv.com (Beehiiv Support)</webMaster>

      <item>
  <title>Interesting Reads This Week</title>
  <description>A closer look at Maine&#39;s YourPace program and mixed messages buried in Strada&#39;s latest data</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0692eb73-977e-4920-8057-55b8c392d24b/Screenshot_2026-11-13_at_19-23-23_UMPI_NECHE_Requested_Information_Report_Final_8.13.26_.docx_-_umpi-neche-requested-information-report-final-81326-docx.pdf.png" length="49264" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261114</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261114</guid>
  <pubDate>Sat, 14 Nov 2026 19:25:13 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-11-14T19:25:13Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Glenda Morgan</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Labor Market Outcomes]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Online Education]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Labor Market]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Enrollment Analysis]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class='paywall'><div class='paywall__content'><h2 class='paywall__header'>Premium Content</h2><p class='paywall__description'>This content is reserved for premium subscribers of On EdTech+. To Access this and other great posts, consider upgrading to premium.</p><p class='paywall__links'><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Upgrade</a><span class="translation_missing" title="translation missing: en.templates.posts.rss.link_conjuction">Link Conjuction</span><a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Sign In</a></p><div class='paywall__upsell'><div class='paywall__upsell_header'><h3>A subscription gets you:</h3></div><ul class='paywall__upsell_features'><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'> New content 3-4 times per week </li><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'> Shared Q&A discussions </li><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'> More coming soon </li><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'></li></ul></div></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=2a5f2e62-ea0c-48d8-85c9-29136cc2e14d&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>What a Credential Leaves Out</title>
  <description>Two new OET+ podcast episodes on what AI exposes about credentialism and what Betsy Bligh learned about her school after landing her first ultrasound job.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/e38985b7-c942-4a73-aea7-aaa3b1d2d56b/Beneath_the_diploma.png" length="2938353" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/what-a-credential-leaves-out</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/what-a-credential-leaves-out</guid>
  <pubDate>Fri, 13 Nov 2026 21:58:22 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-11-13T21:58:22Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Labor Market]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Academic Integrity]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Ai]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Education Reform And Outcomes]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="On EdTech+ logo" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0668f4be-a68a-44a2-8ad9-ef042f83dc62/onedtechpluslogo-1200x630.png"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-a-credential-leaves-out" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-a-credential-leaves-out" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The new <i>On EdTech+ Team</i> subscription is available where it is more appropriate for your institution or company to pay for premium access. The mechanism is based on invoicing, allowing for purchase orders and ACH bank payments, going beyond credit card processing. The subscription allows up to 10 colleagues to directly receive the newsletter. Check with your organization to see if that subscription type works better for you, and <a class="link" href="https://philhillaa.com/oet-team-inquiry/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-a-credential-leaves-out" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">contact us for team requests</a>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We have also released two recent episodes of <b>The </b><b><i>On EdTech+</i></b><b> Podcast</b>, a private audio series for premium subscribers. You can listen directly on the website—each has a built-in player and auto-generated transcript—or add the private feed to your podcast app (instructions below).</p><ul><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/podcast/s/the_on_edtech_plus_podcast/s01e06_darin_francis?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-a-credential-leaves-out" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><b><i>S01E06: </i></b></a><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/podcast/s/the_on_edtech_plus_podcast/s01e06_darin_francis?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-a-credential-leaves-out" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><b><i>Darin Francis on how AI exposes the credentialism crisis</i></b></a> (46 min)</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/podcast/s/the_on_edtech_plus_podcast/s01e07_betsy_bligh_gets_a_job_and_reflects_on_workforce_perception_of_different_academic_institutions?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-a-credential-leaves-out" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><b><i>S01E07: </i></b></a><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/podcast/s/the_on_edtech_plus_podcast/s01e07_betsy_bligh_gets_a_job_and_reflects_on_workforce_perception_of_different_academic_institutions?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-a-credential-leaves-out" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><b><i>Betsy Bligh gets a job and reflects on workforce perception of different academic institutions</i></b></a> (21 min)</p></li></ul><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="ai-didnt-break-academic-integrity-b">AI Didn&#39;t Break Academic Integrity, but It Exposed Credentialism</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I recently joined Darin Francis on his <a class="link" href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=90-umv2AgfY&utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-a-credential-leaves-out" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Signals in Higher Ed</i></a> podcast for a discussion about AI, academic integrity, and a more fundamental problem in higher education: <b>we&#39;ve built a system that too often rewards earning credentials rather than demonstrating learning.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Darin gave me permission to share the episode in our feed; it originally aired on <i>Signals in Higher Ed</i>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The conversation was framed by Darin: &quot;AI didn&#39;t break academic integrity. It exposed a system that was already broken because we built everything around the credential and made the learning become optional.&quot;</p><div class="paywall"><hr class="paywall__break"/><div class="paywall__content"><h2 class="paywall__header"> Subscribe to Premium to read the rest. </h2><p class="paywall__description"> Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to the rest of this post. </p><p class="paywall__links"><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-a-credential-leaves-out">Upgrade</a> Translation missing: en.app.shared.conjuction.or <a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=what-a-credential-leaves-out">Sign In</a></p></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=6a8c2465-85c9-4178-828b-91f1918d43ce&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Microsoft Classroom Is Worth Watching</title>
  <description>The LMS product category looks stable, but its current vendors should not get too comfortable.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/41cb24cb-8b85-41e7-8d91-3f123be9da12/Screenshot_2026-11-11_at_3.11.21_PM.png" length="943794" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/microsoft-classroom-is-worth-watching</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/microsoft-classroom-is-worth-watching</guid>
  <pubDate>Wed, 11 Nov 2026 22:59:51 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-11-11T22:59:51Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Lms Market]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[General Edtech]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Ai]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="On EdTech logo" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/d03d9e27-4cad-42c7-a9b6-bec78b49dcb0/OET-poweredby-logo2025.png?t=1757446904"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=microsoft-classroom-is-worth-watching" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=microsoft-classroom-is-worth-watching" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Microsoft has <a class="link" href="https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/blog/educationblog/introducing-microsoft-classroom-a-new-experience-built-for-teaching-and-learning/4571185?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=microsoft-classroom-is-worth-watching" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">announced Microsoft Classroom</a>, a standalone teaching and learning application with a preview planned for early 2027. It brings together tools for assignments, grading, class materials, and notebooks, along with AI tools for teaching and studying. And Microsoft is explicitly targeting higher education as well as K–12.</p><div class="image"><img alt="Microsoft diagram of Classroom functionality, including classwork, assignments, notebooks, gradebook, study areas, and school data sync" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/41cb24cb-8b85-41e7-8d91-3f123be9da12/Screenshot_2026-11-11_at_3.11.21_PM.png?t=1794435199"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I don’t want to overanalyze a product announcement, but this one is worth following, both for the news itself and for an important distinction in how we think about AI and the LMS market.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="a-stable-category-does-not-mean-saf">A stable category does not mean safe vendors</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Morgan and I have pushed back on arguments that AI will make the LMS obsolete. The need to organize courses, manage enrollment, assess learning, and provide a consistent institutional experience is not going away. Furthermore, the value of the company providing the services—with cybersecurity protection, platform patching and updates, bug fixes, and implementation and ongoing support—is increasing, not decreasing, in today’s environment. The LMS product category looks remarkably stable.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That does not mean today’s LMS vendors are safe.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">AI creates opportunities for competitors to rethink the interfaces and experiences around those functions. I have discussed startups and horizontal EdTech companies as potential sources of competition. As we are seeing today, Big Tech belongs in that discussion as well. Microsoft and Google are investing in AI at a scale that traditional EdTech companies cannot approach, and both already have extensive relationships with colleges and universities.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The question is whether they turn those advantages into learning products institutions actually want to adopt in lieu of traditional EdTech offerings.</p><div class="image"><img alt="Microsoft Classroom interface, with left column of modules and tool options" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/c1a55dca-70ed-4cf9-9433-11db9e1a27df/MS_Classroom.png?t=1794435831"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Having said that, Microsoft Classroom certainly is starting with a traditional left-column LMS approach. On one hand, this starting place could be intended to make colleges and universities more comfortable with considering alternate solutions, but on the other hand, this seems like a missed opportunity to get people excited about a significantly simplified user experience.</p><div class="image"><img alt="Traditional generic LMS interface, with left column of modules and tool options" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/1b351a62-1655-44e9-b0cd-c831097b579d/LMS_Structure.jpg?t=1785800892"/></div><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="getting-the-obvious-out-of-the-way">Getting the obvious out of the way</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Really, you had to name your product Classroom despite the long-term usage of Google Classroom as a quasi-LMS? I don’t know if this move was intentional to gum up the brand recognition that Google has built up (and apparently not protected with trademarks), or if it is lazy marketing. But from a market perspective it is not helpful.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="why-microsoft-classroom-is-differen">Why Microsoft Classroom is different from Teams</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Microsoft has offered many of the ingredients of an LMS through MS Teams for years. You <i>could</i> patch together assignments, grading, notebooks, and collaboration into something resembling an LMS. This is similar to Google Wave and other historical Big Tech offerings, but who wants to do that when purpose-built alternatives exist?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Microsoft Classroom appears to be an attempt to address that product-design problem with a dedicated instructional experience. Microsoft says Teams for Education and its LMS integrations will continue. We will have to see how coherent the new product is and how seriously Microsoft addresses higher-ed requirements.</p><div class="image"><img alt="Diagram of Microsoft 365 Eduction offerings, including Classroom, traditional LTI integration, and MS Teams for Education" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0e69e7db-dc45-4a83-8117-7bb35c3fda29/Screenshot_2026-11-11_at_3.21.27_PM.png?t=1794435706"/></div><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="why-microsoft-classroom-is-differen">Why Microsoft Classroom is different from Google Classroom</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Google Classroom provides another useful comparison. It has had a major impact on the K–12 LMS market. But, as <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/google-classroom-as-an-lms-the-company-ups-the-ante-in-education?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=microsoft-classroom-is-worth-watching" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">I have covered before</a>, Google has largely chosen not to address the higher-ed administrative use cases and go-to-market requirements necessary to compete for the institutional LMS market. Microsoft is signaling higher-ed ambitions from the outset.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That raises an interesting possibility beyond Microsoft’s own product. For Big Tech, an LMS can be a gateway drug: introduce students to an ecosystem of productivity and AI tools, and potentially keep them as users throughout their working lives. Could Microsoft Classroom push Google to become more aggressive with Classroom in higher ed?</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="expected-pricing-model">Expected pricing model</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">From my reading of the announcement and the <a class="link" href="https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/training/educator-center/instructor-materials/microsoft-365-education-frequently-asked-questions?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=microsoft-classroom-is-worth-watching" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">MS Education licensing FAQ</a>, Microsoft plans to <b>bundle Classroom with its paid Microsoft 365 Education A2, A3, A5, and A7 licenses</b>, rather than announce a separate LMS subscription price. For institutions whose faculty and students already have eligible licenses, the application would be included at no additional charge. That gives Microsoft a potentially powerful way to get Classroom into institutions that already use its products, even if they have an existing LMS. The preview is planned for early 2027.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The qualifier is that <b>bundled is not the same as free for every institution or student</b>. Classroom is not listed as part of Microsoft’s new no-cost A0 student offering, and Microsoft is also restructuring its education licensing, including retiring Office 365 A1 and the Student Use Benefit at applicable renewals beginning in 2028. The real cost will depend on which licenses an institution needs for its faculty and students and the terms of its agreement.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is not dissimilar to Google Classroom’s pricing that is tied to broader bundling licenses, and that product has influenced K-12 market pricing but not higher ed pricing. So the issue to me is market penetration as a standalone LMS, not pricing per se.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="worth-watching-but-dont-overreact">Worth watching, but don’t overreact</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Not only has the LMS product category been resilient, but we have also had the same Big Four solutions for approximately 15 years—Instructure Canvas, D2L Brightspace (although with a new name), Blackboard LMS, and Moodle. And these vendors have not been resting on their laurels, and they have each made their own AI investments, although not providing AI models. This is not an easy market to change in terms of vendors, even if Big Tech clearly has the resources to change the vendor mix (as we have already seen with Google Classroom in the K-12 market). But will that happen in the next few years?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We do not know yet. But that is why this announcement deserves attention. The LMS category could remain quite stable while AI changes which companies compete in it, what they offer, and why they want to be there.</p><div class="image"><a class="image__link" href="https://philhillaa.com/oet-team-inquiry/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=microsoft-classroom-is-worth-watching" rel="noopener" target="_blank"><img alt="On EdTech+ Team access" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/4fb2b370-cfb8-44f1-abca-d452d4b4bca9/On_EdTech%2B_Team_access.png?t=1793296580"/></a></div><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>The main On EdTech newsletter is free to share in part or in whole. All we ask is attribution.</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Thanks for being a subscriber.</i></p></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=6cee2efd-dec9-46df-9cbc-1209bfb24f8c&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Interesting Reads This Week</title>
  <description>Assessment, student navigation, and the dangers of automating a mess</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/76198ad5-068c-43b5-997c-78ee592700c1/Three_Bromides_of_AI_Learning.png" length="1613481" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261107</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261107</guid>
  <pubDate>Sat, 07 Nov 2026 17:54:51 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-11-07T17:54:51Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Glenda Morgan</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Labor Market Outcomes]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Teaching And Learning]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Academic Integrity]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Ai]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="On EdTech+ logo" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0668f4be-a68a-44a2-8ad9-ef042f83dc62/onedtechpluslogo-1200x630.png"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b><i>Due to the importance of the first topic on AI and assessment, I am sharing the full first section in front of the paywall. [-Phil]</i></b></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">For those of us in the US, that was quite a week. Somewhere between the polls, the results, and the election postmortems, I even managed to read a little about EdTech.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="what-does-assessment-actually-asses">What does assessment actually assess?</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I finally got around to reading Wonkhe&#39;s <a class="link" href="https://wonkhe.com/media/2026/03/Trained-to-stop-learning-F.pdf?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">report</a> on assessment, and I should have read it earlier because it&#39;s really good.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Assessment has become one of the most fraught areas of higher education&#39;s encounter with AI. It is where some of the technology&#39;s most troubling consequences, including cheating and cognitive offloading, are playing out. It is also where some of our worst institutional instincts are on display, from increased surveillance to ham-fisted attempts at detection and punishment. And, perhaps most interestingly, AI is exposing longstanding weaknesses in how we assess learning, raising uncomfortable questions about what our assessments actually measure and whether they were doing a particularly good job of it in the first place.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Based on a large survey of UK higher education students, supplemented by focus groups, Wonkhe’s report gets beneath the AI adoption statistics that fill my inbox every week. The researchers ask whether students believe they have learned what their assessments supposedly demonstrate, whether grades reflect their understanding, and what influences their decisions about using AI.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The authors describe some of the findings as &quot;uncomfortable,&quot; and I can see why. Almost half of students (47%) worry that their grades don&#39;t fully reflect what they know, while 38% say they sometimes submit work they cannot fully explain without going back to their sources.</p><div class="image"><a class="image__link" href="https://wonkhe.com/media/2026/03/Trained-to-stop-learning-F.pdf?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" rel="noopener" target="_blank"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/b379c253-6487-4344-b625-e9a6dc9157cf/Screenshot_2026-11-07_at_10.27.30_AM.png?t=1794073257"/></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One of the most interesting findings concerns what students believe their courses reward. Only around one in five think their courses primarily reward thinking and reasoning rather than producing outputs such as essays or exam answers. As one computing undergraduate put it:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">“We learn how to implement, rather than think and if we graduated with only the stuff we learnt inside the curriculum, nothing good would come out of us&quot; – Undergraduate, computing</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>And this appears to matter for AI use. Among students who say their courses primarily reward final outputs, 71% report using AI for assessment. Among those who say their courses primarily reward thinking and reasoning, the figure is 38%.</b></p><div class="image"><a class="image__link" href="https://wonkhe.com/media/2026/03/Trained-to-stop-learning-F.pdf?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" rel="noopener" target="_blank"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/abe0ea12-bcd2-4cb4-b72e-171c8e7b4142/Screenshot_2026-11-07_at_10.27.51_AM.png?t=1794073268"/></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That&#39;s a substantial difference, although we should be careful about interpreting it. The study doesn&#39;t establish that emphasizing thinking and reasoning causes students to use AI less. But it does suggest that students&#39; perceptions of what their courses value are associated with how they approach AI.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The report also finds that students who understand their assessment criteria report substantially less AI use than those who find the criteria unclear. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">What I particularly like about this research is that it shifts our attention away from simply identifying which students are using AI and toward examining how the design of courses and assessments might influence their behavior.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The report is especially useful because it offers concrete recommendations that go beyond the usual invocation of one of the Three Bromides of AI in Learning: design more authentic assessments (the other two being &quot;keep a human in the loop&quot; and &quot;we need more AI literacy&quot;).</p><div class="image"><img alt="Satirical illustration titled “The Three Bromides of AI in Learning,” showing three weary figures riding donkeys through a barren landscape under cloudy skies. A knight in rusty armor represents “Authentic Assessment,” a disheveled cowboy represents “Human in the Loop,” and an elderly, bearded sage in threadbare robes represents “AI Literacy.” All three look dejected, parodying the familiar recommendations repeatedly offered as solutions to AI challenges in education." class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/b4c1b96a-c192-4db2-afbf-c186d2847f9e/Three_Bromides_of_AI_Learning.png?t=1793991556"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Created with ChatGPT</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Instead, the authors emphasize what they call &quot;accountability moments&quot;: opportunities within assessment when students must actively demonstrate their understanding. The idea is to make thinking visible <i>during</i> the learning process rather than relying entirely on a final product. They also emphasize timely, actionable feedback so that students can use it to improve their work, rather than receiving comments after the opportunity to learn from them has passed. Formative assessment should actually be formative, rather than summative assessment in disguise.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I like these recommendations, although the report is less helpful on how to introduce accountability moments at scale, particularly in large courses with limited faculty capacity.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Another intriguing finding concerns belonging. I usually encounter belonging in the student success literature, where it is associated with persistence and the likelihood of stopping out. Here, the researchers find that students&#39; sense of belonging is associated with striking differences in how they perceive AI and its potential benefits.</p><div class="image"><a class="image__link" href="https://wonkhe.com/media/2026/03/Trained-to-stop-learning-F.pdf?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" rel="noopener" target="_blank"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/f9f9e5f9-f7df-4fef-b65e-644e57924919/Screenshot_2026-11-07_at_10.30.02_AM.png?t=1794073286"/></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The differences are striking. Among students who strongly disagree that they belong to a community, 98% agree that AI helps them learn more, compared with just 28% of students who strongly agree that they belong. These findings concern students&#39; perceptions of AI&#39;s benefits as much as their actual use of it.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The authors suggest that students who feel they belong may be less inclined to turn to AI because their educational experience already provides some of what AI substitutes for. I find that fascinating, although the evidence doesn&#39;t establish that belonging itself causes these differences. Students who feel a stronger sense of belonging may also differ in their engagement, motivation, academic experiences, or access to support. Still, I appreciate that the researchers are looking beyond individual decisions about whether to use AI and considering how the educational environment might shape those decisions.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The report is a welcome contribution to a conversation about assessment. <b>If AI finally forces us to reconsider what our assessments reward and whether they genuinely demonstrate learning, something worthwhile might come out of this.</b></p><div class="paywall"><hr class="paywall__break"/><div class="paywall__content"><h2 class="paywall__header"> Subscribe to Premium to read the rest. </h2><p class="paywall__description"> Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to the rest of this post. </p><p class="paywall__links"><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Upgrade</a> Translation missing: en.app.shared.conjuction.or <a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Sign In</a></p></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=a97c2252-2267-44d4-9b8d-9d41e52d45d9&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>The Midterms Didn&#39;t Fix Higher Ed&#39;s Math</title>
  <description>Federal gridlock, bipartisan policy pressures, and an AI backlash with real consequences for EdTech.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/266b1fda-72a0-439b-8ea7-f163131229ea/Screenshot_2026-11-05_at_1.08.07_PM.png" length="242732" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/the-midterms-didnt-fix-higher-ed-math</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/the-midterms-didnt-fix-higher-ed-math</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 05 Nov 2026 21:04:06 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-11-05T21:04:06Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Regulatory Analysis]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Hei Finances]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Ai]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0668f4be-a68a-44a2-8ad9-ef042f83dc62/onedtechpluslogo-1200x630.png"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-midterms-didn-t-fix-higher-ed-s-math" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-midterms-didn-t-fix-higher-ed-s-math" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I want to cautiously wade into this week’s big question: what do the midterm results mean for higher education and EdTech? These are initial observations, focused on topics we’ve been covering at On EdTech and several implications I’m not seeing enough of in the education trade press. The election changed the political landscape, but how much it changes the conditions facing institutions is another matter.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/266b1fda-72a0-439b-8ea7-f163131229ea/Screenshot_2026-11-05_at_1.08.07_PM.png?t=1793911058"/></div><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="federal-gridlock-does-not-undo-the-">Federal gridlock does not undo the law</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Democrats winning control of the House and Senate will change Washington’s agenda. My expectation for the next two years, however, is <b>plenty of hearings and headlines, with relatively little change to the core education legislation already passed.</b> President Trump retains his veto, and the administration retains substantial executive authority. Legislative gridlock does not mean an end to disruptive federal actions.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">As I argued last year in <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/it-s-not-loan-limits-or-accountability-or-pell-it-s-the-combination?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-midterms-didn-t-fix-higher-ed-s-math" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">“It’s Not Loan Limits or Accountability or Pell, It’s the Combination,”</a> much of the policy affecting institutional planning is now in statute. The new borrowing limits, phaseout of Grad PLUS, and earnings-based accountability framework cannot simply disappear through another turn of regulatory ping-pong. Institutions should stop building plans around the hope that Congress will undo these financial constraints.</p><div class="paywall"><hr class="paywall__break"/><div class="paywall__content"><h2 class="paywall__header"> Subscribe to Premium to read the rest. </h2><p class="paywall__description"> Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to the rest of this post. </p><p class="paywall__links"><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-midterms-didn-t-fix-higher-ed-s-math">Upgrade</a> Translation missing: en.app.shared.conjuction.or <a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-midterms-didn-t-fix-higher-ed-s-math">Sign In</a></p></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=835de2c4-87ac-485f-bbda-fae1d4ad3abd&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Three Observations on NSC Fall 2026 Enrollment Data</title>
  <description>The &#39;undergrad enrollment holding steady&#39; narrative misses some important data signals</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/5c561f71-5443-4516-bfc2-7b626ef84d60/UG_Enrollment_Trend_Peak_YoY_20261029.png" length="462009" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data</guid>
  <pubDate>Tue, 03 Nov 2026 17:24:11 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-11-03T17:24:11Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Dual Enrollment]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Hei Finances]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Enrollment Analysis]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/d03d9e27-4cad-42c7-a9b6-bec78b49dcb0/OET-poweredby-logo2025.png?t=1757446904"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Last week the big news in US higher education was the release of National Student Clearinghouse’s (NSC’s) <a class="link" href="https://nscresearchcenter.org/prelim-fall-enrollment-trends/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">preliminary Fall 2026</a> enrollment data.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Preliminary fall 2026 data show total postsecondary enrollment holding steady compared to last fall (+0.2%). Undergraduate enrollment is up 0.6 percent, with little change at public and private nonprofit 4-year institutions (+0.3% and 0.0%, respectively). Community colleges are the only sector showing growth, with undergraduate enrollment increasing 1.2 percent.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Accordingly, this news was presented in the media.</p><ul><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Forbes: <a class="link" href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltnietzel/2026/10/29/college-enrollment-holding-steady-according-to-preliminary-report/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">National College Enrollment Holds Steady, According To Preliminary Report</a></p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Chronicle: <a class="link" href="https://www.chronicle.com/article/in-first-year-of-demographic-cliff-fall-undergraduate-enrollment-held-steady?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">In First Year of ‘Demographic Cliff,’ Fall Undergraduate Enrollment Held Steady</a></p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Inside Higher Ed: <a class="link" href="https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2026/10/29/preliminary-enrollment-data-shows-slower-growth?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Preliminary Enrollment Data Shows Slower Growth</a></p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Higher Ed Dive: <a class="link" href="https://www.highereddive.com/news/undergraduate-enrollment-inched-up-this-fall-while-masters-dips-37/873114/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Undergraduate enrollment inched up this fall, while master’s dips 3.7%</a></p></li></ul><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The coverage reports the slowdown. The larger question is what that slowdown marks. Taking a broader look at trends and looking at age composition shows some different headlines. <b>My read is that 2026 marks the transition from the post-pandemic recovery toward renewed enrollment decline. Whether this fall ultimately finishes slightly positive or slightly negative is secondary to the direction of travel.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">While this reading is much more negative in outlook than the public reports, it is important to deal with the data reality we are given. For this post I’m focusing just on undergraduate data, with three observations.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="trending-to-decline">Trending to Decline</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Higher ed undergraduate enrollments tend to move in multi-year trends, and if you look at the past 15 years, you can see a few distinct time frames.</p><ul><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">From 2012–2019 we had an almost linear decline of roughly 0.5%–1.5% per year.</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">From 2020–2022 we had a nonlinear Covid-driven decline.</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">From 2023–2024 (and really part of 2022) we had a recovery in aggregate enrollments post-Covid and with improved retention rates.</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Beyond 2024 we are seeing a trend away from 3.5% growth (based on IPEDS data) towards decline, with the crossover coming roughly this year. This does not appear to be a linear trend but something closer to a linear change in growth/decline rates.</p></li></ul><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/5c561f71-5443-4516-bfc2-7b626ef84d60/UG_Enrollment_Trend_Peak_YoY_20261029.png?t=1793720801"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The precise turning year matters less than the end of the recovery and the conditions institutions will face afterward. We need to be ready for this decline, which has been predicted for a long time.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="demographic-cliff-reality">Demographic Cliff Reality</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The “cliff” part of the demographic cliff argument has too often been overstated, but the core argument <a class="link" href="https://www.bbc.com/reel/video/p0n1vxgk/watch?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">from Nathan Grawe</a> is important. Demographic analysis on domestic births and enrollment shows a long-term decline in domestic 18-year-olds ready to enter college, starting in 2025/26 and likely going through 2039.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The decline in childbirths began with the Great Recession in roughly 2008, and 18 years later, here we are. Adult student populations, increases in immediate college enrollments, and better retention rates can offset these numbers, but absent a massive change in those numbers, they can only dampen the impacts of the decline.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">WICHE’s <a class="link" href="https://www.wiche.edu/knocking/data-visualizations/graduates/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Knocking at the College Door</a> data series has tracked these numbers, and their latest forecast shows the decline in harder numbers.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/52c45565-4fad-4f2f-8d0b-91009a4c3b12/Screenshot_2026-11-03_at_10.56.57_AM.png?t=1793721590"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Projected US high school graduates: percent change from 2023</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Here you can see the peak in 2025 and the long-term expected decline of high school graduates.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="the-gains-come-from-dual-enrollment">The Gains Come From Dual Enrollment</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">High school dual enrollment, roughly captured by NSC as those 17 years or younger, increased yet again, by 3.9%. No other age group came close. The demographic pressure arrives through entering cohorts and then works through the enrolled population over several years. Aggregate enrollment need not immediately turn negative for that pressure to matter.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/fad8adef-2a78-493a-941f-ea166df86f21/Screenshot_2026-11-03_at_11.03.19_AM.png?t=1793721819"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Note that the 2.4% increase in Fall 2025 came from preliminary data, whereas the 1.2% in the first chart came from end-of-term data.</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The Community College Research Center (CCRC) estimates roughly 3.1 million dual enrollment students. 3.9% of that is roughly 120,000. The NSC-reported 0.6% gain of the roughly 16.6 million total undergraduates is roughly 100,000.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Without dual enrollment gains, total undergraduate enrollments would already be in decline.</b> And keep in mind that dual enrollment is a pull-forward effect—these students will not be new undergraduates when they graduate; they are already in the numbers.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="keep-up-the-improvements-but-base-a">Keep Up the Improvements, but Base Assumptions on Reality</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">There have been worthwhile improvements in student retention, graduation rates, and expanding access to adult students. Those are all important and should continue. And it is important to note that aggregate growth or decline rates are not distributed equally—there will be winners and losers in terms of institutions and geographic locations.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But at the end of the day, I think there are some important trends we are seeing with recent enrollment data that can be hidden by the ‘enrollment is steady’ narrative. Institutions should keep improving access and retention. But they should build their enrollment assumptions around a recovery that is running out of momentum. Finishing slightly above zero in Fall 2026 would offer little reassurance about the years ahead.</p><div class="image"><a class="image__link" href="https://philhillaa.com/contact-us/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=three-observations-on-nsc-fall-2026-enrollment-data" rel="noopener" target="_blank"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/b2ae30e7-0485-4bc8-bac8-63fb1b56cdec/Speaking_ad.png?t=1793719278"/></a></div><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>The main On EdTech newsletter is free to share in part or in whole. All we ask is attribution.</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Thanks for being a subscriber.</i></p></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=357e96af-1313-4604-b5c1-1ac46b690975&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Interesting Reads This Week</title>
  <description>The super model edition</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/c425a320-bd98-45d9-9286-e2137f6a4315/Screenshot_2026-10-30_at_13-42-01_AI_report_Sep_2026.pdf.png" length="121008" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261031</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261031</guid>
  <pubDate>Sat, 31 Oct 2026 17:38:52 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-31T17:38:52Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Glenda Morgan</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Teaching And Learning]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Edtech Research]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Online Education]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Academic Integrity]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Ai]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class='paywall'><div class='paywall__content'><h2 class='paywall__header'>Premium Content</h2><p class='paywall__description'>This content is reserved for premium subscribers of On EdTech+. To Access this and other great posts, consider upgrading to premium.</p><p class='paywall__links'><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Upgrade</a><span class="translation_missing" title="translation missing: en.templates.posts.rss.link_conjuction">Link Conjuction</span><a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Sign In</a></p><div class='paywall__upsell'><div class='paywall__upsell_header'><h3>A subscription gets you:</h3></div><ul class='paywall__upsell_features'><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'> New content 3-4 times per week </li><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'> Shared Q&A discussions </li><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'> More coming soon </li><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'></li></ul></div></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=6391b3ff-f519-4da6-ac53-54a1a7828c62&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>EdTech’s Cybersecurity Reckoning</title>
  <description>The Canvas breach was an early marker of a new reality. PHP2Shell shows why EdTech’s move toward managed services will accelerate.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/a15cf5d2-89c5-4131-87ea-fb09fc9b1e0e/AI_Hacker_Wrestling.jpg" length="828984" type="image/jpeg"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2026 21:04:10 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-29T21:04:10Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/d03d9e27-4cad-42c7-a9b6-bec78b49dcb0/OET-poweredby-logo2025.png?t=1757446904"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In June I wrapped up my coverage of the Canvas data breach with <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/who-finds-the-flaws-first?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">a post about AI,</a> cybersecurity, and the new world we had entered. My argument was that increasingly capable agentic AI represented a paradigm shift in the economics of attacking software.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Reading a large codebase closely enough to find detailed weaknesses was never impossible. For a target like EdTech, however, it was usually not worth the time, because the data was only moderately valuable and the labor was real and better spent elsewhere. What changed last year is not that the work became possible but that it became cheap, and cheap enough to move attacking a mid-value sector out of what was often in the “not worth it” column and into the “worth it” one. The capability had been visible earlier, in autonomous systems that were already finding real vulnerabilities and outscoring human researchers through 2025, but the broad, low-cost, reliable version is recent. <b>It is the cost, and not the novelty, that moves the calculation.</b></p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I concluded that post with a warning.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The new game is already being played. EdTech is in it whether or not the community has fully registered the change.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Last week’s disclosure of two critical vulnerabilities in PHP, the software underlying much of higher education’s web infrastructure, provides clarity on this argument. Researchers involved in the discovery of the vulnerabilities <a class="link" href="https://www.wiz.io/blog/php2shell-php-rce?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">describe using AI</a> to turn longstanding weaknesses into working exploits and adapt them across applications in hours. The connection to AI is explicit, and so is the change in what becomes practical.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The immediate response involved emergency patches, disrupted services, and universities and hosting providers taking systems offline. My view is that we should read this as a significant marker of a broader change in EdTech. The assumptions that made it reasonable for a college, department, or individual faculty member to operate a public-facing application are breaking down.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Higher education has a particularly large exposure because so much of its technology grew through local initiative: someone built a useful tool, installed an open-source application, or kept a departmental website running. That approach delivered considerable value and fit the education ethos, but it also distributed responsibility for maintaining and defending software across multiple teams and individuals with very different capabilities.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>I believe we are entering a period that will significantly accelerate the move toward managed services, shared infrastructure, and restrictions on locally operated applications exposed to the public internet,</b> particularly for under-resourced institutions. This reaches into budgets, institutional autonomy, and the ways educational technology gets built and delivered—well beyond the immediate work of a CIO responding to a security alert.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/a15cf5d2-89c5-4131-87ea-fb09fc9b1e0e/AI_Hacker_Wrestling.jpg?t=1781644046"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>AI also seems to anthropomorphize EdTech as Marky Mark for some reason</p></span></div></div><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="where-php-lives-in-ed-tech">Where PHP Lives in EdTech</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Wiz Research, one of the groups that reported the PHP vulnerabilities, estimates that PHP powers about 70% of websites. <a class="link" href="https://w3techs.com/technologies/segmentation/tld-edu-/programming_language?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">W3Techs finds PHP on 79.1% of .edu websites whose server-side programming language it can identify</a>. That is a large footprint, though neither figure tells us who maintains those installations.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">PHP sits underneath the application itself, creating a dependency that is easy to overlook. Addressing PHP2Shell means installing a fixed PHP build, including a vendor backport where available, and checking that the application still works. For older applications, that may require an application upgrade first.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">PHP runs much of the campus web and one of the major LMS families. Moodle and related platforms such as Totara and Open LMS use it, as do other open-source learning systems including ILIAS, Stud.IP, and Open eClass. Beyond the LMS, WordPress and Drupal power campus and departmental websites, while tools such as REDCap, Open Journal Systems, and Omeka support research and scholarship. The applications have different owners and maintenance arrangements, even when they share the same underlying language.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">According to <a class="link" href="https://stats.moodle.org/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Moodle’s registered-site statistics</a>, about a quarter of registered Moodle sites run Moodle 4.1 LTS or older. Those branches cannot run any of PHP’s officially patched 8.2-or-newer releases. Operators on older versions need a distribution or long-term-support vendor backport, or they need to upgrade Moodle before moving to a supported PHP release. That is why “run the update” can become an unplanned project.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/19e7d10f-d323-44e3-baa5-a8bdf1bcbb55/Screenshot_2026-10-29_at_11.27.39_AM.png?t=1793298514"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Percentage of registered Moodle sites worldwide using specific versions</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Moodle HQ (which runs the Moodle ecosystem) put out this message in <a class="link" href="https://moodle.org/mod/forum/discuss.php?d=482882&utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">a forum post</a>.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">As a precautionary measure in response to the PHP2SHELL vulnerability, which was made public on October 21, 2026, Moodle HQ made the decision to take our sites offline. You may notice that our public facing sites were inaccessible for a period of time, but are back online or coming back online now.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Patches to address this vulnerability have been released. We have patched this site and brought it back online. We are continuing to deploy and validate the patches on our other public facing and client sites and will continue to bring sites back online as quickly as possible.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We strongly encourage self-hosted site holders to notify the individual(s) responsible for updating PHP for their sites and to create a plan to update your PHP with the released security patches, immediately.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Unpatched sites remain vulnerable to potential exploits related to PHP2SHELL.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The managed-hosting response shows both the capacity and the disruption involved. <a class="link" href="https://eledia.de/en/sicherheitsluecke-in-php-warum-wir-alle-von-eledia-verwalteten-lernplattformen-vorsorglich-offline-genommen-haben/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">eLeDia took its managed learning platforms offline</a> on October 21 and reported 99% restored that evening. <a class="link" href="https://status.openlms.net/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Open LMS took customer sites offline</a> and reported the last sites patched and restored late on October 22. In each case, an identifiable operator could act across its customers, even though that meant interrupting access.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Other major EdTech systems, including Canvas, Blackboard Learn, and Brightspace, do not run on PHP. That distinction matters for this particular vulnerability. For the larger argument, the question is who can identify and maintain each layer of an application when the next vulnerability appears.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="the-departmental-tail">The Departmental Tail</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Learning management systems and central campus websites usually have identifiable operators. Departments, labs, libraries, and research centers also run smaller applications built to solve local problems. Those tools can persist long after the project team changes, and the person responsible for the application may have little control over the software underneath it.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">When a critical vulnerability appears, someone still has to find each tool, identify the version actually serving it, determine a patch path, and decide whether it can remain on the public internet while that work happens.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In spot checks of public room-booking systems, I found a <a class="link" href="https://ccrma.stanford.edu/rooms/help.php?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Stanford CCRMA installation</a> reporting PHP 5.3.3 on an operating-system generation that has been out of support for years, while <a class="link" href="https://www.as.utexas.edu/meeting/help.php?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">UT Austin Astronomy</a> reported PHP 7.2.24, a branch whose upstream support ended in 2020. These are small, useful applications—the kind someone set up to solve a local problem and that may have kept working long after the people or assumptions behind the original installation changed. Public version information cannot establish whether a particular server was compromised, and some vendors backport security fixes without changing the reported PHP version, but the examples expose the operating question colleges now face. Who knows each of these applications exists, who owns the full stack beneath it, and who can act quickly when a critical flaw appears? A departmental tool can be inexpensive to create and valuable for years, while the continuing work of keeping it safe on the public internet remains easy to overlook.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The comparison is <a class="link" href="https://neurocndm.mcgill.ca/reserve/help.php?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">McGill’s neuroscience center</a>, which runs an old version of the same room-booking software on a centrally maintained host that reported PHP 8.4.27, a release patched for PHP2Shell. The application did not have to be new for the underlying software to be current. What mattered was having someone responsible for that software.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Universities described the same divide in their emergency response. <a class="link" href="https://www.student.universiteitleiden.nl/en/announcements/2026/10/websites-vulnerable-due-to-global-vulnerability-issue-temporary-security-measures-in-place?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Leiden restricted affected faculty and institute websites</a> while its central sites remained available, and advised people running their own research or conference sites to take them offline. <a class="link" href="https://www.uni-marburg.de/de/hrz/aktuelles/nachrichten/2026/webdienste-eingeschraenkt-php2shell?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Marburg restricted numerous web services to campus or VPN access</a> and asked their operators to check whether the servers used PHP, update it if necessary, and report back before public access was restored. That is the departmental tail in practice: an institution trying to coordinate a response across services it does not operate as a unified action.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="the-end-of-the-internet">The End of the Internet</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><a class="link" href="https://stratechery.com/2026/the-end-of-the-internet/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Ben Thompson at Stratechery</a> described a similar shift through his own experience. He installed WordPress and configured PHP himself in 2003; today, his site runs on managed WordPress, and he says his provider had patched it before the vulnerability was publicly disclosed. Thompson argues that the old internet promise that anyone could put a server online and keep it there has become much harder to sustain in the age of AI. Higher education’s departmental applications are part of that same history, with institutional responsibilities attached.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Thompson also sees a future with more software created for individuals and small groups. For EdTech, that could mean more tools built close to the faculty, staff, and students who need them, while institutions take a more deliberate role in where those tools run and who maintains them. Managed platforms and restricted networks can support local invention, provided the institution still accounts for the risks of the applications and data it holds.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="where-we-stand">Where We Stand</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It is instructive to understand how AI has changed the economics of cybersecurity and that we are not dealing with new cases of poor software development. The PHP vulnerability has existed at least since version 5.4, released in 2012, with the original bug entering code <a class="link" href="https://deadneurons.substack.com/p/php2shell-explained-php2shell-was?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">in 2004</a>. What AI has done is make it cost-effective to find this long-hidden vulnerability.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">My take is that PHP2Shell and this new reality mark an acceleration in the restructuring of EdTech. Colleges and universities will still make local choices, use open-source software, and build tools for their own needs. But the ability to put an application on the public internet carries an operating obligation that is becoming much harder to sustain through spare capacity, occasional upgrades, and the knowledge of one helpful colleague. I expect that pressure to drive a substantial shift toward managed services and shared infrastructure, with the strongest pressure on the institutions and departments least able to fund continuous attention. The budget comparison increasingly has to include the full cost of keeping a service safely available.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The developments to watch will be the decisions made after this week’s patches are installed: which applications return under new management, which remain behind restricted access, and which disappear. At the same time, AI may enable a proliferation of small, <b>useful tools built close to the people who need them</b>. Those trends can happen together. <b>AI is making software easier to create while changing what it takes to operate it responsibly.</b> I think that combination will reshape EdTech far more than another round of cybersecurity guidance suggests.</p><div class="image"><a class="image__link" href="https://philhillaa.com/oet-team-inquiry/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" rel="noopener" target="_blank"><img alt="On EdTech+ Team offers shared premium analysis, research, and data tools. Explore Team access." class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/4fb2b370-cfb8-44f1-abca-d452d4b4bca9/On_EdTech%2B_Team_access.png?t=1793296580"/></a></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><a class="link" href="https://philhillaa.com/oet-team-inquiry/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=edtech-s-cybersecurity-reckoning" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Explore On EdTech+ Team access</a></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>The main On EdTech newsletter is free to share in part or in whole. All we ask is attribution.</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Thanks for being a subscriber.</i></p></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=a386cf5a-4f3e-4f62-a8b4-ef62afd78294&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>The SaaS Apocalypse Meets Actual Data</title>
  <description>What Stripe’s data and generative UI tell us about the future of EdTech</description>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/the-saas-apocalypse-meets-actual-data</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/the-saas-apocalypse-meets-actual-data</guid>
  <pubDate>Mon, 26 Oct 2026 20:18:41 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-26T20:18:41Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Labor Market]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Ai]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0668f4be-a68a-44a2-8ad9-ef042f83dc62/onedtechpluslogo-1200x630.png"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-saas-apocalypse-meets-actual-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-saas-apocalypse-meets-actual-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The “death of the LMS” and “SaaS apocalypse” arguments share an underlying assumption: AI makes software so easy to create that traditional software business models become obsolete. Morgan and I <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/the-report-of-the-lms-death-is-an-exaggeration?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-saas-apocalypse-meets-actual-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">challenged that argument for the LMS</a> last December, and I <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/ai-saas-and-edtech-survival?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-saas-apocalypse-meets-actual-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">extended the discussion to EdTech more broadly</a> in April. Institutions pay for dependable services, support, and ongoing development. The ability to generate code does not eliminate those needs.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Now <a class="link" href="https://www.stripeeconomics.com/p/the-saaspocalypse-was-more-like-a?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-saas-apocalypse-meets-actual-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Stripe’s business data</a> substantially undercut the market apocalypse argument. Across the SaaS businesses it tracks, growth has continued and even accelerated. This strengthens our argument about why the business model persists. But it also raises a more useful question: where should we look for AI to fundamentally change EdTech?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I think the bigger impact will come from redefining interfaces and experiences. In <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/the-left-column-isnt-permanent?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-saas-apocalypse-meets-actual-data" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">“The Left Column Isn’t Permanent,”</a> I described systems that build an experience around what someone needs to accomplish, instead of requiring users to navigate familiar screens and menus. Google’s work on <b>generative UI</b> gives that prediction clearer terminology and a concrete education example. Whether the changes come from incumbent vendors, startups, or bespoke university projects, this is where I expect the more significant impact: changing how people use EdTech, well beyond making existing product designs cheaper to reproduce.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>SaaS EdTech product categories will likely survive even in the interface through which users access the system changes significantly.</b></p><div class="paywall"><hr class="paywall__break"/><div class="paywall__content"><h2 class="paywall__header"> Subscribe to Premium to read the rest. </h2><p class="paywall__description"> Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to the rest of this post. </p><p class="paywall__links"><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-saas-apocalypse-meets-actual-data">Upgrade</a> Translation missing: en.app.shared.conjuction.or <a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=the-saas-apocalypse-meets-actual-data">Sign In</a></p></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=b0f891b6-3071-4660-baf9-96e3a38a9f25&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Interesting Reads This Week</title>
  <description>Who is responsible for making teaching better?</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/1e3bad02-65dd-47ec-b850-33aefdc08568/Screenshot_2026-10-24_at_10.53.17_AM.png" length="353321" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-a682</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-a682</guid>
  <pubDate>Sat, 24 Oct 2026 18:49:59 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-24T18:49:59Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Glenda Morgan</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Regulatory Analysis]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Teaching And Learning]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0668f4be-a68a-44a2-8ad9-ef042f83dc62/onedtechpluslogo-1200x630.png"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I have been writing <i>Interesting Reads This Week</i> for more than three years, which means I have now exhausted weather, travel, animals, and most of my other reliable opening devices. Fortunately, higher education continues to produce things to write about.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="when-bad-teaching-is-still-satisfac">When bad teaching is still satisfactory</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The Office of the Legislative Auditor General of the Utah Legislature released a performance <a class="link" href="https://pf.utleg.gov/olag/reports/audits/2026/fd5ceb89-2542-4607-b5ad-abfc14175d90/2026-31_RPT.pdf?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">audit</a> of tenured faculty at the 16 public colleges and universities in the Utah System of Higher Education (USHE). There is plenty in the report with which I disagree, including some of its recommendations. <b>But buried in what is ostensibly an audit of faculty accountability is something much more interesting: an unusual window into how universities determine whether teaching is good enough.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">And for me this isn’t about Utah. I suspect many of the problems documented here could be found at public and private institutions anywhere. They raise uncomfortable questions about how institutions evaluate teaching, respond when it isn’t working, and, ultimately, improve it.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The part I found fascinating was the qualitative evidence. The auditors examined 666 (yes, really) post-tenure reviews conducted since the new requirements took effect. Of those, 658 rated teaching satisfactory and only eight found it unsatisfactory. But the auditors also identified 40 cases in which faculty had been rated satisfactory despite what the auditors considered “concerning evidence” about their teaching.</p><div class="paywall"><hr class="paywall__break"/><div class="paywall__content"><h2 class="paywall__header"> Subscribe to Premium to read the rest. </h2><p class="paywall__description"> Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to the rest of this post. </p><p class="paywall__links"><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Upgrade</a> Translation missing: en.app.shared.conjuction.or <a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Sign In</a></p></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=1bf6f3ca-1a0d-4f93-a62b-78d028153613&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Efficacy Starts With the Institution, Not the Tool</title>
  <description>Maryland’s AI study raises questions its leaders should be answering about their own decisions</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/a1d0e4ab-4949-4ccc-b22e-852ca36a3195/Screenshot_2026-10-21_at_8.20.41_PM.png" length="194067" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 22 Oct 2026 14:57:38 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-22T14:57:38Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
    <dc:creator>Glenda Morgan</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Edtech Research]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Ai]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/d03d9e27-4cad-42c7-a9b6-bec78b49dcb0/OET-poweredby-logo2025.png?t=1757446904"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Two weeks ago, Morgan and I wrote <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">“An AI Tutor Study That Barely Tested Tutoring”</a> about the University of Maryland study making the rounds, building on Morgan’s <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261003?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">earlier coverage</a>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In a nutshell, UMD billed its study as a test of AI tutoring, but it largely tested access to an answer-giving chatbot with little integration into teaching. Only about 15% of students offered the tool ever used it, and just two instructors ended the semester with tutoring mode enabled.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Our criticism focused on the research claims. But a </b><a class="link" href="https://today.umd.edu/study-suggests-more-guidance-needed-in-use-of-ai-course-assistants?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><b>recent interview</b></a><b> with UMD Provost Jennifer King Rice raises a more fundamental problem with the leadership decisions behind this initiative. What we missed is that Rice was the report’s senior author and the one who set up the initiative.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The Maryland study illustrates a common problem with how higher education evaluates EdTech: institutional implementation decisions are treated as background context when they are central to the results.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="this-came-from-the-top">This Came From the Top</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In the Maryland Today interview, Provost Rice describes the origin of the study and her role.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">We believe deeply in evidence-based practice and won’t rush AI technology into general use in the classroom until we know it works.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">So we decided that rather than roll this tool out to everyone just because we could, we should slow down and take the time to study it first. Last summer, I reached out to faculty members who have expertise in program evaluation and AI applications in education, and pulled them in alongside the team from DIT. We designed a study that used randomization to better understand the impact of the virtual study assistant on student learning and student engagement in course materials.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But a significant issue is that she is the chief academic officer at UMD which therefore raises the issue of institutional responsibility. The question is whether leadership applied the same scrutiny to its own implementation choices that it applied to the technology.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="instructional-support-was-missing">Instructional Support Was Missing</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">UMD (through its Department of Information Technology (DIT)) <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/university-of-maryland-report-as-chatbot-product-research?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">provided</a> an enormous amount of documentation, webinars, and training opportunities on technical implementation. How to enable the tool, how to configure it, how to receive reports, etc.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But the core implementation choice is that <b>UMD provided “no additional guidance for how [instructors] should incorporate the tool.”</b> Among responding treatment instructors, none reported incorporating it into tasks or assignments.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is EdTech 101. Tools are only valuable in supporting student learning if they are integrated into instructional practices. Rice and other authors know this truism, as the report itself called out [emphasis added].</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Together, these studies indicate that <b>GenAI’s educational effects depend on tutor configuration, instructional scaffolding, and realized engagement,</b> and that improvements during assisted practice may not necessarily translate into independent learning.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Secondarily, this statement also points out that educational effects depend on “realized engagement,” yet the report brushed off the 15% adoption rate of students in the treatment group.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Why wasn’t the initiative designed around the conditions the authors themselves identified as necessary?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>In the interview, Provost Rice acknowledged that “making AI tools available without providing faculty or students with clear guidance was not effective.”</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Our question is why that understanding did not shape the initiative from the beginning. The report’s research summary already called out the need for instructional scaffolding, thus the finding that simply making AI tools available without guidance was ineffective therefore looks less like a surprising research discovery than a foreseeable and even obvious consequence of the initiative&#39;s design.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>This was not a research discovery; it was a foreseeable flaw in the design of the initiative.</b></p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="institutional-execution-belongs-in-">Institutional Execution Belongs in the Efficacy Discussion</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This issue is not unique to the University of Maryland, but this study does provide useful clarity.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">For years, governments and education organizations have called on EdTech vendors to back up their promises with credible evidence, as seen in the U.S. Department of Education’s <a class="link" href="https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED641164&utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">2024 National Educational Technology Plan</a>, UNESCO’s <a class="link" href="https://www.unesco.org/gem-report/en/articles/unesco-issues-urgent-call-appropriate-use-technology-education?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">2023 Global Education Monitoring Report</a> , and Digital Promise’s <a class="link" href="https://digitalpromise.org/product-certifications/eeipledge/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=efficacy-starts-with-the-institution-not-the-tool" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Edtech Evidence & Integrity Pledge</a>. The common theme is pushing education leaders to require vendors to explain their products’ research foundations and prioritize tools with independent product certifications.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>However, there is too often a problem with how higher education asks the efficacy question. Too often efficacy questions are premised on an assumption that we are evaluating a relatively simple relationship:</b><br><br><b>Tool → Outcome → Evidence of Efficacy</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But EdTech does not produce outcomes on its own. Between acquiring a tool and measuring an outcome lie a whole series of institutional decisions. </p><ul><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">What educational problem are we trying to solve, and is this tool appropriate?</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">How will instructors incorporate it, and what support will they need?</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">How will students understand and use it?</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">How will we monitor what happens and respond?</p></li></ul><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>A more realistic model looks more like:</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Problem definition → Tool selection → Faculty support and curricular redesign → Student awareness and use → Measurement and adaptation → Outcomes → Evidence of efficacy</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is more difficult and messier than simply asking if a product “works.” But it is a more accurate representation of how EdTech actually functions and whether it produces, or fails to produce, results.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">And it doesn’t get vendors off the hook for developing products that have the potential for efficacy. Nor does it guarantee that good implementation will produce good outcomes and improve learning. <b>But it does mean that implementation and efficacy cannot be separated. If students barely use a tool, instructors do not integrate it into their teaching, and an institution does little in response to evidence that those things are happening, what exactly has been evaluated?</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That is why this study matters beyond Maryland. It is a particularly visible version of a common higher education problem.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>If institutions want to take efficacy seriously—and we sincerely hope that they do—their own decisions need to be part of the analysis.</b> Leaders need to define the problem, create the conditions for meaningful use, and adapt to what is happening. Measuring impact and outcomes is a critical part of establishing efficacy. But it cannot substitute for the institutional work required to produce the impacts and the outcomes in the first place.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Leaving faculty and students to figure things out for themselves is an implementation strategy—a spectacularly bad one.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="parting-thought">Parting Thought</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Academic leaders who demand evidence that EdTech works should expect the same scrutiny of their own decisions. Defining an educational purpose, supporting instructors, and responding to weak adoption are part of leading an initiative. Those responsibilities do not disappear because the evaluation uses randomization. In evidence-based practice, implementation and support and tools are interrelated.</p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>The main On EdTech newsletter is free to share in part or in whole. All we ask is attribution.</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Thanks for being a subscriber.</i></p></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=97623372-ea1c-4f28-8952-ba36700abaa0&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>A New Starting Point for Understanding Program Risk</title>
  <description>Introducing the Postsecondary Signals Program Risk Report, with an automatic 20% discount for eligible On EdTech+ subscribers</description>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/a-new-starting-point-for-understanding-program-risk</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/a-new-starting-point-for-understanding-program-risk</guid>
  <pubDate>Tue, 20 Oct 2026 19:25:49 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-20T19:25:49Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Regulatory Analysis]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Hei Finances]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0668f4be-a68a-44a2-8ad9-ef042f83dc62/onedtechpluslogo-1200x630.png"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-new-starting-point-for-understanding-program-risk" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-new-starting-point-for-understanding-program-risk" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>tl;dr—I’m releasing a new program risk report generator that provides institution-specific risk analysis coming from the new accountability and graduate loan limit rules for US higher education.</b></p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="the-strategic-program-review-impera">The Strategic Program-Review Imperative</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">A <a class="link" href="https://www.acenet.edu/News-Room/Pages/New-Survey-Federal-Student-Loan-Changes.aspx?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-new-starting-point-for-understanding-program-risk" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">new survey from ACE and five partner associations</a> captures the challenge facing graduate and professional education as the new federal loan rules take effect. Nearly one-third of respondents said their institutions, schools, or programs were still deciding what changes to make. The most requested information was benchmarking on how peer institutions are responding, selected by 45%. Half reported that students were more concerned about their finances than usual.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The survey shows the need to turn policy analysis into institutional strategy: understanding students’ financing gaps, assessing institutional aid options, and deciding where programs need closer attention.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Earnings accountability deserves the same institutional lens. An <a class="link" href="https://www.peer-center.org/research/limited-impact-earnings-based-accountability?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-new-starting-point-for-understanding-program-risk" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">October 14 analysis from the PEER Center</a> estimates that programs projected to fail the new standards enroll just 2.5% of federally aided students nationally. Its <a class="link" href="https://www.peer-center.org/s/PEER_Earnings-Based-Accountability_FINAL.pdf?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-new-starting-point-for-understanding-program-risk" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">detailed tables</a> nevertheless identify roughly 31,000 bachelor’s students and 37,000 master’s students receiving federal aid in programs projected to fail. Degree programs are part of this exposure, and the institutional impact can be far greater than national aggregates.</p><div class="paywall"><hr class="paywall__break"/><div class="paywall__content"><h2 class="paywall__header"> Subscribe to Premium to read the rest. </h2><p class="paywall__description"> Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to the rest of this post. </p><p class="paywall__links"><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-new-starting-point-for-understanding-program-risk">Upgrade</a> Translation missing: en.app.shared.conjuction.or <a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=a-new-starting-point-for-understanding-program-risk">Sign In</a></p></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=a4de5d9f-dd82-4037-bfb3-5d69b270cd31&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Interesting Reads This Week</title>
  <description>Looking past labels</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/d5037d63-fa4d-4a54-a3a2-f0fcca4b6e4f/Screenshot_2026-10-17_at_11.17.44_AM.png" length="317470" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261017</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261017</guid>
  <pubDate>Sat, 17 Oct 2026 19:31:00 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-17T19:31:00Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Glenda Morgan</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Ai]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0668f4be-a68a-44a2-8ad9-ef042f83dc62/onedtechpluslogo-1200x630.png"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The last remnants of Tropical Storm Rachel finally petered out here on the Wasatch Front this week, and we have crisp fall days and blue skies. As soon as I finish this post I’m headed to see some fall color, but what did I read this week?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Three things caught my attention: Silicon Valley&#39;s latest reinvention of the university, AI doing surprisingly sophisticated instructional design (with a catch), and organizations expecting AI to transform their industries while judging it mostly by how many hours it saves.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>There is perhaps a theme here. In all three cases, looking closely at what something actually does turns out to be rather more revealing than what people call it.</b></p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="silicon-valley-discovers-the-univer">Silicon Valley discovers the university</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">It seems like every week we get an announcement of a new alternative form of higher education or higher education-focused learning program. One of the most recent is the announcement of the Horowitz Andreessen Academy (HAA) by the venture capital firm Andreessen Horowitz. </p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">HAA will be a two-year residential <a class="link" href="https://eriktorenberg.substack.com/p/introducing-horowitz-andreessen-academy?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">program</a> in San Francisco for 50 students between the ages of 16 and 22, with the first cohort starting in fall 2027. The inaugural cohort will pay no tuition, although students will have to cover their living expenses in San Francisco. After that, the plan is to charge tuition comparable to an elite private university.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The ambition is considerably larger than creating another small educational program. HAA&#39;s founders position it as a future-focused alternative to a traditional higher education system they have been deeply critical of, and as a model that others might follow (per founder <a class="link" href="https://www.insidehighered.com/news/tech-innovation/teaching-learning/2026/09/24/silicon-valley-ai-academy-seeks-main-character?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Ben Horowitz</a>).</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">There needs to be a pioneer that shows the way on how to train someone into the new world.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That&#39;s a bold claim. But before declaring HAA either the future of higher education or a threat to it, there is a more basic question worth asking: how much of what it proposes is actually new?</p><div class="paywall"><hr class="paywall__break"/><div class="paywall__content"><h2 class="paywall__header"> Subscribe to Premium to read the rest. </h2><p class="paywall__description"> Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to the rest of this post. </p><p class="paywall__links"><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Upgrade</a> Translation missing: en.app.shared.conjuction.or <a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Sign In</a></p></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=3146f2a6-6daf-4edd-ad26-429b06c31d27&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Mixed Synchronicity and the Limits of Instructional Design</title>
  <description>As online learning incorporates more synchronous opportunities and AI capabilities, we need to rethink how much of the learning experience can—or should—be designed in advance.</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/1e6cc016-294a-4d51-803a-835717716773/Synchronicity.webp" length="56096" type="image/webp"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/mixed-synchronicity-and-the-limits-of-instructional-design</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/mixed-synchronicity-and-the-limits-of-instructional-design</guid>
  <pubDate>Fri, 16 Oct 2026 19:55:14 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-16T19:55:14Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/d03d9e27-4cad-42c7-a9b6-bec78b49dcb0/OET-poweredby-logo2025.png?t=1757446904"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=mixed-synchronicity-and-the-limits-of-instructional-design" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=mixed-synchronicity-and-the-limits-of-instructional-design" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Nicole Weber recently published an interesting OLC Insights article, <a class="link" href="https://onlinelearningconsortium.org/olc-insights/2026/10/do-asynchronous-courses-need-synchronous-sessions-to-succeed/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=mixed-synchronicity-and-the-limits-of-instructional-design" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Do Asynchronous Courses Need Synchronous Sessions to Succeed?</i></a>. She pushes back on the assertion that fully asynchronous courses need synchronous opportunities to truly support student success, drawing on her experience with asynchronous graduate programs and an institutional study of student, faculty, and administrator perceptions.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="border-radius:0px 0px 0px 0px;border-style:solid;border-width:0px 0px 0px 0px;box-sizing:border-box;border-color:#E5E7EB;" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/09b397f6-4c8a-446b-9b51-40ded7dfbbb9/Screenshot_2026-10-16_at_11.48.35_AM.png?t=1792176540"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">On one hand, I appreciate the discussion. I&#39;ve argued for years that we should stop treating synchronous and asynchronous as binary choices, and Weber acknowledges that synchronous activities can provide meaningful benefits. She also makes important points about preserving flexibility, avoiding mandatory sessions that create barriers, and respecting students&#39; circumstances.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>On the other hand, I think her article illustrates a broader problem with instructional design assumptions, one that will become increasingly important as AI changes the nature of learning experiences. It is the assumption of a priori design as ultimate virtue.</b></p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="a-familiar-discussion">A Familiar Discussion</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The opportunity to combine synchronous elements with asynchronous online courses is something I&#39;ve been tracking since at least 2021. In <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/the-synchronous-opportunity-wileys-2022-voice-of-the-online-learner-report?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=mixed-synchronicity-and-the-limits-of-instructional-design" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">2022, I highlighted Wiley research</a> showing that 79% of online learners were willing to participate in some synchronous sessions despite a strong preference for asynchronous formats. The <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/prospective-online-students-want-async-sync-mix?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=mixed-synchronicity-and-the-limits-of-instructional-design" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">2024 Risepoint survey</a> showed a similar pattern: 76% preferred asynchronous formats, but 74% were willing to participate in live sessions. <b>Student preference for asynchronous courses does not mean students want exclusively asynchronous experiences.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">At <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/lets-not-romanticize-2019-for-online-learning?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=mixed-synchronicity-and-the-limits-of-instructional-design" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">OLC Innovate 2022</a>, Joe Moreau and I discussed the need to avoid romanticizing pre-pandemic online education. One of my central arguments was that student engagement had long been an Achilles&#39; heel of online education and that the pandemic had exposed opportunities to improve it.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Later that year, during my <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/digital-education-summit-des22-keynote?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=mixed-synchronicity-and-the-limits-of-instructional-design" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Digital Education Summit keynote</a>, I suggested enabling students to organize their own synchronous group discussions, based on their schedules and needs. As I described the instructor&#39;s role:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I, as an instructor, am either helping them, monitoring them, or maybe not even directly involved.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The point wasn&#39;t simply to add more Zoom lectures. It was to provide opportunities for interaction and give space for students to decide how to use them.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="the-limits-of-a-priori-design">The Limits of a priori Design</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This brings me back to Weber&#39;s article and one of her five design principles in particular.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Synchronous time should be reserved for moments that cannot be done as effectively asynchronously.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">She also argues that synchronous activities should align with learning outcomes and justify the costs imposed on students. These are reasonable considerations, particularly for required activities. But there&#39;s an underlying assumption that deserves scrutiny: <b>How can designers know a priori which interactions will provide value, or even what that value might be?</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is where I see a form of design hubris, not just in Weber&#39;s argument but across much of the instructional design community. We assume that we can identify learning objectives, design the appropriate experiences, and specify how students should interact with content, instructors, and one another. We plan the learning experience in advance and expect students to follow the plan.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">ADDIE is a prime example. The familiar Analyze–Design–Develop–Implement–Evaluate framework helped organize the instructional design profession, but its structure also encourages an a priori mindset. Analyze the problem, design and develop the solution, implement it, and then evaluate. Even with iterative variations, the fundamental orientation is toward specifying learning experiences before students encounter them.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>The problem isn&#39;t simply how ADDIE gets implemented. Its structure makes overplanning appear virtuous.</b> Too often, the process itself becomes a proxy for quality: objectives mapped, activities aligned, templates completed, boxes checked. Going through the motions of instructional design is not evidence that learning occurred.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I&#39;m not arguing against intentional design. I&#39;m arguing against the assumption that designers can—or should—anticipate every meaningful learning interaction.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Consider those student-organized synchronous discussions. Perhaps students work through a difficult concept, discover unexpected applications, or develop peer-support relationships that continue throughout a program. The instructor may not have anticipated these outcomes, but that doesn&#39;t make them less valuable.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>The quality of design that we overemphasize so often is quite different than quality of the resulting learning experience. Sometimes good design means creating the conditions for learning without prescribing everything that happens.</b></p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="ai-makes-this-much-more-important">AI Makes This Much More Important</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The issue extends well beyond synchronous learning.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Much of the earlier generation of adaptive courseware assumed that designers could anticipate learning needs, develop appropriate interventions, and create predetermined pathways for students. Algorithms might select the pathway, but the possible experiences remained largely bounded by what had been designed a priori.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Generative AI changes that equation. These probabilistic systems can respond to unexpected questions, support exploration, and navigate learning needs that designers could never fully enumerate beforehand. They aren&#39;t inherently better at teaching, and their unpredictability introduces new risks, but they challenge the assumption that we must specify all useful learning interactions in advance.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This requires a different approach to instructional design, and particularly to <b>assessment of learning</b>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Giving learners more agency does not mean relaxing academic standards. Quite the opposite. <b>We should be less prescriptive about how students learn and far more demanding about demonstrating what they have learned.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Learning objectives and disciplinary standards remain essential. Instructors and designers need to focus much more attention on meaningful assessments that demonstrate actual understanding, reasoning, and the ability to apply knowledge. Not just completing activities, producing polished assignments, or passing quizzes that can increasingly be gamed with AI. We need credible evidence of mastery, including authentic demonstrations of learning, and the willingness to intervene when students are not meeting standards.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is not a return to social constructivist relativism, where learners simply determine what counts as knowledge. Students should have more control over their learning experiences, but that doesn&#39;t mean they determine the academic standards. Instructors remain responsible for setting those standards, assessing achievement, and improving courses based on evidence of what actually works.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Less control over the learning path should come with more rigor in assessing learning outcomes.</b> That is a more demanding role for instructional designers and instructors, not a diminished one.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="time-to-rethink-some-assumptions">Time to Rethink Some Assumptions</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I appreciate Weber&#39;s contribution and the broader OLC discussion. It is encouraging to see serious attention to combining synchronous and asynchronous learning while preserving flexibility. But I would encourage the instructional design community to go further and challenge some of the assumptions underlying its traditional approaches.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">AI is changing what is possible, and a priori design models that made sense when learning experiences had to be carefully scripted are increasingly limiting. We need to become more comfortable with emergent learning experiences, student agency, and adapting based on what students actually do and learn.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The opportunity is not to abandon instructional design but to rethink its emphasis. <b>Less time attempting to control every learning interaction, more attention to enabling meaningful experiences, and substantially more rigor in determining whether students have actually learned.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That&#39;s a version of learner-centered education worth pursuing.</p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>The main On EdTech newsletter is free to share in part or in whole. All we ask is attribution.</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Thanks for being a subscriber.</i></p></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=f0004821-418c-446a-93e7-5836bc3bf151&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>MoodleMoot Europe Conference Notes 2026</title>
  <description>Scott Anderberg&#39;s sovereignty argument deserves to shape more than Moodle&#39;s messaging</description>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 15 Oct 2026 00:59:07 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-15T00:59:07Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/d03d9e27-4cad-42c7-a9b6-bec78b49dcb0/OET-poweredby-logo2025.png?t=1757446904"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Martin Dougiamas no longer works at Moodle.</b> He remains chairman and a major shareholder, but his work on the future of education and AI is now independent of the company he founded.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Martin said this near the beginning of his keynote at MoodleMoot Europe in Barcelona last week. He left two months earlier, explaining that the research he wanted to pursue did not fit particularly well within Moodle HQ. Partner Avetica had already <a class="link" href="https://avetica.nl/moodle-tips/goodbye-from-martin/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">reported on his farewell</a>, but <b>this is a consequential change that has received remarkably little attention.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/big-changes-afoot-moodle?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Big Changes Afoot at Moodle</a> in 2023, I described Martin&#39;s planned move from CEO to Head of Research, exploring technologies that could inform Moodle&#39;s longer-term direction. Scott Anderberg subsequently became CEO. Martin told me he will continue to be part of the Moodle community.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Before getting into what this means for Moodle today, some recognition is in order. Along the lines of Matt Pittinsky’s <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/the-lms-at-30-from-cms-to-lms-at-last?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">The LMS at 30</a>, Martin belongs among the people who helped define the category. Moodle gave institutions around the world an LMS they could run, modify, and support through a community and network of providers. It made online learning infrastructure available in places and circumstances that commercial vendors often struggled to serve. <b>Many people built that software and community, but Martin&#39;s contribution to creating and sustaining it was enormous, and in my opinion, viable elearning infrastructure exists in a large portion of the world </b><i><b>because</b></i><b> of the Moodle vision.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Moodle HQ should have done a better job explaining this transition and acknowledging Martin&#39;s contribution. Leaving people to piece it together serves neither Martin nor the company particularly well.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The transition provides useful context for the conference itself. <b>Scott is coming into his own as CEO, and his keynote on sovereignty was the most strategically interesting part of the event.</b></p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="scott-and-the-sovereignty-opportuni">Scott and the sovereignty opportunity</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Sovereignty was everywhere at this conference. In quite a few conversations, it sounded like a new label for the open source arguments of the 2000s. We own the code. We can host it ourselves. We are not dependent on a proprietary vendor. All familiar, and all relevant, but repeating those points does not explain how an institution should respond to the changes happening now.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Scott&#39;s keynote went further. He traced how sovereignty evolved from the authority of monarchs to states, communities, and individuals, then brought the discussion down to a question people could use: <b>“Who gets to decide?”</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">For an institution choosing software, he organized that question around three decisions:</p><ul><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Who has rights to the software, including the ability to change it or take it away?</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">How is it delivered, and who provides that service?</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Where is the data held, and who can access it?</p></li></ul><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>The important extension was the ability to change those decisions.</b> An institution might choose a managed service today and another provider later. It might use one AI model and replace it when capabilities, costs, or terms change. It might decide that a previously acceptable dependency has become a problem. What practical options does it have then?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That gives Moodle a way to reach institutions that care about these choices without necessarily caring about the history of open source. In June I <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/put-ai-sovereignty-on-your-radar?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">argued that AI sovereignty was becoming an EdTech issue</a>, with an opportunity for vendors offering credible answers about dependence and continuity. Scott supplied a basis for Moodle to make that case.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/8032bbb0-778e-41fd-a75a-a60c6e2f22d7/3_pillars.jpg?t=1792022019"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Grok cleanup of conference photo</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Afterward, I told Scott that I did not think he realized how good, and potentially how important, his keynote was. Moodle has spent years trying to reconcile a community protective of its traditions with a company that needs to make harder product and business decisions. This sovereignty framing could be the lynchpin, but I am not convinced that Moodle HQ will build out a bold new vision.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Scott also challenged the idea that writing sovereignty policies necessarily produces sovereignty. Europe wants to avoid being beholden to American Big Tech companies, but it also loves policies and regulations über alles. Think of GDPR: cookie approvals that no one reads, horrible website experiences, and burdensome compliance for startups. The big risk is that Europe will take an important concept of sovereignty in the AI age and GDPR it.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="core-improvements-and-the-academic-">Core improvements and the academic product question</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Marie Achour, Moodle&#39;s Chief Product Officer, and her team deserve credit for continuing to address problems in the core product. The detailed Moodle 5.3 session and her keynote described useful changes, some already in the product and others further out on the roadmap.</p><ul><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Course navigation and presentation:</b> changes bring the course index closer to the content, improve movement between activities, and make the page easier to follow.</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Marking and learning outcomes:</b> phased work supports multiple markers, individual feedback, and combined results. Learning outcomes can be associated with activities.</p></li><li><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Course creation:</b> a prototype showed a simpler process with learning design and outcomes built into it, including assistance with drafting outcomes. This was a direction being explored, not a finished product announcement.</p></li></ul><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The new design system should also make it easier for Moodle and plugin developers to produce consistent experiences.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Marie framed the academic roadmap around “learning worth having.” Her argument was that AI makes producing a course easier, but does not ensure that it is a good course. Moodle should help educators design for learning, with better alignment and assessment. That is a reasonable response to the explosion of generated content.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The academic product vision, however, has become less clear since last year. In her <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/moodlemoot-global-conference-notes-2025?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">2025 conference coverage</a>, Morgan wrote:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Yes, Moodle is now breaking eggs and attempting a significant redesign of the platform, the governance, and the product offerings.</b></p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"> Glenda Morgan, September 2025 </figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">One of those proposed offerings was Moodle Higher Ed. But Marie did not mention it in her keynote this year, and offline she described HQ as rethinking the vision and effectively putting it on hold (my words, not hers).</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The product eggs are not getting broken.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Moodle Workplace makes this harder to understand. It demonstrates that Moodle can package its platform around a specific set of organizational needs and build a commercial product around them. Some higher education institutions already use Workplace, and the conference included changes intended to make that use easier. But the question about a compelling offering for academic, course-based learning remains.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="100-million-learner-paradox">100 Million Learner Paradox</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Moodle appears to be caught in what <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/open-edx-conference-notes-2025?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">I called</a> the “100 Million Learner Paradox” in last year&#39;s Open edX coverage. Moodle boasts over 500 million registered users, yet I continue to hear from institutions and partners about the difficulty of getting universities and training providers to adopt it. <i>How can a platform with such massive reach still struggle to find additional adoption?</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Nor is this just about winning new customers. UNSW Sydney is <a class="link" href="https://www.prnewswire.com/apac/news-releases/unsw-selects-d2l-for-institution-wide-learning-transformation-reaching-over-80-000-learners-302872793.html?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">moving from Moodle to D2L Brightspace</a> in a transformation covering more than 80,000 students. Deputy Vice-Chancellor Sarah Maddison described the situation UNSW faces.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Professor Sarah Maddison, Deputy Vice-Chancellor, Education and Student Experience, said the new platform would help ensure UNSW&#39;s learning environment keeps pace with the needs of students and educators.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">&quot;Our students are entering an increasingly complex world, shaped by rapid technological, professional and social change. Their learning environment needs to be ready for what comes next,&quot; said Professor Maddison.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"> Sarah Maddison, UNSW Sydney </figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">More specifically, UNSW needs:</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">“to create a more consistent, accessible and intuitive digital learning experience for our students, while giving our educators the flexibility and creativity to design and deliver outstanding teaching, now and into the future.&quot;</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is the transformation so many colleges and universities need. <b>I fear that Moodle is letting the dopamine hits of 500 million+ registered users keep it from seeing what is needed in today&#39;s academic markets.</b> Protecting the big base by avoiding the leading edge is a valid strategy. But UNSW is a reminder that the base does not necessarily stay put, and a higher ed facing existential challenges needs new levels of thinking from product companies.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="ai-and-the-moodle-roadmap">AI and the Moodle roadmap</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The distinction between Moodle LMS and Workplace also appeared in the AI discussion. AI will remain optional and delivered through integrations in Moodle LMS, while Workplace could incorporate more native functionality. Some Moodle installations operate with unreliable electricity and connectivity; requiring AI for core teaching and learning would undermine those uses.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The AI subsystem is adding support for developers&#39; own actions, richer conversations, and coordination of more complex AI activity. Choice of providers and visibility into AI use also matter for sovereignty.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But the talk stayed mostly within how to add and manage AI inside Moodle. I heard much less about how AI might change the experience of using Moodle, or what HQ wants partners to build beyond today&#39;s workflows. Keeping AI optional still leaves room for a university or partner to build a different experience on the platform. Is the subsystem helping them do that, or are they having to work around it?</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Martin&#39;s keynote explored how AI might change the learning experience. He discussed interfaces generated on demand and a learner-controlled coach connecting to institutional systems. Moodle could continue holding content, applying policies, and issuing credentials while learners interacted through their own software—the possibility I explored in <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/the-left-column-isnt-permanent?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">The Left Column Isn&#39;t Permanent</a>.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Parts of Martin&#39;s presentation struck me as utopian, but he was thinking about what the future might look like. Moodle’s product roadmap appears to assume that much of today&#39;s experience will continue.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Martin&#39;s research was originally supposed to inform Moodle&#39;s long-term roadmap. With him now working independently, who inside HQ is responsible for connecting that kind of experimentation to the product?</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="more-direction-in-the-partner-ecosy">More direction in the partner ecosystem</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>There was a part of the conference where HQ&#39;s willingness to make firmer choices was much clearer: certified integrations.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Standard certification, Plus, and Premium offer increasing visibility and closer commercial relationships, including co-selling at the Premium level. The program emphasizes accessibility, usability, and security audits, plus compatibility across Moodle upgrades.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">HQ is setting more explicit expectations for the tools operating within Moodle, then helping selected providers reach customers. That gives integration companies a reason to invest in the relationship beyond being compatible with the LMS.</p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/4bd86f0b-8d3e-4a2d-853e-b4e1df92684f/Certified.jpg?t=1792021337"/><div class="image__source"><span class="image__source_text"><p>Grok cleanup of conference photo</p></span></div></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The marketplace, launched in July to replace an aging directory, aims to make plugins easier to find, evaluate, and purchase. Marie described weekly improvements and faster responses to feedback. There was more urgency here.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Brightspace Apps and Canvas Apps show that other vendors are also putting more structure around their integrations. These moves can make third-party tools easier to adopt while increasing the platform company&#39;s influence over how they reach customers. The commercial implications deserve attention alongside the technical benefits.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>For Moodle, this is one way to make Scott&#39;s argument useful. An institution gets more value from choice when it can identify dependable tools and obtain support without assembling everything itself.</b> Certification can reduce that burden. The ability to change providers and tools still needs to remain practical as the commercial relationships become tighter.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="putting-it-all-together">Putting it all together</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In 2023, I <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/moodlemoot-global-23-conference-notes?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=moodlemoot-europe-conference-notes-2026" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">described Moodle becoming a product company</a> and set out things to watch: a more competitive academic course experience, stronger participation in institutional evaluations, and a new CEO who would sustain change.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This year&#39;s conference gave me more confidence in the CEO part of that argument. I also saw useful core improvements and a more assertive approach to the ecosystem.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Scott gave Moodle a reason to change without abandoning its values. Now HQ has to decide what that means for the academic product.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I will return to the wider European sovereignty discussion and AI resistance in a separate post.</p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>The main On EdTech newsletter is free to share in part or in whole. All we ask is attribution.</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Thanks for being a subscriber.</i></p></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=dd1d5398-ec8f-4baa-9ad1-d2ed033d72a0&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Interesting Reads This Week</title>
  <description>Institutions kidding themselves, a rising tide lifting six boats, and denominators behaving badly</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/7e63240d-00e7-40fe-9cfb-d1328596b9fd/Screenshot_2026-10-10_at_8.03.42_PM.png" length="1066034" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261010</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261010</guid>
  <pubDate>Sat, 10 Oct 2026 18:48:00 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-10T18:48:00Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Glenda Morgan</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Microcredentials]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Hei Finances]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Enrollment Analysis]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class='paywall'><div class='paywall__content'><h2 class='paywall__header'>Premium Content</h2><p class='paywall__description'>This content is reserved for premium subscribers of On EdTech+. To Access this and other great posts, consider upgrading to premium.</p><p class='paywall__links'><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Upgrade</a><span class="translation_missing" title="translation missing: en.templates.posts.rss.link_conjuction">Link Conjuction</span><a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Sign In</a></p><div class='paywall__upsell'><div class='paywall__upsell_header'><h3>A subscription gets you:</h3></div><ul class='paywall__upsell_features'><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'> New content 3-4 times per week </li><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'> Shared Q&A discussions </li><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'> More coming soon </li><li class='paywall__upsell_feature'></li></ul></div></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=88369bb5-60bc-4d83-a184-fef8a851db46&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>University of Maryland Report As Chatbot Product Research</title>
  <description>Lessons on the Virtual Study Assistant at the heart of the flawed report</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/238811cc-0a5a-4dbd-bcfa-c45e98098508/Screenshot_2026-10-09_at_8.19.15_AM.png" length="1063629" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/university-of-maryland-report-as-chatbot-product-research</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/university-of-maryland-report-as-chatbot-product-research</guid>
  <pubDate>Fri, 09 Oct 2026 15:17:04 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-09T15:17:04Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Lms Market]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Edtech Research]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Ai]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0668f4be-a68a-44a2-8ad9-ef042f83dc62/onedtechpluslogo-1200x630.png"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=university-of-maryland-report-as-chatbot-product-research" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=university-of-maryland-report-as-chatbot-product-research" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The flawed <a class="link" href="https://edworkingpapers.com/sites/default/files/ai26-1598.pdf?utm_campaign=an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring&utm_medium=referral&utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">University of Maryland report</a> that was <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=university-of-maryland-report-as-chatbot-product-research" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">not really about AI tutoring</a> could have had a more interesting approach if the researchers had stuck to their own advice.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The findings reported here thus concern the [GPT-4o–based virtual study assistant] VSA as configured and introduced in this study, rather than establishing the effects of more scaffolded AI tutoring.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">If you read the report as a study on AI tutoring (which was the title and assumption behind the study), one question that jumps out is how anyone in their right mind would design an AI tutor that by default gives direct answers to students—essentially a university-sanctioned tool to bypass the instructor’s teaching process. If you read the report as product research on UMD’s VSA, however, it looks completely different.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">What emerges is <b>a well-intentioned course assistant chatbot where substantial development and documentation did not translate into sustained adoption or instructional integration.</b> And it is not surprising that only 33 instructors signed up for the study, and just 15% of students in the treatment group even tried out the VSA.</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="what-vsa-is">What VSA Is</h2><div class="paywall"><hr class="paywall__break"/><div class="paywall__content"><h2 class="paywall__header"> Subscribe to Premium to read the rest. </h2><p class="paywall__description"> Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to the rest of this post. </p><p class="paywall__links"><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=university-of-maryland-report-as-chatbot-product-research">Upgrade</a> Translation missing: en.app.shared.conjuction.or <a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=university-of-maryland-report-as-chatbot-product-research">Sign In</a></p></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=985cdad0-9a3d-4887-8ff4-4b4ed9717ef4&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Introducing On EdTech+ Team</title>
  <description>A new method to centrally pay for a group, and to pay by invoice</description>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/introducing-on-edtech-plus-team</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/introducing-on-edtech-plus-team</guid>
  <pubDate>Thu, 08 Oct 2026 16:14:10 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-08T16:14:10Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Internal News]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0668f4be-a68a-44a2-8ad9-ef042f83dc62/onedtechpluslogo-1200x630.png"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=introducing-on-edtech-team" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=introducing-on-edtech-team" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Since the introduction of <i>On EdTech+</i> in 2022, there has only been one payment option—credit cards from individuals. One of the most common requests I have had is to allow for organizational purchases, to avoid cases where people have to expense their subscription with their college, university, or company. A second related request has been to allow payment by invoicing. The state of Virginia, for example, now requires registration with its payment portal and invoice processing for newsletter subscriptions. And a third related request has been to allow group sharing of paid newsletters.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Thanks to new capabilities in our newsletter platform (Beehiiv), we’re introducing <i><b>On EdTech+ Team</b></i> to make it easier for an institution or company to give those colleagues access—and manage the subscription through one invoice.</p><div class="paywall"><hr class="paywall__break"/><div class="paywall__content"><h2 class="paywall__header"> Subscribe to Premium to read the rest. </h2><p class="paywall__description"> Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to the rest of this post. </p><p class="paywall__links"><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=introducing-on-edtech-team">Upgrade</a> Translation missing: en.app.shared.conjuction.or <a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=introducing-on-edtech-team">Sign In</a></p></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=42b46dd1-82d5-40f3-b96c-592ead9e5bd6&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>An AI Tutor Study That Barely Tested Tutoring</title>
  <description>The University of Maryland study on AI tutors did not provide what the title claimed</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/e54538ce-99dd-4586-b173-de50b6656783/Screenshot_2026-10-07_at_6.35.59_PM.png" length="195552" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring</guid>
  <pubDate>Wed, 07 Oct 2026 18:56:29 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-07T18:56:29Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Glenda Morgan</dc:creator>
    <dc:creator>Phil Hill</dc:creator>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/d03d9e27-4cad-42c7-a9b6-bec78b49dcb0/OET-poweredby-logo2025.png?t=1757446904"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Sometimes a bad academic study is just a bad academic study, particularly when its title is misleading. We should be able to admit that.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In <a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261003?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">Saturday’s post</a> for premium subscribers, Morgan described just such a study that unfortunately is going to cloud an important topic—whether the use of course-specific AI tutors help or hurt learning, course grades, and course participation.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The study’s title sounds promising: <a class="link" href="https://edworkingpapers.com/sites/default/files/ai26-1598.pdf?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">“The Effects of Course-Integrated AI Tutoring on Student Performance and Engagement: A Randomized University Trial.”</a> And the report’s introduction touts its first-of-a-kind nature.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The current study presents findings from, to our knowledge, the first large-scale randomized experiment evaluating the effects of AI tutoring on student learning at a large U.S. public university.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">The problem is that the report does not produce what it promises. It does not directly measure course-integrated AI tutoring, and while it may have included randomization, the treatment group did not take the same drug (i.e., AI tutoring). There may have been some useful limited findings included, but those will be buried beneath the headlines.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Much of today’s post draws on Morgan’s post, but we want to share the core analysis with a broader audience since the research itself is getting disseminated through <a class="link" href="https://www.insidehighered.com/news/tech-innovation/artificial-intelligence/2026/10/07/maryland-ai-research-raised-more-questions?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">media coverage</a>. We also draw on <a class="link" href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/saguilar_ai-makes-learning-worse-for-university-students-share-7511101764172140544-qDAp/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_ios&rcm=ACoAAACP7lUB_yu0lQLIIy5dfywh6w4Nm8eNruY" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">a LinkedIn post</a> from USC professor Stephen Aguilar (partially for the entertainment value).</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="the-four-flaws">The Four Flaws</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">There are three claims worth unpacking here: effects, AI tutoring, and student performance and engagement.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">But first, what did they actually do? The paper explores the use of an AI-powered course-based chatbot, the Virtual Study Assistant (VSA), in a randomized controlled trial among 2,379 undergraduate students and 30 instructors across multiple disciplines at the University of Maryland. Instructors were randomly assigned to offer the tool or serve as controls within groups of identical or similar courses. The researchers also analyzed a smaller “exact match” sample restricted to sections of the same course.</span></p><h3 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="the-three-flaws">Effects: The treatment group largely did not use the AI tool</h3><p id="the-three-flaws" class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Let’s start with the effects part, as described in the paper’s abstract.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:15px;">Among sections of the same course, tutor access reduced final grades by 0.37 standard deviations and learning management system participation by 0.90 standard deviations. Participation declines were similarly large in the full sample [snip]</span></p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">That sounds consequential, but what, exactly, produced those effects? Only about 15% of students offered access ever used the tool—and only 13% in the same-course sample.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">Aguilar described this problem quite well [emphasis added].</span></p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Think of a drug trail, there&#39;s a placebo group who doesn&#39;t get the drug, and a treatment group who does.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In medical research the ENTIRE treatment group gets the drug.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>In this experiment only 15% of the treatment group used AI.</b></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>Yet, EVERYONE in the treatment arm got lower grades.</b> Not just the 15% who used AI. That&#39;s means the effect CANNOT be attributed to AI-tool use. You can&#39;t blame a thing that wasn&#39;t used for lower grades. That&#39;s like blaming a drug I didn&#39;t take for giving me a stomach ache.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">To be clear, the average of the entire treatment group showed lowered grades, which is different than saying that everyone did. But the key point on such low adoption causing interpretation problems remains.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">Nor did the typical user engage with the tool intensively throughout the semester. Among students who tried it, the average was approximately four sessions. About 40% had only one session, while a few heavy users pulled up the average. A session could contain multiple questions and responses, but this was hardly widespread, sustained use.</span></p><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/e54538ce-99dd-4586-b173-de50b6656783/Screenshot_2026-10-07_at_6.35.59_PM.png?t=1791390985"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;"><b>So how did an intervention that relatively few students used produce a substantial difference in average scores and recorded LMS participation? The authors offer possible explanations, rather than demonstrated mechanisms.</b></span><span style="font-size:16px;"> Offering the tool may have encouraged broader AI use. Its availability could have signaled that AI use was acceptable, changing students’ use of other tools that the researchers did not track. The intervention may have changed instructor practices. Treatment instructors received guides, tutorials, and weekly summaries of tool use. Those resources could have changed how they taught, supported students, or discussed AI.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">These possibilities matter because the intervention involved more than putting a chatbot in front of students. It also introduced information and signals that could affect instructors and students who never touched the tool.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;"><b>The study therefore leaves us with a consequential finding and an unresolved explanation. Offering this particular intervention reduced average course scores and recorded LMS participation in the same-course sample. Whether using the tutor caused those declines remains unanswered. That distinction becomes important when readers interpret the result as evidence that using an AI tutor harms learning, as many people seem to be doing.</b></span></p><h3 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="tutoring-not-the-same-thing-as-prov">Tutoring: Not the same thing as providing direct answers</h3><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">Second, what exactly was the “AI tutoring” being tested? The tool was a custom chatbot built on OpenAI technology that retrieved information from course materials in the LMS. </span><span style="font-size:16px;"><b>It had two modes: direct instruction and tutoring. The first supplied answers; the second could guide students step by step toward an answer. The tool default was configured for direct instruction, and only two instructors chose tutoring mode.</b></span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">Answering a course question is not, by itself, tutoring. Tutoring should attempt to find out what a learner understands, diagnose misunderstandings, and adapt explanations, hints, and practice accordingly. Some AI tutoring systems also maintain learner profiles across sessions, allowing that guidance to build on previous work. Putting course documents behind a chatbot does not automatically supply those capabilities.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">Of the requests made to the tool, 73.8% sought information, explanations, or solutions; 11.3% involved practice or test preparation; and 0.7% sought feedback on students’ own attempts. </span><span style="font-size:16px;"><b>The study therefore largely examined access to a course-integrated answer-giving assistant. And that “integration” really just meant technical LTI integration with the LMS, not integration into teaching methods. Yet “AI tutoring” gets top billing in the title. </b></span><span style="font-size:16px;">This is a shaky basis for presenting the results as evidence about tutoring. The findings deserve to be read as evidence about the assistant as configured, rather than generalized to more scaffolded AI tutoring.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">The report called out this challenge.</span></p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Overall, these findings suggest that instructors engaged with the VSA to some extent but did little to integrate it into their instruction, which may have contributed to the low student engagement described above.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Aguilar provided a useful reaction [emphasis added].</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Translation: We gave instructors limited support; to be honest we just turned the AI thing on and let instructors do whatever. Most of them stuck with business as usual.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><b>EdTech isn&#39;t like some learning grenade you toss into ignorance and when it explodes people learn. </b>EdTech was never a passive change-maker. EdTech is a tool, and how that tool is/isn&#39;t used is EVERYTHING.</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><h3 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="was-it-even-ai-tutoring">Performance and Engagement: Indirect at best</h3><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">Third, what did the researchers actually measure when they examined “student performance and engagement”?</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">For performance, the researchers looked at final course scores. Students offered the tool scored about three points lower out of 100 across the full sample, though the statistical evidence for that difference was weaker. When the comparison was limited to sections of the same course, the gap was about four points, with stronger statistical evidence that it reflected more than chance.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">A four-point drop deserves attention. But the study does not establish that using the AI tutor caused students to learn less. It shows that students in sections offered the tool earned lower course scores, while leaving unresolved what caused that difference.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">The engagement claim needs similar unpacking. The researchers measured recorded LMS participation, including assignment submissions, discussion responses, and quizzes. These are substantive course activities, not merely clicks. The count tells us that recorded participation fell. It does not tell us why, or whether, actual learning was affected.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">What students do in an LMS depends on what their courses ask them to do there. A discussion-heavy course, a course built around online quizzes, and a course where most work happens elsewhere will generate different activity counts. Comparing sections of the same course helps, but does not make those counts a complete measure of engagement.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">The study found fewer recorded LMS activities. That matters. What remains unclear is whether students disengaged from learning, shifted their work elsewhere, or responded to changes in teaching. The LMS can count activities. It cannot supply the missing course context, or explain what those activities meant.</span></p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="a-bad-study-clouding-important-ques">A Bad Study Clouding Important Questions</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">Our disappointment with this research is with the distance between what the title and some of the paper’s language promise about AI tutoring and what the study actually establishes. The authors acknowledge important limitations, but readers still have considerable translation to do. And we are already seeing the reaction, including posts titled </span><a class="link" href="https://www.theedadvocate.org/the-hidden-downside-ai-tutors-tanked-student-grades-heres-why/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><span style="font-size:16px;">“</span></a><a class="link" href="https://www.theedadvocate.org/the-hidden-downside-ai-tutors-tanked-student-grades-heres-why/?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=an-ai-tutor-study-that-barely-tested-tutoring" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">The Hidden Downside: AI Tutors Tanked Student Grades – Here’s Why.”</a></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;">There is nevertheless useful research here, and we wish the researchers had focused on that instead. Making a course-specific AI assistant available inside the LMS did not produce widespread or sustained use, and offering it did not improve the measured outcomes. In the same-course sample, average scores and recorded LMS participation were lower.</span></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="font-size:16px;"><b>That is a finding EdTech needs: availability is not adoption, and adoption is not evidence of better learning. What students do with a tool—and how instructors integrate it—requires attention.</b></span><span style="font-size:16px;"> We wish that useful contribution had received clearer billing, rather than leaving readers to disentangle it from broader claims about the effects of AI tutoring wrapped up in dense statistical and methodological jargon.</span></p><hr class="content_break"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>The main On EdTech newsletter is free to share in part or in whole. All we ask is attribution.</i></p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Thanks for being a subscriber.</i></p></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=4c969ae7-1336-42a3-b7a5-acaf5261ec9a&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

      <item>
  <title>Interesting Reads This Week</title>
  <description>What AI tutoring studies—and online enrollment numbers—actually tell us</description>
      <enclosure url="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/ede41754-e826-4f93-b897-cc36492ea5de/Screenshot_2026-10-03_at_11.27.45_AM.png" length="200480" type="image/png"/>
  <link>https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261003</link>
  <guid isPermaLink="true">https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/p/interesting-reads-this-week-20261003</guid>
  <pubDate>Sat, 03 Oct 2026 19:29:00 +0000</pubDate>
  <atom:published>2026-10-03T19:29:00Z</atom:published>
    <dc:creator>Glenda Morgan</dc:creator>
    <category><![CDATA[Edtech Research]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Online Education]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Enrollment Analysis]]></category>
    <category><![CDATA[Ai]]></category>
  <content:encoded><![CDATA[
    <div class='beehiiv'><style>
  .bh__table, .bh__table_header, .bh__table_cell { border: 1px solid #C0C0C0; }
  .bh__table_cell { padding: 5px; background-color: #FFFFFF; }
  .bh__table_cell p { color: #2D2D2D; font-family: 'Helvetica',Arial,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
  .bh__table_header { padding: 5px; background-color:#F1F1F1; }
  .bh__table_header p { color: #2A2A2A; font-family:'Trebuchet MS','Lucida Grande',Tahoma,sans-serif !important; overflow-wrap: break-word; }
</style><div class='beehiiv__body'><div class="image"><img alt="" class="image__image" style="" src="https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/0668f4be-a68a-44a2-8ad9-ef042f83dc62/onedtechpluslogo-1200x630.png"/></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><i>Was this forwarded to you by a friend? Sign up, and get your own copy of the news that matters sent to your inbox every week. </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/subscribe?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Sign up for the On EdTech newsletter</i></a><i>. Interested in additional analysis? </i><a class="link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow"><i>Upgrade to the On EdTech+ newsletter</i></a><i>.</i></p><hr class="content_break"><p id="how-can-it-seriously-be-october-and" class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">How can it seriously be October? And what did I read this week?</p><h2 class="heading" style="text-align:left;" id="ai-tutoring-a-useful-finding-under-">AI tutoring: a useful finding under an unhelpful label</h2><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Were you to pick up a research report titled “The Effects of Course-Integrated AI Tutoring on Student Performance and Engagement: A Randomized University Trial,” you might expect it to tell you about, well, the effects of course-integrated AI tutoring on student performance and engagement. In the case of a recent research <a class="link" href="https://edworkingpapers.com/sites/default/files/ai26-1598.pdf?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer nofollow">report</a> published in the Annenberg Institute’s working-paper series, you would be sorely disappointed.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">There are three claims worth unpacking here: effects, AI tutoring, and student performance and engagement.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">But first, what did they actually do? The paper explores the use of an AI-powered course-based chatbot, the Virtual Study Assistant (VSA), in a randomized controlled trial among 2,379 undergraduate students and 30 instructors across multiple disciplines at the University of Maryland. Instructors were randomly assigned to offer the tool or serve as controls within groups of identical or similar courses. The researchers also analyzed a smaller “exact match” sample restricted to sections of the same course.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Let’s start with the effects part, as described in the paper’s abstract.</p><div class="blockquote"><blockquote class="blockquote__quote"><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Among sections of the same course, tutor access reduced final grades by 0.37 standard deviations and learning management system participation by 0.90 standard deviations. Participation declines were similarly large in the full sample [snip]</p><figcaption class="blockquote__byline"></figcaption></blockquote></div><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">That sounds consequential, but what, exactly, produced those effects? Only about 15% of students offered access ever used the tool—and only 13% in the same-course sample.</p><p class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Randomization gives the researchers grounds to estimate the effect of offering the intervention. It does not establish the <b>effect</b> of using the tutor. The lower scores are an average difference between groups offered and not offered access. The randomized comparison does not isolate the causal effect of using the tool.</p><div class="paywall"><hr class="paywall__break"/><div class="paywall__content"><h2 class="paywall__header"> Subscribe to Premium to read the rest. </h2><p class="paywall__description"> Become a paying subscriber of Premium to get access to the rest of this post. </p><p class="paywall__links"><a class="paywall__upgrade_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/upgrade?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Upgrade</a> Translation missing: en.app.shared.conjuction.or <a class="paywall__login_link" href="https://onedtech.philhillaa.com/login?utm_source=onedtech.philhillaa.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=interesting-reads-this-week">Sign In</a></p></div></div></div><div class='beehiiv__footer'><br class='beehiiv__footer__break'><hr class='beehiiv__footer__line'><a target="_blank" class="beehiiv__footer_link" style="text-align: center;" href="https://www.beehiiv.com/powered-by?publication_logo=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.beehiiv.com%2Fcdn-cgi%2Fimage%2Ffit%3Dscale-down%2Cformat%3Dauto%2Conerror%3Dredirect%2Cquality%3D80%2Fuploads%2Fpublication%2Flogo%2F390281de-7b28-4b4b-9da7-0974c7db6094%2Fo-et800x800.png%3Fv%3D1794885874&publication_name=On+EdTech+Newsletter&utm_campaign=493421d7-46f0-47ed-8fb2-d7f69d7f1c5f&utm_medium=post_rss&utm_source=on_edtech_newsletter">Powered by beehiiv</a></div></div>
  ]]></content:encoded>
</item>

  </channel>
</rss>
