WEBVTT

1
00:00:00.100 --> 00:00:18.080
[upbeat music] Welcome back to Block Space Live presented by CleanSpark. There was news over the weekend. A lot of Iran chaos. That'll probably be a lot of what we talk about today, but we've got a nice little docket.

2
00:00:18.140 --> 00:00:32.400
We have our guest, Ryan Gentry, CEO of the Bitcoin Infrastructure Corp, and he's talking about machine payments, the hottest topic in AI and crypto. We're also talking about the MicroStrategy, a common stock raise.

3
00:00:32.460 --> 00:00:48.820
There's been crypto layoffs, and Marathon today is actually getting into AI. This is a fantastic e- fantastic episode. I'll toss to Colin. Yeah, the Marathon slipstream soft- enters the AI software development landscape.

4
00:00:48.880 --> 00:00:56.520
Yeah. But you're listening to Block Space Live. We go live every Monday, Wednesday and Friday at 9:00 A.M. PT, 12:00 P.M.

5
00:00:56.920 --> 00:01:06.600
ET, featuring quick hits on the latest in Bitcoin mining, AI, Bitcoin, a little bit of everything, segments, interviews with the brightest minds in Bitcoin and crypto.

6
00:01:07.080 --> 00:01:11.300
Uh, make sure to hit Subscribe if you're watching on YouTube, click the bell, and you'll get notified when we're live.

7
00:01:11.720 --> 00:01:20.400
This is also a podcast, so you can find it anywhere where you listen to your podcasts, on our RSS feed. If you like what you hear, you'll love our newsletter.

8
00:01:20.420 --> 00:01:32.500
We got a link in the show notes, and also we have a conference coming at y'all in about a month, less than a month in New York City, OpNext, Bitcoin's technical conference for investors.

9
00:01:32.540 --> 00:01:41.630
Head to opnext.dev for info and tickets. Get them quick before they go up. We'll see y'all April 16th at the Times Center. So things happened over the weekend.

10
00:01:41.940 --> 00:01:53.620
Trump tweeted, or maybe he truthed, and markets have been roiling since. Yeah. So this, this is what everyone is talking about this morning in terms of market news.

11
00:01:53.680 --> 00:02:09.560
So it's looking like Trump is saying that they are making progress for peace talks in Iran and saying that he is postponing strikes against Iran's power plants for five days, I'm quoting here from CNBC, citing what he said were, quote, "productive conversations with Tehran to end the war."

12
00:02:10.039 --> 00:02:20.040
Markets surged and oil prices dropped on the news. Tehran is saying, "There's no such thing as these peace talks. We are not actually anywhere close to resolving this conflict."

13
00:02:20.080 --> 00:02:32.940
Trump is just trying to buy time as global markets are thrown into turmoil on account of the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, which processes roughly 25% of the world's oil in terms of exports to the market.

14
00:02:33.350 --> 00:02:46.720
And with that closed, oil prices have surged. WTI and Brent surged to almost $120 a barrel a few weeks ago, but they are down today on this news, and markets are indeed loving it. We've gone risk on again.

15
00:02:46.840 --> 00:03:08.590
Bitcoin, which sagged over the weekend, has popped back above 70,000, touched 71, almost 72 this morning, and this is 100% as a result of this little liquidity bump here that resulted from Trump saying that, "You know, we might be, we might be getting close to an end to this, or at least pausing aggression for now."

16
00:03:08.660 --> 00:03:19.500
You can also look at other, you know, trad equities. S&P 500's up. I believe the NASDAQ is also up as well. NASDAQ's up. Let's see what the Dow is doing.

17
00:03:19.660 --> 00:03:32.910
It's a, it's a grand slam, all three of them going up, a- as well as Bitcoin. So overall, markets really do- Those are the markets. I mean, those are the markets. Gold, on the other hand- Gold is getting crushed...

18
00:03:32.920 --> 00:03:45.160
has absolutely pooped the bed. Gold back down to, I believe it's, like, October prices before... That was, like, right before the people started lining up for gold, you know, leading into Thanksgiving. But gold back,

19
00:03:46.100 --> 00:03:59.840
um- Yeah, it's back at prices we last saw in October, and you- just for context on this, this- it sold off pretty brutally in early hours this morning, and this follows a 10% decline last week.

20
00:03:59.900 --> 00:04:09.480
Now, that is nuclear for an asset like gold, and it, it touched $4,100 an ounce, and it, it's sprung back up to almost 4,500.

21
00:04:09.500 --> 00:04:16.160
But, you know, precious metals are starting to trade like shitcoins, and this is something we've talked about a little bit on the show.

22
00:04:16.180 --> 00:04:26.820
There's been so much volatility that it, you know, you're seeing thing- like, silver have these wild swings, too. I mean, silver looks even worse. [chuckles] It's down 22% over the last month.

23
00:04:26.900 --> 00:04:47.100
Sure, there are some Bitcoin and crypto diehards that are just relishing this because if you were on FinTwit or plugged into financial circles at the end of last year, everyone doing laps around Bitcoin and crypto investors because the boomer rocks ended up out- outperforming Bitcoin along with everything else.

24
00:04:47.560 --> 00:04:52.400
But right now- I mean, you say-... they're counter-trading everything else.

25
00:04:53.080 --> 00:05:02.060
You say precious metals are, uh, trading like shitcoins, and it's ironic 'cause, like, some shitcoins are trading like precious metals in that they're flat 'cause they can't go down anymore.

26
00:05:02.080 --> 00:05:09.250
But also, Bitcoin's, like, you know, done pretty well. It- is this, like, one of the first times we've seen Bitcoin go up and gold go down?

27
00:05:09.940 --> 00:05:18.960
Because maybe we can get an actual, like, decouple, you know, in recent memory- Right... because basically gold's had all of the, uh, attention on it as of late.

28
00:05:19.380 --> 00:05:27.700
Yeah, I mean, I'm sure we could go back and look at, uh, look at scenarios in which they are inversely correlated with each other.

29
00:05:27.740 --> 00:05:38.380
That being said, a lot of the traditional breakdowns or traditional correlations are kind of breaking down with a lot of these different asset classes. Yeah. A fun little chart I wanna show. This is an infographic.

30
00:05:38.480 --> 00:05:46.960
I believe Iran, over the weekend, you know, started, uh, puffing up their chest and saying, "We can shoot missiles." And they released, like, a list of targets, you know? Do you see that?

31
00:05:47.500 --> 00:05:57.700
And they- and so some people did the whole thing where you, like, you know, draw a circle around the map to see how far the country can shoot their missiles, and here you are.

32
00:05:57.740 --> 00:06:03.800
Here's, like, the, you know, the big circle, the high-level thing, and you can see if you're in northern Sweden or Norway, you're just out.

33
00:06:04.380 --> 00:06:17.196
The western side of Denmark is safe, whereas the eastern side of Denmark-Is, is supposedly vulnerable. Luxembourg, just between France and Germany, surprisingly just barely out of range of Iran.

34
00:06:17.256 --> 00:06:24.576
So- Like most of, most of Europe, which is really interesting. Yeah. But yeah, like you said, Charlie, this is all anyone can really talk about right now.

35
00:06:24.636 --> 00:06:35.556
And for our lead story today, before we get to, before we get Ryan up on the stage, I want to flag this that we just posted on Blockspace.

36
00:06:35.916 --> 00:06:42.116
Federal Reserve, quote, "hawkishness", end quote, not Iran to blame for weaker Bitcoin ETF inflows, says CoinShares.

37
00:06:42.396 --> 00:06:47.776
Says CoinShares animus-- a-analyst, James Butterfill, claiming that outflows last week stemmed from the U.S.

38
00:06:47.856 --> 00:06:56.196
Reserve newly hawkish stance and, and which was largely interpreted as a hawkish pause by investors and not investor fear around the current conflict between Israel, Iran, and U.S.

39
00:06:56.696 --> 00:06:59.796
This is kind of like, uh, you know, not to throw shade on, on, on James here.

40
00:07:00.106 --> 00:07:13.315
I get what he's saying, but to me it's almost like splitting hairs because I would say that the, the renewed hawkishness of the Fed is largely driven by inflation fears from the war in Iran because oil prices have absolutely surged, and I've got some charts to throw up for this.

41
00:07:13.396 --> 00:07:22.236
So let's just look at crude first. And to recap, the Fed met last week. FOMC said, "No more... No rate cuts today."

42
00:07:22.916 --> 00:07:30.696
And they also-- But the CME FedWatch tool is now pricing in zero rate cuts for the entirety of twenty twenty-six.

43
00:07:31.076 --> 00:07:40.976
Now, that is a big revision from the end of last year, where market participants were expecting maybe three, roughly around three throughout the course of the year.

44
00:07:40.996 --> 00:07:48.036
But now the Fed is signaling, you know, we're, we're probably not gonna cut at all. In fact, some people are actually worried that they might raise throughout the year.

45
00:07:48.056 --> 00:07:58.036
But just to give you an idea of why markets are kind of in turmoil, for those of you who haven't been watching these charts like hawks, this is when the Iran war broke out, the end of February.

46
00:07:58.556 --> 00:08:10.256
Oil has just absolutely surged since following the close of the Strait of Hormuz. This is WTI crude, so this is the, uh, West Texas index. This is what we use to track oil in the U.S.

47
00:08:10.676 --> 00:08:21.976
And it, it, it, it ta- it tapped a hundred on, on the daily. Believe it got up to as much as a hundred and twenty on Monday of one of these weeks in mid-March before sharply correcting afterwards.

48
00:08:22.376 --> 00:08:32.816
And then if we look at Brent, Brent's having it worse. You know, the, this, this is the benchmark for crude oil and particularly the European market. Obviously, they don't produce very much oil.

49
00:08:33.116 --> 00:08:42.036
There's a little bit of a premium. We have the luxury in the U.S. of consuming and pr- producing and consuming locally, so a little bit less of a shock to oil prices from where we're coming from.

50
00:08:42.436 --> 00:08:48.496
But it's the same picture. It's just up and to the right. Now, as a result, this has spiked inflation fears.

51
00:08:49.136 --> 00:09:02.035
And if we wanna look at where this is showing up, it's showing up in the bond market most of all, and this is from Adam Coby Essie terminal. If anyone wants to sponsor us for one, really appreciate it. Yeah, Bloomberg.

52
00:09:02.496 --> 00:09:07.756
[laughs] Bloomberg, give us a terminal, please. In a sudden turn of events, Adam posts here, "U.S.

53
00:09:07.856 --> 00:09:14.996
twelve-month inflation expectations have surged to five point two percent, the highest level since March twenty twenty-three. In just three weeks, markets have gone from pricing in rate cuts to rate hikes."

54
00:09:15.516 --> 00:09:21.236
What this is, this, this index right here basically looks at one year forward-looking inflation expectations.

55
00:09:21.246 --> 00:09:31.016
So what this chart is saying is that traders are pricing in the likelihood of five point two percent average inflation over the next twelve months. It's a big jump from where we are.

56
00:09:31.036 --> 00:09:44.696
Inflation has also been rising a little bit if we look at some of the benchmark surveys that the Fed looks at. So in February, CPI headline was point three percent month over month. Not crazy.

57
00:09:44.736 --> 00:09:53.816
Point two-- two point four percent year over year. But if you look at PPI, that's producer price inflation, so for manufacturers, producers, things like that.

58
00:09:53.845 --> 00:10:04.016
Headline PPI last-- in February was point seven percent month over month, which was much hotter than expected, and three point four percent year over year. So inflation is starting to rear its head again.

59
00:10:04.096 --> 00:10:08.976
People are worried it's going to get worse because of oil prices being elevated as a result of this war.

60
00:10:09.706 --> 00:10:19.636
And the last charts that I will pop up here before I shut up, if we look at the bond market, I'm gonna actually pull up this first.

61
00:10:19.996 --> 00:10:26.956
This is really where you're seeing, you know, these, these inflation expectations rear their head. This is the thirty-year.

62
00:10:27.076 --> 00:10:35.336
After the start of the war, between the start of the war and now, you've seen it move by thirty bips, which is a pretty aggressive move over the last month.

63
00:10:35.396 --> 00:10:38.916
You can look at the two-year, five-year, ten-year, all of them are moving up as a result.

64
00:10:39.416 --> 00:10:46.916
So this is the Fed's worst nightmare, or this is the Tre- Treasury's, rather, worst nightmare right now, and I guess the Fed, 'cause, you know, they're all kinda acting in concert.

65
00:10:46.956 --> 00:10:56.516
The, the interest rate on the long tail of these bonds is going up at a time when the Federal Reserve, or, or the, uh, U.S. government really wants to drive these rates down. We have thirty-five trillion in debt.

66
00:10:56.856 --> 00:11:07.896
We're starting to spend way too much of tax receipts on interest payments on that debt, and that as well. This, uh, I was tipped off of this chart courtesy of Jeff Park. Ooh, is this gonna fit? There we go.

67
00:11:08.226 --> 00:11:11.196
This is the MOVE index. This is basically like the VIX for the bond market.

68
00:11:11.256 --> 00:11:18.496
The VIX is a volatility index that looks at the wider market and looks at, you know, how volatile things are and gives a reading for volatility in real time.

69
00:11:18.516 --> 00:11:27.956
Well, the MOVE has just been blown out since, uh, the, the war kicked off. This is the five-day. If we look at the month, it's- it looks like all these other charts up and to the right, and we're above a hundred.

70
00:11:28.436 --> 00:11:34.196
And between like a hundred and a hundred and twenty on this reading is when things start to get, you know, people are getting skittish.

71
00:11:34.216 --> 00:11:44.516
We go above a hundred and twenty, that's extreme volatility, stuff that we saw in the COVID crash, during the, uh, during the Great Recession in two thousand seven, two thousand eight, uh, etc.

72
00:11:45.516 --> 00:11:57.186
So get a little market update on that, and this all has, you know, the reason we bring this up as it relates to Bitcoin is 'cause if you look back, particularly at, like, at yields on U.S. Treasuries, the last time U.S.

73
00:11:57.296 --> 00:12:08.036
Treasuries really had a sharp move up, um, that's comparable to what we have now, was twenty twenty-two when the Fed started hiking again. You know, the entire market was thrown into a tizzy as a result.

74
00:12:08.396 --> 00:12:15.576
Equities were down. Bitcoin was down that year. And you're starting to see rates move up pretty aggressively again.

75
00:12:16.076 --> 00:12:21.948
And so, uh-Depending on, you know, where the liquidity is actually flowing, it doesn't bode super well for Bitcoin.

76
00:12:21.988 --> 00:12:32.558
But yeah, I just-- I wanted to take a moment to address that comment from the Coinshares team, 'cause I get where they're coming from in the sense of like, it really is the Fed driving the, the ship right now.

77
00:12:33.088 --> 00:12:47.278
But the Fed is reacting largely to what's going on in Iran, and I think that's important context. Cool. Well, we're gonna bring up Ryan here in a second. But yeah, Bitcoin up, gold down, bonds, bond market in chaos.

78
00:12:47.278 --> 00:13:01.268
Bond rip. Well, bonds plummeting and yields ripping. Yeah. So trade accordingly. Not financial advice, but as it pertains to other types of money, we've got our boy, Ryan Gentry. Welcome back to Blockspace.

79
00:13:01.328 --> 00:13:03.788
Ryan, how you doing? I'm living the dream.

80
00:13:04.048 --> 00:13:14.848
Although this morning was bizarre because I checked prices and was depressed, and then I got a notification on my phone that all of a sudden Bitcoin is back over seventy K 'cause of the Trump tweet.

81
00:13:15.008 --> 00:13:24.418
Checked again and was like, "What happened?" So I don't know. I've been discombobulated since like moment one this morning. We're all discombobulated, man. E-every, y-you know, it's, I, I...

82
00:13:24.448 --> 00:13:35.878
This is the year for me of the schiz-schizophrenic market reactions where everyone, every day it seems like is going, it's so over, and then we're so back by the end of the day- Yeah...or the morning.

83
00:13:35.918 --> 00:13:44.208
Like within, within hours. [chuckles] Yeah, exactly. This was the, this was the fastest I've experienced. It was like woke up and was like, "Still poor. It's over."

84
00:13:44.358 --> 00:13:50.368
[chuckles] And then was like, "Oh my God, we're so back," like within the next fifteen minutes. [chuckles] Well, you just not, you just don't own the right assets.

85
00:13:50.448 --> 00:13:57.838
You need to own whatever the opposite of gold was the past couple months, and then- Right. Yeah. Okay. Bonds, money market accounts. Yeah.

86
00:13:57.868 --> 00:14:13.728
So, so we brought you on 'cause you a CEO of Bitcoin Infrastructure Corp, and but you've really kind of blown up over the past couple weeks as you've been tweeting about a thing which has really also captured the interest of Twitter here, which is payments, particularly machine payments,

87
00:14:14.628 --> 00:14:24.928
and you built a website, fourohtwoindex.io. And befo-be- just to explain what that is, I think maybe I would invite you to do a little recap.

88
00:14:24.948 --> 00:14:33.648
You did a history on like machine payments protocols thread a little while ago. Mm-hmm. Can you kinda reprise that for the audience here? Yeah, sure.

89
00:14:33.708 --> 00:14:40.668
So for those who don't know, you know, HTTP is the protocol that underwi- underpins all of the web, right?

90
00:14:40.688 --> 00:14:50.137
And so I'm, I'm certain that ninety-nine percent of your listeners at some point have seen an HTTP 402 error code, which means that like the website they were trying to visit is down.

91
00:14:50.828 --> 00:14:59.508
So there's a little-known error code that was included all the way back in the, in the mid-'90s, um, HTTP 402 payment required- Mm.

92
00:14:59.548 --> 00:15:08.988
That's been in there forever just waiting on internet digital currency in an internet-native- Mm. Payment network to leverage for that error code.

93
00:15:09.108 --> 00:15:23.028
So I got into crypto broadly in 2017 because I was working on Internet of Things type stuff at Intel. So that was kinda like my entry point. I was not like Austrian economics or, or any other reason for that.

94
00:15:23.168 --> 00:15:25.128
I just thought machine-to-machine payments were cool.

95
00:15:25.648 --> 00:15:36.868
So it turns out that all of a sudden now, like with these agents, it seems like machine-to-machine payments might really be having a moment, so I kinda have nerd sniped myself into getting back into this and, and tracking this.

96
00:15:37.278 --> 00:15:44.728
But the history, to your point is, so, you know, I got into crypto generally. I was working with Multicoin for a couple years, like looking, learning about all these protocols.

97
00:15:44.748 --> 00:15:53.188
And then I went to the very first Lightning Conference in 2019, the, you know, the LN Conf in Berlin, which is still the best conference I think I've ever been to.

98
00:15:53.768 --> 00:15:57.668
Um, you know, this year's coming up next aside, of course.

99
00:15:58.148 --> 00:16:13.808
But, um, uh, in-- at that conference, Roastbeef, the Lightning Labs CTO, who I worked with for the last five years very closely, he presented the protocol that is now known as 402 or L402, saying that, "Hey, we have

100
00:16:15.448 --> 00:16:18.288
a solution to this internet-native HTTP error code.

101
00:16:18.368 --> 00:16:29.338
We have a solution where you can put up a paywall on a specific resource, on a specific API, and force somebody before they access the resource to pay you over Lightning." And I thought that was amazing.

102
00:16:29.488 --> 00:16:36.968
I still think it's amazing. It is amazing. It is just a really cool thing, and it's kind of a niche thing for, you know, everyday non-developers.

103
00:16:37.568 --> 00:16:50.528
But developers who are used to having to put up rate limits and having to deal with all sorts of nonsense because they can't just simple resist native to the internet, they don't have a way to stop somebody to pay them before they request a resource, they get it immediately.

104
00:16:50.568 --> 00:17:02.588
Like, oh, a paid endpoint would be amazing. So Roastbeef, you know, came up with that idea in 2019, I believe, like the first like release of actual working software was either end of 2019, early 2020.

105
00:17:03.168 --> 00:17:14.148
It was obviously Lightning and Bitcoin specific. Then in 2025, Coinbase came up with kind of their own version called X402, which works on base and on like EVM chains generally.

106
00:17:14.168 --> 00:17:24.068
It, you know, Lightning L402 is peer-to-peer. It's locally verifiable. It has all the usual Bitcoin principles, you know, totally decentralized, all this sort of stuff.

107
00:17:24.228 --> 00:17:29.368
The X402 version, of course, has like a centralized facilitator run by Coinbase right in the middle.

108
00:17:29.688 --> 00:17:36.368
Although, you know, also there are other facilitators that exist now in the ecosystem, so it's like decentralizing according to market conditions.

109
00:17:36.948 --> 00:17:46.868
And then most recently, like last Wednesday, Stripe and their new blockchain, Tempo, they released their own standard, MPP, and so that had

110
00:17:47.808 --> 00:17:53.028
Lightning included from day one as a first-class citizen of the protocol, which is great.

111
00:17:53.368 --> 00:18:07.588
And so like, you know, for five years from 2020 to 2025, you know, kinda working and to help grow this L402 community, you know, having Stripe come in and work on this is great, and they have tons of distribution, right?

112
00:18:07.628 --> 00:18:11.748
They have tons of internet-native merchants. It's great that Lightning is included from day one.

113
00:18:11.828 --> 00:18:26.436
Lightning Labs actually on Friday also released an update to their own software, adding MPP suppo-Tuesday, I think, and I already had this 402 Index website built that I was really just using for kind of my own...

114
00:18:26.496 --> 00:18:29.126
I was just curious how things were growing and, and to be able to track it.

115
00:18:29.156 --> 00:18:40.016
It was kind of like my first little vibe coding foray, and so I was like, "Well, crap, I can add MPP support and be the first website on the internet to support this thing. I should ship it."

116
00:18:40.536 --> 00:18:50.876
And so I shipped it, and it seems like people liked it. I have the pending approval from the Council of the Crypto Balds. I got retweets from Jeremy Allaire and a nice comment from Brian Armstrong.

117
00:18:50.936 --> 00:19:04.136
So I got two very important Crypto Bald CEOs' approval so far, and I'm, I'm working on the rest very hard. Yeah. The- you've got the blessing of the balds for this project. So like the real kind of,

118
00:19:05.096 --> 00:19:19.756
the real crossing of streams here lately in these like payment protocols has been talking about machine payments. Less so it seems to me like humans initiating these payments. Like w- I don't know.

119
00:19:20.276 --> 00:19:30.016
D- is- does that change how we think about these protocols? I, you know... Explain to me like why people are so excited about machine payments in general.

120
00:19:30.116 --> 00:19:40.336
Um, I think it's mostly that the idea has been that, you know, who is a natural user of crypto for payments, like really?

121
00:19:40.516 --> 00:19:48.136
You know, like here in the West, a- and y- I have a couple of different answers to this, but like here in the US we have Venmo, right? Like we have Cash App.

122
00:19:48.176 --> 00:19:56.196
Like I don't, uh, candidly I don't have really many problems with payments on a day-to-day basis, right? Apple Pay works great. Tap to Pay is a good experience.

123
00:19:56.256 --> 00:20:06.736
Like, you know, I think a lot of the early people that were excited about payments in crypto were specifically mad at PayPal for like arbitrary censorship reasons, and they wanted like an uncensorable payment network.

124
00:20:07.126 --> 00:20:16.476
And that's, you know, I, I totally see the value in that for human rights purposes and stuff like that. But it's not like a real pain that like modern people living in the US with

125
00:20:18.556 --> 00:20:26.816
smartphones really encounter on a day-to-day basis, right? Working at Lightning Labs, like people who have a lot of pain with the existing payment networks are people in emerging markets, right?

126
00:20:26.876 --> 00:20:33.716
People in Latin America and, and Sub-Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia, like those networks are a lot -- They don't really have the benefits that we do.

127
00:20:33.756 --> 00:20:38.956
And so like a first-class, world-class payments network like Lightning Network really makes a lot of sense for them.

128
00:20:38.976 --> 00:20:47.956
But then kind of in thinking about, okay, what, who else is like not a, is the, is the existing payments system that we have not well designed for?

129
00:20:48.956 --> 00:21:01.726
The idea has always been machines, and the machines would be much, it would be much easier for them to just like spin up a private key and start sending payments without permission than like having a bank try and get a bank account for an AI agent, right?

130
00:21:01.726 --> 00:21:07.815
And so that's kinda always been the reason why people are excited. And the other thing is it's just, it's just fun. It's cool.

131
00:21:07.856 --> 00:21:20.296
Like I, I think it's cool and fun to give, you know, Claude Code a five dollar budget and have it like go pay a, send sats across the internet and go pay for internet, you know, any sort of resource, right?

132
00:21:20.396 --> 00:21:24.676
Pay for LLM compute, pay for some data, you know, pay for an analysis.

133
00:21:25.176 --> 00:21:38.656
And the other part of this that has been cool and nostalgic for me and has reminded me, I, I did the whole mid-curve thing and bought myself a Mac Mini, um, it reminds me of like the early, early days of, of Lightning when I had a Casa Node.

134
00:21:39.076 --> 00:21:45.816
And I was really excited about like the home server revolution of people, you know, having a home server.

135
00:21:45.916 --> 00:21:59.096
Uh, and so, you know, one thing that would be cool if you're running a home server that costs, you know, whatever, eight hundred bucks or something like that, is like being able to claw back a bit of that expense by, you know, monetizing some work that you have locally.

136
00:21:59.556 --> 00:22:09.756
And so whether it's like you're running a local hosted GPU and LLM, and you don't use it twenty-four/seven, but you think people on the internet might wanna use it, like I think that's a really interesting use case.

137
00:22:09.776 --> 00:22:17.336
You know, it's still like really early to this stuff, but, you know, people are doing a lot of selling data. People are trying to, you know, sell Oracle information.

138
00:22:17.396 --> 00:22:24.396
Like there's all sorts of stuff that people are trying, and I think it's just a fun blank canvas to experiment on. These tools are mature.

139
00:22:24.456 --> 00:22:36.936
The networks are finally mature to be able to support this, and there's a lot of energy and excitement behind it, and especially because, you know, everybody is pivoting to AI right now, and so I guess in a sense, I'm a little bit guilty of that.

140
00:22:37.356 --> 00:22:49.016
But, you know, at least I'm still sticking with Bitcoin payments and Lightning as a, as a core part of it. Yeah, as you said, it would be interesting to claw back some of the money you accidentally blew on that Mac Mini.

141
00:22:49.056 --> 00:22:52.076
Exactly. Okay. Okay, so there's all these payment standards.

142
00:22:52.136 --> 00:23:02.676
You say it kind of kicked off with L402, the Lightning one, then X402, Coinbase is one, MPP, which I guess is Stripe Tempos, and maybe a little bit of Lightspark, you know, spice in there.

143
00:23:03.256 --> 00:23:10.506
Are any-- Like is one of these differentiated that much? Are they all differentiated? Is this a winner-take-all proto- like payment protocol landscape?

144
00:23:10.506 --> 00:23:26.036
Like how should listeners think about these different standards over the coming years? [chuckles] I'm honestly... I don't think anybody knows. I think the answer pre-AI agents, pre-vibe coding,

145
00:23:27.116 --> 00:23:31.675
the answer would've been like it's all a network effects game. It's a winner-take-all market.

146
00:23:32.096 --> 00:23:45.196
Whoever, you know, whoever gets the highest value service providers to start, you know, demanding a certain type of protocol for payment, like everybody's gonna comply to that. Pfft, I, I really don't know anymore.

147
00:23:45.476 --> 00:23:50.046
I think, you know, it's, it could very well be possible that

148
00:23:51.116 --> 00:24:01.675
because software is now so cheap to generate and so cheap to generate, you know, compliant with the spec, that, you know, there are multiple protocols that win, and they don't have to all be aligned.

149
00:24:02.156 --> 00:24:12.276
It could be very possible that the one that is, you know, supports the broadest distribution of options is the one that wins.

150
00:24:12.556 --> 00:24:18.056
I honestly, like I don't think anybody knows, and I'm just kind of along for the ride tracking it at the moment.

151
00:24:18.176 --> 00:24:35.344
Um, I think like what I know currently and what I tweeted in kind of my original thread that was just interesting is that, you know, Lightning has, L402 has kind of the highest signal-to-noise ratio right now, and that like of the providers that are set up, the highest percentage areYou know, configured properly.

152
00:24:35.404 --> 00:24:38.704
Although it is, you know, like Base has the biggest ecosystem.

153
00:24:38.744 --> 00:24:46.004
They have something like fifteen thousand endpoints, but, you know, the vast majority are-- don't even work, which, you know, kinda checks out for the crypto community.

154
00:24:46.444 --> 00:24:54.684
And then MPP is like obviously brand new, but, you know, they have this Stripe, they have OpenAI and Anthropic endpoints on there. Like, they have some really big names.

155
00:24:55.204 --> 00:24:59.124
So I think kind of like breaking it down by that distribution is, is interesting.

156
00:24:59.564 --> 00:25:10.404
You know, anybody doing payments on the internet, it's gonna be really tough to compete with Stripe, which is why, you know, I'm really glad that Lightning is included as a first-class citizen right off the bat for them.

157
00:25:10.904 --> 00:25:20.924
Um, but you know, it's new. They have a new blockchain that they're using too, which is very hard to, you know... It's very hard to get a new blockchain, uh, to get users in the early days.

158
00:25:21.024 --> 00:25:27.584
It's like also kinda like a corporate chain. I think there's only like a couple of nodes backing it anyways. So, you know, we'll see.

159
00:25:27.664 --> 00:25:39.324
I think it's, it's a very interesting, exciting time, and I don't think anybody knows how it's all gonna end up, which is why it's one of the fun places to be playing in right now. Um, yeah.

160
00:25:39.484 --> 00:25:44.124
So Ryan, I know you gotta get, get going, so kind of a lightning question, pun intended one hundred percent.

161
00:25:44.544 --> 00:25:59.654
[chuckles] When I look at these AI agent payments and I think about the trajectory of Lightning up until this point, and I think about stable coins in conversation with that, I ha- I had to ask myself, unfortunately, a black-pilled question, which is why wouldn't we just be using stables for these agent payments?

162
00:26:00.204 --> 00:26:07.404
Can you give us the bull case for Bitcoin versus stables, and then maybe the bear case for why stables have an edge? Kinda just taking both sides of it.

163
00:26:08.364 --> 00:26:20.524
Well, I think the, the bull case really is that it's stables running on Lightning. That's what I actually think is gonna happen here. I think that certainly, again, like, you know, like I...

164
00:26:20.584 --> 00:26:26.264
A ton of people in the L402 space have submitted their endpoints to the 402 index with a price in sats,

165
00:26:27.284 --> 00:26:33.684
and I just display them in a price in USD, and just, like, every time I do render the webpage, I just auto-convert it.

166
00:26:34.744 --> 00:26:42.604
That's now, like, easy enough, and if all that stuff is done by an agent, like, you know, I think it's, it's pretty easy to automate.

167
00:26:42.844 --> 00:26:50.523
If you wanna receive Bitcoin, um, you know, you can quote in dollars and still receive Bitcoin under the hood, and that can still happen.

168
00:26:50.604 --> 00:27:03.484
But I certainly think that, you know, a lot of service providers, especially if you're paying for your server in dollars, you kinda are gonna want to be receiving the money that you're gonna use to pay for that server also in dollars, right?

169
00:27:03.584 --> 00:27:10.804
Just so you don't incur slippage and that, you know, it's, it's-- you don't have to deal with the volatility and stuff like that. So, you know, I think we'll see both.

170
00:27:11.184 --> 00:27:19.824
I think it also just really depends on what service do agents actually wanna pay for, which is really the big question, right? There's a ton of people that are putting this stuff up.

171
00:27:20.124 --> 00:27:36.484
I think Artemis had a really good article the other day that, like, there was this headline number that X402 was doing, like, twenty-four million bucks a month in volume, but then they deduped everything and took out all the wash trading and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, and they got down to, like, well, there's probably actually, like, one point six million dollars a month.

172
00:27:36.844 --> 00:27:39.404
Which is not nothing, but it's like, you know, that's, like, ten X smaller.

173
00:27:39.844 --> 00:27:54.664
So I think people are still trying to figure out what's worthwhile, what's worth doing, what do people care about, and if the use case, if the service provider that catches fire is demanding Bitcoin payments, then by golly, his customers are gonna be paying him in Bitcoin.

174
00:27:56.324 --> 00:28:07.064
Sounds awesome, Ryan. You got any more vibe coding projects on the horizon I should, I should watch out for? Or are you now in maintenance mode for an accidental- My-... viral? [chuckles] Yeah.

175
00:28:07.184 --> 00:28:12.384
My, my, my goal, I was hoping to be in maintenance mode. I'm actually more in, like, "Oh, crap, things are breaking and I have to fix them" mode.

176
00:28:12.924 --> 00:28:25.024
But I- my goal is to turn this, like, very tightly scoped little personal project, and I would like to, like, end-to-end automate the whole thing. So you're, you know, getting included in the registry.

177
00:28:25.144 --> 00:28:30.844
Already you have to, like, pass a health check and prove that your endpoint is properly configured and, and is-- has good uptime.

178
00:28:30.884 --> 00:28:40.364
Once you get in there, you can verify your domain, which allows you to then edit the listing securely, that you have to prove, you know, you own the domain before you can do any edits, so I don't have to manually edit.

179
00:28:40.764 --> 00:28:49.484
I'm continually health checking these endpoints to make sure they're up and, you know, have a couple more ideas to, you know, improve the verification of that.

180
00:28:49.504 --> 00:28:56.854
But what I would like to do is to have this, you know, be end-to-end automated, including kind of like the sales and marketing.

181
00:28:57.024 --> 00:29:05.034
I thought that seemed like a cool, fun project to do with all this new agentic tools that exist. So we'll see how far I get with that.

182
00:29:05.224 --> 00:29:10.224
I, I definitely still have some more work to do and did not expect it to get this popular this fast.

183
00:29:10.664 --> 00:29:23.624
But it's been fun, and I think, you know, the community building around it is having a good time and, and we'll see where it goes. Thank you, Ryan, CEO of Bitcoin Infrastructure Group and vibe coder behind 402index.io.

184
00:29:23.824 --> 00:29:31.684
Ryan, we'll catch you later. Thanks for coming on the show. All right. Thanks. I love the idea of it depends on what the AI agent is doing.

185
00:29:31.944 --> 00:29:37.614
My-- of course, my mind immediately went to, ah, yes, for fulfilling my Amazon purchases, you'll use stables. But when- [chuckles]...

186
00:29:37.724 --> 00:29:47.344
when I need to up the MDMA from the dark web, that's when we start using Bitcoin on Lightning and Monero. Um- Yeah. Just kidding. Just kidding. Allegedly, that doesn't happen.

187
00:29:47.364 --> 00:29:58.464
[chuckles] Look, so, so we got, we got more stories. We've got, we've got crypto layoffs, we got Marathon AI, but before that, a word from our sponsor, CleanSpark. [gentle music] We are CleanSpark,

188
00:29:59.364 --> 00:30:15.424
America's Bitcoin miner, a publicly traded company with the largest operating hash rate, powered entirely by self-operated infrastructure across four states. This is our proof of work.

189
00:30:16.304 --> 00:30:25.124
We are setting the standard for what's next. Learn more about the intersection of energy and Bitcoin at cleanspark.com.

190
00:30:27.764 --> 00:30:42.240
Agentic payments, actually a really good segue into our next story, which is that AI is coming for all of your jobs, including those of you in crypto who thought you would be safe.Because you bought into a generational Ponzi scheme.

191
00:30:42.280 --> 00:30:57.520
Crypto firms cut hundreds of jobs in weeks, blaming weak markets, strong AI. CoinDesk, this is an article that CoinDesk put out today, this morning at six forty-two AM, and the layoffs are starting to stack up.

192
00:30:57.580 --> 00:31:03.240
Now, it's still pretty mild compared to the last bear market, and we'll get into those numbers in a second.

193
00:31:03.260 --> 00:31:20.780
But adding to Block, which laid off forty percent of its workforce a few weeks ago, some four thousand employees, and hired a few of them back, by the way, we have Algorand, Gemini, Crypto.com, OP Labs, Pip Labs, and Messari, who have all cut staff in recent weeks.

194
00:31:21.360 --> 00:31:27.480
Special shout out to Messari. Wonder if this [chuckles] I wonder if someone at CoinDesk has an axe to grind against Messari.

195
00:31:27.860 --> 00:31:37.980
Messari has now laid off staff three times since twenty-twenty-three, shrinking from a target of a thousand analysts to roughly a hundred and forty employees today. Yes, pretty rough.

196
00:31:38.080 --> 00:31:43.680
And then we'll just go over a few of the numbers here, rifle through the casualty list really quickly.

197
00:31:45.140 --> 00:31:58.680
Al-Algorand, which I, I don't even know how some of these, you know, altcoin companies are still around at this point in twenty twenty-six. But anyway, Algorand fired twenty-five percent of less than two hundred staff.

198
00:31:59.520 --> 00:32:11.000
Gemini has fired two hundred staff, roughly twenty-five percent of their workforce, which is pretty crazy. Um, and let's see.

199
00:32:11.060 --> 00:32:23.900
Crypto.com firing a hundred and eighty, about twelve percent, and Block axing, as we said, forty percent, roughly four thousand people. Messari did not give a number for how many people they laid off. Now, some,

200
00:32:25.520 --> 00:32:35.160
some backward-looking stats to contextualize this. So if we look at the twenty twenty-two job market, according to data,

201
00:32:36.960 --> 00:32:45.080
twenty-six thousand jobs over twenty twenty-two, a tally that took months to become apparent, CoinDesk says here, of course.

202
00:32:45.140 --> 00:32:57.180
Right now, the numbers that they have from the most recent batch is four hundred and fifty from the new ones. If we add Block onto that, it's almost forty-five hundred. So pretty sizable chunk.

203
00:32:57.220 --> 00:33:07.540
Of course, Block is not only a crypto company, there's a caveat there. They also operate the Square point-of-sale terminal. They operate Cash App, which does have a Bitcoin buying option.

204
00:33:07.820 --> 00:33:18.680
You can also buy stocks and money on it, so it's kind of a neobank, neofinancial services platform. But regardless, some of those people were definitely involved in crypto initiatives, so there's some overlap there.

205
00:33:18.730 --> 00:33:24.030
It's hard to say how much should actually be included in the crypto job total, though, for that, from what we know.

206
00:33:24.680 --> 00:33:32.120
But all of these companies basically cited weak market conditions and AI for these job cuts, saying, "We're trying to get ahead of the ball here.

207
00:33:32.180 --> 00:33:41.540
If we can use AI tools to automate the job of two or three people, we're, we're gonna do that." And that was the same thing Jack Dorsey said during the Block layoffs, so.

208
00:33:41.600 --> 00:33:51.480
Yeah, it's interesting because we haven't, as far as I can tell, we haven't seen this ex- this type of layoff trend hit tech broadly yet. It's more appears to be like a hiring freeze.

209
00:33:52.040 --> 00:33:59.680
So in like all ty- in all like, in all things like crypto, we tend to be a harbinger of maybe what's to come.

210
00:33:59.740 --> 00:34:08.660
I'll also note, like, yes, this is a trend across multiple companies, Algorand, Gemini, Crypto.com, OP Labs, et cetera, et cetera.

211
00:34:08.760 --> 00:34:22.940
But just the Block numbers alone, if we're talking like gross, like layoffs, Block accounts for more than all of the other ones that you've referenced combined. Just for like scale of- Yeah, you- Of layoffs...

212
00:34:23.000 --> 00:34:34.140
you, you could ten-x it and it would-- You'd have to ten-x it to get- Yeah... to, to have it be comparable or more than. And I-- it, it's interesting what you said about the tech sector broadly.

213
00:34:35.060 --> 00:34:46.500
We have started seeing in financial services and some other sectors, these headlines of mass layoffs. Like Charlie said, tech so far has been somewhat insulated.

214
00:34:46.520 --> 00:34:56.400
But your comment, Charlie, actually echoes something that Powell brought up in his conference last week following the Federal Open Market Committee's decision on interest rates.

215
00:34:56.479 --> 00:35:00.729
He basically said, "The job market is not great right now,"

216
00:35:01.740 --> 00:35:12.940
i.e., hiring has stagnated, but the mass layoffs that you would ex- see in a recession haven't quite come yet, and the labor market is not so dire that you're seeing layoffs left and right.

217
00:35:13.360 --> 00:35:26.360
They're starting to creep in, but there's no crazy cascading effect right now. That being said, just to highlight some of those numbers, because they really are not stellar. Bureau of Labor Statistics

218
00:35:27.500 --> 00:35:40.020
revised their December number down to seventeen non-farm payrolls lost. The January number was a hundred and twenty-six non-farm payrolls. A hundred and twenty-six thousand, excuse me. That was revised.

219
00:35:40.460 --> 00:35:50.800
Seemed like a pretty strong start to the year, although if you go back to twenty twenty-four and twenty twenty-three and even some of twenty twenty-five, the number is a little bit muted from what it has been.

220
00:35:51.740 --> 00:36:06.660
And then for February, a horrible job reading. Ninety-two thousand non-farm payrolls lost. Average hourly earnings up three point eight percent year over year. A few just kind of, you know, some color to this.

221
00:36:07.100 --> 00:36:14.070
Part of the reason why the job numbers suck right now is there has been a culling of jobs in the federal bureaucracy.

222
00:36:14.540 --> 00:36:25.090
If you actually look at the latter end of the Biden years, the majority of the job growth came from the public sector. So, you know, there's a side of you that says, "Well, are those jobs actually benefiting the economy?

223
00:36:25.180 --> 00:36:31.120
Are they actually adding productivity to the economy? Is it raising GDP in a way that is meaningful for people?"

224
00:36:31.880 --> 00:36:44.800
So when you take all of that away, and then you also have this incredible AI deflationary pressure, you get a recipe for obviously jobs starting to decline or at least the job market to go stale for a little while.

225
00:36:44.840 --> 00:36:54.448
And-Yeah, go ahead, Charlie. Well, I'll say, you know, you can paint this picture and, you know, February looks pretty bleak, down ninety-two thousand, uh, non-farm payroll jobs.

226
00:36:54.528 --> 00:37:03.488
But I'll say, Colin, you know, these days we revise numbers every month- [chuckles]... you know, going forward. So, like, who knows what it could be.

227
00:37:03.888 --> 00:37:09.508
I'm told that, you know, if we just keep revising, we can keep mashing the numbers to make it look better and better and better.

228
00:37:10.128 --> 00:37:16.388
So never count your job numbers until they hatch is kinda what this particular trend of this administration has taught me.

229
00:37:17.128 --> 00:37:30.348
You know, and also I think just in general with the way that these bureaucrats crunch these numbers, I, I have tracked these numbers for a few ye- a, a year or so now o- on the weekends when I'm just looking at market data.

230
00:37:30.358 --> 00:37:39.248
And to your point, Charlie, it's revised every single time. And often it's not revised like a little bit, like the delta is a few percentage points. It's hugely revised. Sometimes it goes from add... Yeah.

231
00:37:39.488 --> 00:37:47.818
It'll go from, like, fifty thousand jobs added to, like, the seventeen thousand jobs lost like we saw in December. Yeah. I don't know what the original number for December was, but it was more...

232
00:37:47.848 --> 00:37:55.548
It was an, it was a positive swing instead of the negative one we got on the revisions. That's why s- some private reports, like from the ADP, sometimes can be better.

233
00:37:55.608 --> 00:38:07.038
The ADP re-reported forty-one thousand private sector jobs in December, twenty-two in January, and sixty-three in February. Now, granted, those are just private sector. They're not looking at public sector jobs.

234
00:38:07.308 --> 00:38:16.378
But you can even see there that there's a huge discrepancy between what you're getting from the government report and from the ADP. And the, the last little bit that I'll say on this,

235
00:38:17.588 --> 00:38:27.808
looking at the crypto industry specifically, we're kinda getting hit from both sides right now because you have the fact that Bitcoin's down not quite fifty percent from its all-time high.

236
00:38:27.868 --> 00:38:36.398
It was in, in early February, but it's down significantly from its all-time high. You know, it hit like a hundred and twenty-five, hundred and twenty-six thousand in October last year.

237
00:38:36.508 --> 00:38:38.428
Now it's at roughly seventy thousand.

238
00:38:38.508 --> 00:38:50.968
And you have AI, which is going to be incredibly deflationary for the labor market, as Portland Hoddle covered on last Friday's live stream, especially for the software engineering industry, which is the core of a lot of these crypto companies.

239
00:38:51.528 --> 00:39:02.768
So- Could get messy. [chuckles] Could get messy. Let's get a coin rips from here. Could get messy- Yeah... for the rest of the year. Let's move on to the next one. This is also one you're gonna lead.

240
00:39:02.828 --> 00:39:13.778
MicroStrategy, twenty-one billion of something. I would like to see, you know, an im- the impossible challenge of MicroStrategy releasing a non-meme number of something.

241
00:39:14.388 --> 00:39:18.858
I don't-- I think the day, the day that happens is the day that Strategy sells all of its Bitcoin- [chuckles]...

242
00:39:18.928 --> 00:39:31.098
or the sky falls through the Earth because a lot of their marketing and a lot of the even buttoned-up financial, you know, engineering that they conduct is memetic. Like y- Yeah...

243
00:39:31.237 --> 00:39:34.288
like you just said, like they've got the twenty-one million in here.

244
00:39:34.328 --> 00:39:42.208
But for the headline- Well, they had the whole presentation where he's like, "In twenty-one years, the-- something, you know, the Bitcoin's gonna be the something or other." I don't know.

245
00:39:42.348 --> 00:39:49.908
I've, I've- If I can find the presentation too, I, I'll try to pull it up when you're giving color on this. There's one where they had like a rocket ship. [chuckles] Yeah.

246
00:39:49.948 --> 00:39:53.248
It lit- it was literally a spaceship, and it showed the

247
00:39:54.248 --> 00:40:04.588
flow of funds from fundraising into Bitcoin and the kind of financial flywheel for all of these preferred stocks, uh, that Strategy has in relation to their common stock.

248
00:40:05.108 --> 00:40:13.568
Anyway, this headline coming at y'all from Blockspace, "Saylor's Strategy Launches Twenty-one Billion Common Stock and Twenty-one Billion Preferred Stock Offerings."

249
00:40:14.108 --> 00:40:26.768
So Strategy has filed to authorize forty-four point one billion in new at-the-market equity offerings through its Strategy, its MSTR common stock, and the Stretch preferred equity.

250
00:40:26.808 --> 00:40:35.568
So the Stretches are these preferred stocks which pay dividends. That-- Strategy's got five of them at this point. Stretch is the most popular, I believe.

251
00:40:37.808 --> 00:40:51.648
But this would, this would, this a- at-the-market offering would be for twenty-one billion in common stock for either of those, plus two point one billion for its Strike, which is another one of the preferred shares that it offers.

252
00:40:51.688 --> 00:41:01.707
To put this into context, uh, because th- this is just a staggering number, right? I mean... And for, for those of you who don't know how these at-the-market offerings work, they're not gonna sell all this in one go.

253
00:41:02.168 --> 00:41:15.708
This is basically a way for them to ha- open offer to sell their stock on the market for, for, for big institutional players, uh, like investment banks, people who are going to market make, right?

254
00:41:16.228 --> 00:41:23.128
So this allows the big institutions to come in and buy stock from Strategy at a on-the-go basis whenever they want to, right?

255
00:41:23.568 --> 00:41:34.428
So it's not like they're gonna sell twenty-one billion in one go, but they're going to keep it open for people to keep buying into as long as there's interest. And to just give you an idea about what this means, the--

256
00:41:35.468 --> 00:41:56.088
right now, Strategy has, I believe, let's see right here, they've got six point two four billion remaining under a current stock offering for its common stock MSTR, and they have sold nine point six one billion under the current, uh, under the current, uh, at-the-market offering that they have open.

257
00:41:57.108 --> 00:42:02.918
For the Strike preferred share, um, they are going to try to decrease shares. They're gonna try to shrink the pie.

258
00:42:03.358 --> 00:42:14.148
But for Stretch, they are in- authorizing a share increase from seventy point four million to two hundred and eighty-two point six million shares, which is a massive increase.

259
00:42:14.188 --> 00:42:20.968
The way that these preferreds work is they're trying to target a specific share price and pay a dividend on top of that.

260
00:42:20.988 --> 00:42:34.388
And so I would be really curious, I would love to have someone on on the next show or two to talk about what this means in terms of the balancing act that Strategy has to, has to execute for all of these different financial instruments.

261
00:42:35.078 --> 00:42:37.438
'Cause they, they have to pay dividends on these things.

262
00:42:37.488 --> 00:42:45.808
This has been one of the criticisms against Strategy is that they don't have an income-generating business that can match the obligations for these preferred shares.

263
00:42:46.068 --> 00:42:52.148
So the only way to continue to furnish the dividends for these shares is to fundraise.

264
00:42:52.508 --> 00:43:01.768
And for Strategy, considering how big of a company it is, that typically means dilution, selling shares on the open market to get more cash in. But the MSTR, the...

265
00:43:01.868 --> 00:43:10.048
I haven't run the numbers for what that m- would mean for its float, but the MSTR ATM is going to be incredibly dilutive for its stock as well.

266
00:43:10.128 --> 00:43:21.644
And one last little note here, Charlie, then I'll kick it to you.This is kind of a twofer because just to give you an idea of who's buying Bitcoin right now, it's basically only strategy. [chuckles] Yeah.

267
00:43:22.074 --> 00:43:31.424
But, uh, my friend from Coindesk, James Van Straten, posted this over the weekend. Strategy set for second-biggest Bitcoin buying quarter despite BTC price slide.

268
00:43:32.044 --> 00:43:40.004
First quarter purchases for strategy this year have reached eighty-nine thousand six hundred and eighteen Bitcoin. It's actually a little bit higher now because they purchased some, I believe...

269
00:43:40.024 --> 00:43:52.063
Or they disclosed that they purchased some last week. This is the most since Q4, twenty twenty-four. You can see the chart here. It's cut off at the bottom, but this big candle right here is Q4, twenty twenty-four.

270
00:43:52.144 --> 00:44:03.204
We are on pace. We are already the second, uh, this is the second m- most buying activity for Strategy ever on record, and that is in BTC terms. This is not in dollar terms.

271
00:44:03.284 --> 00:44:08.304
This is Bitcoin terms, which I think makes this kind of even more wild, honestly.

272
00:44:08.324 --> 00:44:20.544
It just goes to show you how much, how much sway Strategy has in the market and how much funding they can still raise from selling their stock on the open market. But I thought that was pretty incredible.

273
00:44:20.624 --> 00:44:30.474
I mean, Strategy is still just plowing money into Bitcoin. Yeah. I don't have too much to add on this, but I will bring up an interesting thing to contextualize the scale of this buying.

274
00:44:31.184 --> 00:44:43.134
So the twenty-one billion common stock ATM plus twenty-one billion stretch plus two point one billion strike, STRK, adds up to forty-four point one billion in potential new capital.

275
00:44:43.144 --> 00:44:50.604
To put that in perspective, that is more than the entire market cap of most S&P five hundred companies.

276
00:44:51.284 --> 00:45:08.004
Just for like scale of like how much money they're yeeting into their, their, the, the, the wild and wacky universe of MicroStrategy Bitcoin financial engineering. So. I really like that, uh, context. I mean- Yeah...

277
00:45:08.124 --> 00:45:20.004
I think Matt Kimmel on one of our roundups when we were still doing that format, once commented with the fundraisers for the AI pivots and expansions, that we've kind of gotten numb to these massive numbers.

278
00:45:25.624 --> 00:45:33.294
This is a crap ton of money. And again, they're probably not going to be able to tap all of that. On a long enough timeframe, maybe they could.

279
00:45:33.324 --> 00:45:40.204
If Bitcoin ripped, they just-- they, they would probably be able to do it more easily. They definitely would be able to do it more easily. But that [chuckles] is just a lot of money.

280
00:45:40.324 --> 00:45:49.213
And there's something about me that when I see this, it just kinda makes me a little sad, but we won't, we, we won't, [chuckles] we won't pluck that thread. This isn't therapy. I won't call an ambulance.

281
00:45:49.213 --> 00:45:53.024
I, I mean, if you want to put it into context, remember two thousand and eight and the financial crisis?

282
00:45:53.344 --> 00:46:04.544
By quickly pulling up the numbers, you know, the, the total like TARP authorization and like a lot-- the numbers of like how much money we like used, we greenlit to save the economy was like under a trillion.

283
00:46:04.614 --> 00:46:18.384
So it was like s- maybe like seven hundred billion dollars. So like it's wild now that just a few years later, now we're just doing that, but in Bitcoin, it really highlights inflation.

284
00:46:18.504 --> 00:46:32.284
So Saylor's been dead on about that. I think we move on to the next topic. Yes- Um. But before that, we need to do- Before that... a quick shout-out to our friends at Lygos. Hedge funds are getting liquidated.

285
00:46:32.344 --> 00:46:45.064
People are panicking. Is your Bitcoin safe? It's not just Bitcoin's price drying up, whales, hedge funds, and lending desks are going under after the notorious October tenth and February fifth liquidations.

286
00:46:45.104 --> 00:46:55.084
Counterparty risk is rampant, so it's more important than ever to understand who actually controls your Bitcoin. And with Lygos, you are always in control of your Bitcoin.

287
00:46:55.504 --> 00:47:02.704
If you're working with another loan provider, do yourself a favor before it's too late and check out Lygos Finance. It's our preferred Bitcoin lending service.

288
00:47:03.024 --> 00:47:14.344
It's non-custodial, and they use Bitcoin native smart contracts to help you protect your stack. With Lygos, you always know where your Bitcoin is. Hold your keys, no wrapping, no bridging, no rehypothecation.

289
00:47:14.424 --> 00:47:29.724
Get competitive rates for as low as ten percent APR. Go to lygos.finance to learn more. All right. So for this next story, this was a

290
00:47:31.364 --> 00:47:45.204
Blockspace-led piece coming to you from over the weekend, just in. The title goes, Mara launches cloud.mara.com with wrapper for OpenAI-compatible API.

291
00:47:45.364 --> 00:47:55.214
Quote, "Mara Cloud is an enterprise AI inference platform that gives you access to state-of-the-art language models through an OpenAI-compatible API." Okay. Um. Sorry. Yeah.

292
00:47:55.214 --> 00:48:06.144
Just imagine going back in time and talking to, like, your- One year ago... sister, brother, grandparents, and just tell-- and just sen-- s- like speaking that sentence to them. They would shoot you. Yeah.

293
00:48:06.174 --> 00:48:16.724
They'd think you were possessed by a demon. [chuckles] Well, you've been reading them Isaac Asimov pieces. I mean, that's kind of how it would feel. Journey through the center of the Earth? No.

294
00:48:16.844 --> 00:48:27.664
We're building data centers over the entire Earth. But I mean, go back one year and think about Mar- Marathon's statements about, well, I don't think we're gonna get into AI. Maybe it was a year ago. I forget.

295
00:48:27.964 --> 00:48:33.024
It was not that long ago. Yeah, it was about a year ago where I believe it was actually on the twenty twenty-four earnings call.

296
00:48:33.044 --> 00:48:43.734
It could've been one of the quarterly earnings calls, but Fred Thiel kind of skirted the question, but he said, "We're not really looking into getting into Bit- into AI data, data center workloads.

297
00:48:43.804 --> 00:48:52.804
We might look at inference, but most likely we're gonna try to, like, balance load at these sites." Quickly pivoted from that, though. So- So Charlie, what is, what is, what does this mean?

298
00:48:52.884 --> 00:48:55.984
What does this even- I think maybe what is it?

299
00:48:56.084 --> 00:49:24.028
So for those of you who don't live and breathe the world of agents and AI, and maybe you talk a little bit to ChatGPT to ask for recipes like a good American, the rest of us schizos are deep in the weeds of how to, like, use AI and optimize everything in our lives, buying Mac Minis and, uh, and whatso.But there are the-- So basically there's a bunch of different AI models.

300
00:49:24.088 --> 00:49:35.628
A lot of them are proprietary and private. Your Anthropics, your OpenAI's, and your Google's have those like frontier models. They're the best and smartest ones. And then there's open source ones.

301
00:49:36.208 --> 00:49:49.448
And there are these platforms now that kind of are almost like dashboard to let you use any of these models that you want. Um, one of the popular ones that I'm familiar with is called OpenRouter.

302
00:49:49.608 --> 00:49:59.968
It's, uh, pretty popular. So Marathon launched their own dashboard, and they have three of these AI models that you can choose from.

303
00:50:00.148 --> 00:50:07.488
They are three open source models, so not the proprietary ones from Anthropic or, or OpenAI. And this is cloudmar.com.

304
00:50:08.368 --> 00:50:19.908
What this is, is, you know, in AI you have kind of basically two types of like compute that's nee- that need to be run. There's the training of the models, the creating of them, and then there's the running of them.

305
00:50:20.008 --> 00:50:32.428
So like when you're actually talking back and forth to these models. This is the inference, the running of those models. So Marathon is opening up a portal or a platform cloud to inference models.

306
00:50:32.448 --> 00:50:43.908
So you can choose between like DeepSeek V3, the Chinese open source. I think that's a Chinese open source one, GP- and a, a GPT open source model. And so you can do these, and it costs money.

307
00:50:43.948 --> 00:50:57.928
They've got API endpoints you can pay for. So the thing is, so that's what it is. I got some takes, some spicy takes here. You're muted. I'm specifically curious about the cost, Charlie, 'cause you were mentioning- Yeah.

308
00:50:58.108 --> 00:51:09.208
Okay... something interesting about that. So here's, here's the thing. I, I've dug a li- I've dug a little bit into the cost, and I'm still digging into it 'cause this is kind of a new story. Um, why?

309
00:51:09.288 --> 00:51:20.248
These-- this platform is multiples more expensive by what I can see compared to all of the other options. Like it's, it's-- the pricing is pretty terrible.

310
00:51:20.288 --> 00:51:32.168
In fact, it looks like it's four times the price of-- the median price of other services like Oh Together AI or Fireworks or OpenRouter. And I'm kind-- I kind of, you know, why?

311
00:51:32.228 --> 00:51:40.488
Is it, you know, you know, is that just 'cause it's a new feature and they're gonna optimize it? Maybe it costs them more to run inference. I don't really know.

312
00:51:40.908 --> 00:51:53.008
They do give you a five dollar credit for signing up, but that credit gets used up pretty quickly as like calls are like, you know, in the, in the field of like a dollar or so, whereas if you were to go into other platforms it's like thirty cents.

313
00:51:54.088 --> 00:52:07.168
So if we were to compare across the ecosystem, this is like one of the worst priced cloud like inference platforms that I can see. I, I want to, you know, dive deeper and verify this.

314
00:52:07.288 --> 00:52:14.008
Um, and I do just kinda wonder, like I haven't even bothered...

315
00:52:14.018 --> 00:52:25.688
I signed up for an account on this cloud, this Mara cloud platform, and I do kind of wonder because like if it's actually that useful compared to me just using OpenRouter, you know. Um- Yeah.

316
00:52:25.728 --> 00:52:33.688
I'd be really curious to see what differentiates one of these aggregators, right? It-- would it be the speed at which queries are processed?

317
00:52:33.757 --> 00:52:43.848
Is the interface just cleaner, easier to organize all of the different chats that you're having? I would say no. I haven't played with it, but- This interface is, is not a-- this interface is not as clean.

318
00:52:44.068 --> 00:52:49.368
I think I actually missed a little bit of p- of important context here for maybe the listener who's not dialed into AI.

319
00:52:51.668 --> 00:53:02.308
Uh, you can run inference on somebody else's server, like you talk to ChatGPT, and the compute happens, you know, in a data center far away from you. You can also run these models locally.

320
00:53:02.648 --> 00:53:14.168
So basically what you're doing whenever you buy that ChatGPT subscription or Claude, you know, API credits, you're basically paying to use on someone else's server. You can run some of these locally.

321
00:53:14.588 --> 00:53:19.368
So like I run some local models here, and it's-- they're free. And so like,

322
00:53:21.028 --> 00:53:34.428
you know, this is like a big looming question for the industry, which is, will-- like is there actually a significant value, a long-term value in providing inference for like the majority of these, of this like type of compute?

323
00:53:34.938 --> 00:53:46.188
Like, will these models get so efficient and so capable that the average user can run them locally and not really wanna pay for like the expensive like usage from these platforms?

324
00:53:46.628 --> 00:53:53.568
This is a big open question I think has deep implications for like the future of CapEx spend for AI.

325
00:53:53.648 --> 00:54:08.688
Maybe it, you know, I think it's a little more clear that training the models, like they have to be created, they have to be summoned and grown into existence, but then like actually running them, like is there like a long-term moat there for the majority of AI use?

326
00:54:08.768 --> 00:54:18.648
I-- Who knows? So this, these are like the loom- these are like the big questions that nobody really knows. Maybe it's path dependent, maybe it's inevitable. Heck if I know. So, um, the...

327
00:54:19.348 --> 00:54:32.848
It's funny 'cause that in an age of like y- y- you have PowerShells, PowerShell models for these miners, you have neo cloud models for the miner- miners, um, is it really that smart to try to then also be the platform for these models?

328
00:54:32.988 --> 00:54:45.828
Yeah. I mean, that's what I was gonna cl- that's what I was gonna close with. That's the really up in the air question about this for me. And if we look at Mara's product history, they often veer off into these strange,

329
00:54:47.168 --> 00:54:55.648
I guess we'd call them side projects. Some might call them distractions. I love the side projects. I love their side projects. They're super fun. Well, the thing is- I wish more people did them...

330
00:54:55.668 --> 00:55:04.378
some of them are legitimately cool, like Slipstream, right? Was a transaction accelerator. It allows you to go straight to Mara. Mara runs their own mining pool, right? MaraPool. Yeah.

331
00:55:04.378 --> 00:55:10.768
So they have a massive Bitcoin mining operation. So it's, it's over fifty exahashes at this point.

332
00:55:10.808 --> 00:55:18.228
They have their own mining pool that they u- so they're really a self-miner, but- And they're pushing- They run a mining pool... they're pushing quantum research and quantum solutions- Yeah... which is really cool.

333
00:55:18.288 --> 00:55:21.268
It's kind of their kinda lab side. Yeah. They, they do.

334
00:55:21.568 --> 00:55:36.688
A- and so they do a lot of these-These projects that are adjacent to their core business, Bitcoin mining, and soon to be, you know, AI and traditional data center operations, but that aren't necessarily maybe the smartest thing to do rather than just focusing on that core business.

335
00:55:36.768 --> 00:55:47.928
Because Slipstream, as far as I know, it gets very little use, very cool, but there's not much revenue in trying to get people to pay for direct inclusion into a block. They also had- Well, it isn't awful lot either.

336
00:55:47.988 --> 00:55:55.748
It's very profitable, I will emphasize that. It's very profitable, but it's the profit compared to- Sure, but it's a small piece of the pie. Because of the pie. Yeah. Yeah. You know what I mean?

337
00:55:56.588 --> 00:56:04.708
Th-th-this is a company that does hundreds of millions in revenue, right? Yeah. And so maybe a few million or so here and there from something like that might not move the needle so much.

338
00:56:04.728 --> 00:56:16.888
They also had this, uh, th- they had this, this immersion technology called Tupic that they, I believe, shelved and abandoned, supposed to be a way to run immersion-cooled Bitcoin mining infrastructure more easily.

339
00:56:17.488 --> 00:56:26.968
So I, I, I kind of just am with you, Charlie, echoing what you said. Is it really the play for them to be getting into services, software services for AI?

340
00:56:27.008 --> 00:56:36.288
Or should they really just be doubling down, trying to figure out how to get contracts for hosting ma- hosting GPUs or becoming NeoCloud themselves? We- we'll see.

341
00:56:36.388 --> 00:56:42.588
A kind of a strange product, but in line with stuff they've done in the past. So enough about that.

342
00:56:42.728 --> 00:56:49.588
We'd love to have someone who came up with a-- whose AI, AI strategy at Mar or other types of these companies come on the pod. We love to cover this subject.

343
00:56:49.628 --> 00:56:53.908
Otherwise, this is wrapping up the show for the day, I believe.

344
00:56:54.228 --> 00:57:14.948
Make sure if you're listening and you haven't already liked and subscribed, hit that notification bell on YouTube and newsletter.blockchainmedia, newsletter.blockchainmedia.com if you wanna get our newsletter, and it's still not too late to grab that ticket and book that flight to New York for Up Next, April 16th, our Bitcoin technical conference.

345
00:57:16.788 --> 00:57:22.088
Thank you all for tuning in. We'll see you on Wednesday at the same time and Friday. Really looking forward to Friday's show.

346
00:57:22.148 --> 00:57:28.288
We've got Matt Williams from Luxor coming on, going to be talking about hash rate, financial markets, and GPU financing.

347
00:57:28.328 --> 00:57:43.828
And we've also got Astrid Gnaut, CEO of Hut 8, on to talk about some of their AI initiatives for twenty twenty-six. And with that, we will see y'all next time. Have a beautiful week, everyone. [outro music]